Whether insurance covers IVF for gay couples depends on three things: the state you live in, whether your plan is fully insured or self-funded by your employer, and whether you’re a lesbian couple or a gay male couple needing a surrogate. A small group of states now requires insurers to cover fertility treatment on equal terms regardless of sexual orientation, a 2025 class-action settlement will force Aetna to do the same for 2.8 million LGBTQ+ members nationwide, and a growing number of employers offer fertility benefits that bypass the traditional insurance system entirely. Everywhere else, coverage is limited or effectively unavailable because of how insurers define “infertility.”
Why Most Policies Still Exclude Same-Sex Couples
The core problem is the clinical definition of infertility that insurers have used for decades: the inability to conceive after 12 months of regular, unprotected heterosexual intercourse. A same-sex couple cannot meet that standard by definition, because the act it requires is irrelevant to their situation.
The practical effect is that many plans force women without male partners to first pay out of pocket for six to 12 cycles of intrauterine insemination with donor sperm just to earn an infertility diagnosis that would trigger IVF benefits. Gay male couples face an even harder wall, because many plans exclude any fertility services provided to or by a third party, which rules out egg donation and gestational carriers.
In October 2023, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine formally expanded its definition of infertility to include anyone who needs medical intervention to conceive, regardless of relationship status or sexual orientation, and said the definition should not be used to “deny or delay treatment to any individual.”1Stateline. Few States Cover Fertility Treatment for Same-Sex Couples, but That Could Be Changing Insurers and state laws have been slow to adopt it.
States That Require Inclusive IVF Coverage
Of the 25 states with some form of fertility insurance law, only a handful are written in a way that actually reaches same-sex couples. Several older mandates adopted the intercourse-based definition, and a few states, including Arkansas and Hawaii, require that a patient’s eggs be fertilized with “her spouse’s sperm,” which excludes lesbian couples and single people on the face of the statute.2RESOLVE. Insurance Coverage by State
The jurisdictions with mandates that are explicitly inclusive of LGBTQ+ individuals are Colorado, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, Washington, D.C., and now California.1Stateline. Few States Cover Fertility Treatment for Same-Sex Couples, but That Could Be Changing The details matter:
- California (SB 729). Effective January 1, 2026, for large group fully insured plans covering 101 or more employees. The law redefines infertility to include the inability to reproduce without medical intervention, covers LGBTQ+ individuals and single people, and provides up to three completed egg retrievals with unlimited embryo transfers. It does not apply to self-funded employer plans, Medi-Cal, small group or individual market plans, or religious employers.3RESOLVE. Understanding California’s IVF Insurance Law
- New York. Large group insurers must cover up to three IVF cycles and cannot deny coverage based on sexual orientation, gender identity, or marital status. A 2021 directive eliminated the earlier requirement that same-sex female couples first undergo months of donor insemination before qualifying for IVF. After that change, the likelihood of lesbian couples starting IVF after consultation rose 136%, and median time from consultation to treatment fell from 297 days to 173.4New York Department of Financial Services. Governor Cuomo Directs DFS to Require Immediate Coverage for Fertility Services for Same-Sex Couples5SAGE Journals. Impact of New York State Legislation on Fertility Access for Same-Sex Couples
- Washington, D.C. The Expanding Access to Fertility Treatment Amendment Act took full effect January 1, 2025, for large, small, and individual plans. Coverage must be provided “without discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, marital status, or domestic partner status,” with at least three oocyte retrievals and unlimited embryo transfers.6D.C. Law Library. Expanding Access to Fertility Treatment Amendment Act
- New Jersey. The NJ Family Building Act, updated in 2024, is explicitly inclusive. It covers diagnosis, medications, IVF, and up to four completed egg retrievals per lifetime for fully insured plans at employers with more than 50 employees.7CCRMIVF. New Jersey State Mandate
- Maine. Defines a fertility patient as someone “unable to conceive as an individual or with a partner because the individual or couple does not have the necessary gametes for conception,” and prohibits insurers from limiting coverage based on the use of donor gametes, donor embryos, or surrogacy.1Stateline. Few States Cover Fertility Treatment for Same-Sex Couples, but That Could Be Changing
Even in these states, two large carve-outs apply. Self-funded employer plans, which cover most workers at large companies, are governed by federal ERISA law and are generally exempt from state insurance mandates. Religious employers often qualify for exemptions as well.
