Yes, your insurance generally does increase after a claim, but the size of the increase depends on who was at fault, what type of claim you filed, and how much the insurer paid out. An at-fault accident can push a car insurance premium up by roughly 30 to 45 percent, while a comprehensive claim for hail or theft may barely move it. The jump shows up at renewal, not immediately, and typically stays on your policy for three to five years.
How Much Rates Go Up by Claim Type
Not every claim carries the same weight. Insurers treat at-fault accidents far more seriously than losses outside your control, and larger payouts generally produce larger surcharges.
- At-fault accident with bodily injury: roughly 30 to 45 percent above your previous premium, the steepest category.
- At-fault accident with property damage only: typically around 25 to 35 percent, scaling with the size of the payout.
- Comprehensive claim such as theft, hail, or an animal strike: usually around 3 percent on average, because the loss doesn’t reflect your driving.
- Not-at-fault accident: many states bar insurers from raising rates in this situation; in states without that protection, a modest increase is still possible.
For many drivers, an at-fault accident adds roughly $1,000 or more per year in premium costs, though individual results vary with your insurer, location, driving history, and the size of the payout. Part of that jump is a direct surcharge, and part comes from losing a claim-free or good-driver discount, which on its own can add 5 to 20 percent.
When the Increase Hits and How Long It Lasts
You won’t see a mid-policy rate hike just because you filed a claim. Auto policies renew every six or twelve months, and the new premium takes effect at the next renewal. The adjustment appears on your renewal notice.
Once the surcharge is on your policy, it typically stays for three to five years. Some carriers apply surcharges for 36 months; others extend them longer for serious at-fault accidents. The incident may remain on your motor vehicle record or claims history for longer, but the insurer’s ability to charge extra for it usually expires within that window.
When the period ends, your rate should drop. That doesn’t always happen automatically. Check each renewal notice to see whether the surcharge has come off, and if it hasn’t, call your insurer and ask for a review.
When Filing Isn’t Worth It
One of the most useful decisions you can make is whether to file at all. If the repair cost is close to or below your deductible, filing accomplishes little: you’d pay most of the bill anyway and still risk a rate increase. A $300 windshield repair rarely justifies a claim on a $500 deductible.
Even when damage exceeds the deductible, think about the gap. With a $1,000 deductible and a $1,400 repair, the insurer pays you $400, but your rate could rise $500 or more a year for the next three to five years. Paying out of pocket saves money in that scenario. Reserve claims for losses that are genuinely too expensive to absorb yourself.
Watch the Line Between an Inquiry and a Claim
Before you call your insurer to report damage, know that the conversation itself can have consequences. An inquiry is a call to discuss coverage or ask what a hypothetical payout might look like. A claim is a formal request for the insurer to investigate and pay for a loss.
The line can blur. If you describe a specific incident in enough detail, some insurers may open a claim file even when you didn’t ask them to. That claim can then appear on your insurance history report and affect your rates even if the insurer pays nothing. Industry guidance tells insurers not to report mere inquiries, but mistakes happen. When you call, say explicitly that you’re asking a question and are not filing a claim unless you decide to move forward.
Your Claim History Follows You
A claim doesn’t stay with just one insurer. LexisNexis operates the Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange, known as a C.L.U.E. report, which tracks up to seven years of auto and home insurance claims across all carriers. When you apply for a new policy or your current one comes up for renewal, insurers pull this report.
Switching insurers after a claim won’t erase it. The new carrier will see it and factor it into your quote. Different insurers weigh claims differently, though, so shopping around can still produce real savings; one company may surcharge an incident heavily while another treats it leniently.
Federal law gives you the right to a free copy of your C.L.U.E. report and to dispute inaccurate information in it. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, consumer reporting agencies, including LexisNexis, must investigate disputes for free and correct errors they confirm.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 U.S. Code 1681i – Procedure in Case of Disputed Accuracy The same law bars reporting agencies from including adverse information more than seven years old, which is why C.L.U.E. data drops off after that period.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 U.S. Code 1681c – Requirements Relating to Information Contained in Consumer Reports You can request your report directly from LexisNexis.3Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. LexisNexis C.L.U.E. and Telematics OnDemand
State Protections and Accident Forgiveness
State laws vary in how much they restrict insurers from raising rates after a claim. Several states prohibit increases based solely on an accident where you were not at fault. Some go further, requiring that all rate changes be filed publicly with the state insurance department and justified based on factors like driving record and miles driven. Other states give insurers broader discretion to adjust premiums after any payout, regardless of fault. If you believe an increase after a not-at-fault claim is unfair, contact your state’s department of insurance to find out what the rules are and how to file a complaint.
Accident forgiveness is a separate protection you buy or earn from your insurer. It’s an endorsement that prevents a first at-fault accident from triggering a surcharge, and it must already be on your policy before the accident; you can’t add it afterward. Eligibility usually requires a clean driving record for all drivers on the policy, and often a minimum number of years with the same insurer. Some carriers include it free once you qualify; others charge a monthly fee.
One important limit: accident forgiveness doesn’t transfer. If your current insurer forgives an accident and you later switch, the new carrier can factor that accident back into your rate. Your original insurer simply agreed not to use it; the accident itself is not erased from your record.
How to Bring Your Rate Back Down
Shop Around
You can switch insurance companies even while a claim is still open. Your previous insurer remains responsible for resolving the open claim under the old policy, so you don’t lose that coverage. Because carriers use different pricing algorithms, the same accident can produce very different surcharges from one to the next. Getting quotes from several insurers is the single most effective step for cutting a post-claim premium.
Take a Defensive Driving Course
Many states require or encourage insurers to offer a discount to drivers who finish an approved defensive driving or accident prevention course. Discounts typically run 5 to 10 percent off your base premium and last three years before you need to retake the course. That can offset part or all of a surcharge. Your state’s motor vehicle department can point you to approved courses.
Raise Your Deductible
A higher deductible lowers your base premium. Moving from $500 to $1,000, for instance, can reduce your premium enough to absorb some of a surcharge. Only do it if you can afford the higher out-of-pocket cost on the next loss.
If the Insurer Won’t Renew
Beyond raising rates, an insurer can also decide not to renew your policy. Non-renewal is different from cancellation. An insurer generally can’t cancel mid-term except for specific reasons like nonpayment. But when the policy reaches its expiration date, the carrier can choose not to offer another term.
State laws typically require advance written notice of non-renewal, often 30 to 60 days before expiration, along with a reason. Multiple claims in a short period, especially at-fault accidents, are a common trigger. If you get a non-renewal notice, start shopping right away to avoid a gap. Drivers who can’t find standard coverage may need a policy through their state’s assigned-risk pool or a specialty high-risk insurer, both of which cost more.