Being hit by another driver does not automatically raise your premium, but the answer to whether insurance goes up if you’re hit and not at fault is: it can, depending on where you file the claim, what state you live in, and which discounts your policy is built on. A formal at-fault surcharge usually will not apply to you. A quiet loss of your claims-free discount often will. The difference between those two outcomes is largely under your control.
File With the At-Fault Driver’s Insurer When You Can
The single biggest decision after the accident is whose insurance pays for your repairs. If liability is clear and the other driver is insured, filing directly against their liability policy keeps the loss off your personal claims history. The claim is recorded against their policy, not yours.
Filing through your own collision coverage usually gets your car repaired faster, especially when the other insurer is slow to accept responsibility. The trade-off is real. You pay your deductible up front. A claim appears on your record that other insurers can see when you shop around or when your current insurer reviews your account at renewal. If you can wait for the at-fault driver’s insurer to handle repairs directly, you avoid both.
Sometimes you have no choice. If the other driver is uninsured, has fled the scene, or disputes fault, filing under your own coverage may be your only practical route. In those cases the protections below carry more weight.
What a Non-Fault Finding Protects You From
Insurers assign a percentage of fault to each driver using police reports, witness statements, photos, and citations. A driver found to carry the majority of the fault — generally 51 percent or more — faces a surcharge at the next renewal. A driver assigned little or no fault is classified as non-fault and is typically shielded from that surcharge.
Shielded from the surcharge is not the same as shielded from every rate change. Non-fault drivers can still see their bill rise through other mechanisms, and the most common one has nothing to do with fault at all.
The Hidden Increase: Losing Your Claims-Free Discount
Many drivers see their bill climb after a non-fault accident even though no surcharge appears on the policy. The usual reason is the loss of a claims-free or safe-driver discount. Most major insurers offer discounts of roughly 20 to 25 percent for drivers who maintain a record with no filed claims over a set period, often three to five years. Report any accident under your own policy, including one where you had no fault, and that qualifying period can reset. The discount disappears.
Legally, removing a discount is not the same as raising a rate in most states. Your insurer can accurately say your base rate did not change while the discount that had been keeping your bill low is gone. On your monthly statement the two feel identical. This distinction matters because state laws that ban surcharges for non-fault accidents often do not stop an insurer from adjusting voluntary discounts.
Check your declarations page before you decide how to file. If a claims-free or good-driver credit is listed there, you are benefiting from something that could be removed after any claim, fault or no fault.
Your Claim Stays Visible for Seven Years
Every claim filed under your own policy is reported to the Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange, usually called a CLUE report. The database is maintained by LexisNexis and is available to any insurer you apply to. Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, adverse information can remain on a consumer report for up to seven years.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 U.S. Code 1681c – Requirements Relating to Information Contained in Consumer Reports
A non-fault entry on your CLUE report does show you were not responsible, and most insurers weight that differently than an at-fault claim. Some companies still read any claims activity as a mild risk signal. When you shop for a new policy, a quote might come in slightly higher than it would for a driver with no claims at all. You can request a free copy of your own CLUE report once a year from LexisNexis to check it for accuracy.
States That Ban Rate Hikes After Non-Fault Accidents
Several states have laws that prohibit insurers from raising your premium, canceling your policy, or assigning driving-record points after a collision you did not cause. The exact wording varies. Some states draw the line at the driver being less than 51 percent responsible; others use broader “not at fault” language. The shared principle is that a driver should not pay more because someone else caused the accident.
In states with these protections, the law overrides whatever internal surcharge policy your insurer uses. If your rate goes up anyway, you have grounds to file a complaint with the state insurance regulator. Not every state has one of these laws, so drivers elsewhere lean more heavily on insurer policy and the other strategies covered here.
Getting Your Deductible Back Through Subrogation
If you do file under your own collision coverage, you pay the deductible up front. Your insurer then pursues the at-fault driver’s insurer to recover what it paid out, including your deductible. That recovery process is called subrogation, and it happens largely in the background.
Full recovery returns 100 percent of your deductible. Partial recovery returns a proportional share: if your insurer recovers 65 percent of the total claim, you get 65 percent of your deductible back. Any legal or recovery costs are typically split proportionally. The process commonly takes around six months, longer if the other insurer disputes liability or drags its feet.
Your insurer is required to tell you whether it plans to pursue subrogation. If it declines, you can pursue the at-fault driver’s insurer yourself for the deductible. One serious caution: do not sign a release or settlement with the other driver that waives your insurer’s subrogation rights without talking to your insurer first. Signing a waiver of subrogation ends the insurer’s ability to recover on your behalf and can close off your path to getting the deductible back.
Accident Forgiveness as Prevention
Accident forgiveness is an optional add-on that prevents your insurer from raising your rate after your first qualifying accident. It typically runs between $15 and $60 a year. The endorsement is a contractual promise that one eligible incident will not trigger a surcharge or discount removal. Depending on the insurer, that protection may apply regardless of fault or only to at-fault accidents, so read the endorsement language before you buy.
Most insurers limit forgiveness to one incident every three to five years. Eligibility usually requires a clean driving record for several consecutive years before you can add it, and you cannot buy it after an accident has already happened. It is a proactive tool, not a reactive one.
Forgiveness also does not travel. If you switch companies, the new insurer will see the claim on your CLUE report and price your policy accordingly, regardless of what your old insurer agreed to forgive.
If You Live in a No-Fault State
About a dozen states use a no-fault insurance system, which requires every driver to carry personal injury protection (PIP) coverage. Your own PIP policy pays for your medical expenses and lost wages after an accident regardless of who caused it. Because PIP is designed to be used by every injured party, filing a PIP claim generally should not raise your rate. Most no-fault state laws treat PIP claims as non-fault incidents for rating purposes.
Property damage in no-fault states is usually still handled under traditional fault rules. If the other driver caused the collision, you can still pursue their liability insurer for your vehicle repairs, or file under your own collision coverage with the trade-offs covered earlier.
What to Do If Your Rate Goes Up Anyway
Start by asking your insurer for a written explanation of the change. Request that the explanation state whether the increase is a surcharge or a discount removal, and which rating factors changed. That documentation is the foundation for anything that follows.
If the response is unsatisfactory and you believe the increase violates your state’s law, file a complaint with your state’s department of insurance. Every state has a consumer complaint process, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners maintains a directory linking to each state’s filing system.2NAIC. How to File a Complaint and Research Complaints Against Insurance Carriers Before you file, gather your declarations page, the insurer’s written explanation, the police report showing you were not at fault, and any correspondence about the claim. A well-documented complaint gives the regulator what it needs to decide whether the insurer broke state law.