The Aetna Settlement and What It Changes
In December 2025, a federal judge in the Northern District of California granted preliminary approval to a class-action settlement in Berton v. Aetna that will require Aetna to provide fertility benefits to same-sex couples on the same terms as heterosexual couples. The settlement applies nationwide and is estimated to affect 2.8 million LGBTQ+ members.8CalMatters. Aetna Lawsuit LGBTQ IVF Fertility
The suit challenged Aetna’s requirement of 6 to 12 months of “unprotected heterosexual sexual intercourse” to qualify for fertility benefits, and the related rule that women without male partners pay out of pocket for multiple rounds of artificial insemination before benefits kicked in.9CBS News. IVF Treatments Aetna Same-Sex Couples Settlement Under the settlement, intrauterine insemination and intracervical insemination become standard diagnostic medical benefits, and LGBTQ+ members will not be required to complete more ovulation cycles than heterosexual patients to qualify for IVF. Aetna will also pay at least $2 million in damages to qualifying California-based members. The final fairness hearing is set for November 12, 2026, and the terms depend on final court approval.10California Infertility Settlement. Settlement FAQs
Aetna moved on part of this voluntarily in August 2024, launching expanded IUI coverage as a standard medical benefit without requiring an infertility diagnosis, regardless of a member’s sexual orientation or partner status.11Aetna. IUI Intrauterine Insemination Coverage The case is also not isolated. In Murphy v. Health Care Service Corp. (2023), a court allowed a discrimination claim to move forward against Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois on similar grounds.12EPIC Brokers. Section 1557 Fertility Discrimination
Lesbian Couples: Reciprocal IVF and Donor Sperm
Lesbian couples pursuing reciprocal IVF, where one partner provides the eggs and the other carries the pregnancy, run into a procedure that doesn’t fit most insurance frameworks. Two patients are involved, both needing consultations and testing, and insurers may code the procedure differently for same-sex couples or deny claims based on infertility-definition language. Even in states with fertility mandates, reciprocal IVF is rarely fully covered unless the law explicitly addresses it.13Center for Reproduction. Reciprocal IVF Cost Without insurance, a fresh cycle runs between $18,000 and $30,000.14WINFertility. Reciprocal IVF: What Lesbian Couples Need to Know
For couples using IUI with donor sperm as a first step, the practical question is whether the plan treats IUI as a covered medical benefit on its own, or only as something that becomes covered after months of unsuccessful self-paid attempts. New York’s 2021 directive and Aetna’s 2024 IUI policy both target that specific barrier.
Gay Male Couples: Surrogacy Is the Harder Case
Gay male couples face the highest financial barriers because they need both an egg donor and a gestational carrier. Many insurance policies carry explicit exclusions for fertility services involving third parties, and surrogacy compensation and agency fees are almost never covered. Total costs, including IVF, egg donation, carrier compensation, agency fees, and legal costs, typically run between $200,000 and $250,000.15UnitedHealthcare. LGBTQ Family Building
Even in states with inclusive mandates, surrogacy-related costs are generally outside what the mandate covers. Maine’s law is unusual in prohibiting insurers from limiting coverage based on the use of surrogacy. Men Having Babies and other advocacy groups have pushed for model legislation that would bar insurers from excluding third-party fertility services and would protect a surrogate’s maternity coverage regardless of how conception occurred.16Men Having Babies. Fertility Equality
Military and VA Benefits
If one partner is a service member or veteran, separate rules apply. In March 2024, the Department of Defense and the Department of Veterans Affairs both expanded IVF benefits to include service members and veterans regardless of marital status or sexual orientation. The VA covers IVF, IUI, and related services, including the use of donor sperm, donor eggs, and donor embryos, for veterans whose infertility results from a service-connected condition. Surrogacy remains outside the VA’s authority to cover.17Department of Veterans Affairs. VA Expands In Vitro Fertilization for Veterans The DoD limits coverage to six egg retrieval attempts and three completed IVF cycles, and ties eligibility to service-connected injury or illness.18Military.com. Fertility Benefits for Active Duty Service Members
Employer Fertility Benefits as a Workaround
Because state mandates don’t reach self-funded plans and most states still lack inclusive laws, employer-sponsored fertility programs have become the practical path to coverage for many LGBTQ+ workers. Platforms like Progyny, Maven, and Carrot are added by employers on top of the regular health plan and typically cover IVF, reciprocal IVF, surrogacy support, and fertility preservation without requiring a medical infertility diagnosis.
Demand is real. A Progyny survey found that 68% of LGBTQ+ respondents with existing fertility benefits reported being locked out due to medical infertility diagnosis requirements, and 79% said they would consider changing jobs to get fertility coverage.19Progyny. What Family Building Resources Are Available for the LGBTQ Community20Maven Clinic. Fertility Benefits21Illume Fertility. Does Insurance Cover LGBTQ Family Building
How to Find Out What Your Plan Actually Covers
Start with your plan type. If it’s a fully insured plan issued in a state with an inclusive mandate (California, Colorado, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, or D.C.), the mandate applies. If it’s self-funded through your employer, state law doesn’t reach it and the terms are whatever your employer chose.
Then call the insurer and ask three specific questions in writing: What is the plan’s definition of infertility? Is an infertility diagnosis required before IVF or IUI is covered? Are there exclusions for donor gametes, donor embryos, or services provided to or by a third party? A denial can sometimes be appealed with supporting documentation from a fertility clinic.13Center for Reproduction. Reciprocal IVF Cost If you’re an Aetna member, the settlement, once finalized, changes several of those answers directly.
Where insurance falls short, HSAs, FSAs, and HRAs may cover some eligible expenses, and grant programs can close part of the gap. The BabyQuest Foundation, the Cade Foundation (grants up to $10,000), and the Nest Egg Foundation (grants up to $20,000 for IVF) all provide financial assistance.21Illume Fertility. Does Insurance Cover LGBTQ Family Building At companies without inclusive benefits, open enrollment is the window to push HR to add a third-party fertility benefit provider.