Whether Highmark covers in vitro fertilization depends on three things: the state where your plan was issued, whether your employer fully insures the plan or self-funds it, and the specific fertility language in your benefit contract. In Delaware and in New York large group plans, fully insured Highmark coverage must include IVF by law. In Pennsylvania and West Virginia, standard Highmark contracts exclude IVF unless your employer paid to add a fertility benefit.
Coverage by State
Delaware
Delaware has the strongest IVF mandate in Highmark’s footprint. A law effective June 30, 2018 requires individual, group, and blanket policies to cover fertility care, including IVF, on the same terms as other pregnancy-related benefits. Deductibles, copays, and benefit maximums for fertility services cannot differ from those for non-fertility medical care.1RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Delaware Infertility Insurance Laws
Under this law, Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Delaware plans cover up to six completed egg retrievals per lifetime with unlimited embryo transfers, IVF using donor eggs, sperm, or embryos, ICSI, fertility medications, ovulation induction, cryopreservation of eggs, sperm, embryos, and ovarian or testicular tissue, and services for gestational carriers.2Highmark BCBS Delaware. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-014 Retrievals must be completed before age 45, and transfers before age 50.1RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Delaware Infertility Insurance Laws
The Delaware mandate does not reach self-insured employers, employers with fewer than 50 employees, or religious organizations that request an exclusion on faith grounds.2Highmark BCBS Delaware. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-014 State of Delaware employees on the Highmark Comprehensive PPO do get infertility coverage, but with a $30,000 lifetime maximum on medical infertility services and $15,000 on related prescription drugs.3State of Delaware Department of Human Resources. Summary of Benefits and Coverage – Highmark Comprehensive PPO FY25 Delaware Medicaid members on Highmark Health Options are not covered: the medical policy explicitly excludes IVF, GIFT, ZIFT, ICSI, embryo cryopreservation, frozen embryo transfers, ovulation induction management, and gestational carrier services.4Highmark Health Options. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy HHO-DE-MP-1195 No state Medicaid program covers IVF.5KFF. Coverage and Use of Fertility Services in the U.S.
New York
New York requires comprehensive large group policies (more than 100 employees) to cover three cycles of IVF and the associated prescription drugs. Insurers cannot place annual or lifetime dollar limits on infertility services generally, and coverage cannot discriminate based on age, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, or gender identity.6New York Department of Financial Services. Infertility Consumer FAQ The mandate does not apply to self-funded employer plans, Medicaid managed care, or small group plans. Highmark’s fully insured large group products in New York must meet these requirements.
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania has no IVF mandate.7WTAE Pittsburgh. IVF Coverage Dispute Between UPMC and Highmark Highmark’s Pennsylvania medical policy states that assisted reproductive technology services are “generally excluded from standard medical-surgical contracts and are not eligible for reimbursement” unless the member’s specific contract adds an ART benefit.8Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-023 Some employers do buy that benefit voluntarily, so the only reliable way to know is to read your own contract.
Diagnostic workup for infertility, such as blood work, ultrasounds, and the initial consultation, is generally covered under Pennsylvania Highmark plans unless the contract specifically excludes infertility diagnosis. Once treatment crosses into ART, however, every associated service falls under the ART exclusion if the plan doesn’t carry the benefit.8Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-023
The line can blur in practice. A 2023 WTAE report described Kristen and Travis Barta of Saltsburg, who were told by Highmark that IVF would be covered with an out-of-pocket cost under $1,000, while the UPMC fertility clinic asked them to sign an $18,000 contract they financed with a loan. After treatment, an insurance broker found that although the plan did not cover “IVF” as a named benefit, it did cover 20 of the 22 individual procedures Kristen underwent. Their liability dropped to $839 and UPMC refunded the overpayment.7WTAE Pittsburgh. IVF Coverage Dispute Between UPMC and Highmark
West Virginia
West Virginia has no state IVF mandate. Highmark West Virginia’s policy states that assisted fertilization services, including IVF, GIFT, and ZIFT, are generally excluded from standard medical-surgical contracts. Cryopreservation of oocytes, embryos, and sperm, along with storage and procurement services, are listed as non-covered. As in Pennsylvania, diagnostic services for infertility are generally covered, but anything tied to an assisted fertilization treatment plan falls under the exclusion.9Highmark BCBS West Virginia. Assisted Fertilization Medical Policy U-5-007
If Your Employer Self-Funds, State Law Doesn’t Help
State insurance mandates reach only fully insured plans, where the insurer bears the financial risk. If your employer self-funds the plan and uses Highmark only to administer claims, the plan is governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act and is exempt from state insurance mandates.10National Center for Biotechnology Information. Coverage and Use of Fertility Services in Self-Insured Employer Plans Roughly 65% of American workers with employer-sponsored coverage are on self-funded plans, which means a Highmark card in Delaware or New York is no guarantee of IVF coverage.11RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Insurance Coverage by State Ask your HR department whether the plan is fully insured or self-funded; the summary plan description will usually say.
Who Qualifies When IVF Is Covered
When a Highmark plan does include IVF, the member still has to meet clinical criteria and get prior authorization. The requirements vary slightly by state but share a common framework. A patient generally needs documented infertility (no conception after 12 months of unprotected intercourse for those under 35, or 6 months for those 35 and older) and at least one qualifying diagnosis, with no contraindication such as premature ovarian failure, menopause, or a medical reason pregnancy would be unsafe.8Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-023
Qualifying diagnoses include:
- Tubal disease, such as irreparable bilateral tubal occlusion, bilateral salpingectomy, or bilateral hydrosalpinx.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Diminished ovarian reserve, defined as AMH below 1.0, early follicular FSH at or above 10.0, or persistently low antral follicle count.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Severe male factor infertility: fewer than 5 million total motile sperm, fewer than 5% normal morphology, or sperm obtainable only through surgical extraction.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Stage 4 endometriosis as defined by the American Society of Reproductive Medicine.8Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-023
- Unexplained infertility after three properly managed ovulation induction cycles, with or without IUI.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Recurrent pregnancy loss: three or more losses under age 35, or two or more at 35 and older, after negative workup.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Genetic risk factors, such as a balanced chromosome translocation or high risk of genetic disease requiring preimplantation testing.12Highmark BCBS Delaware. Request and Guidelines for IVF Coverage – State of Delaware Members
- Fertility preservation before a treatment such as chemotherapy that threatens ovarian or testicular function.2Highmark BCBS Delaware. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-014
Delaware limits patients to three cycles of ovulation induction and IUI before IVF is available, with no prior cycles required if IVF is medically necessary from the start.1RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Delaware Infertility Insurance Laws In Pennsylvania plans with an ART benefit, Highmark generally expects at least three IUI cycles first unless IVF is medically indicated at the outset.8Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-023
Fertility medications carry their own prior authorization. Injectables such as Follistim, Gonal-F, and Menopur are covered under Highmark’s pharmacy policy only when the member has the matching ART/IVF medical benefit. Clomiphene and Serophene are approved only for infertility patients not enrolled in an ART program. Authorization lasts up to six months per period, with a cumulative cap of 24 months.13Highmark. Pharmacy Policy Bulletin J-0951 – Fertility Agents
What Highmark Doesn’t Cover
A handful of services are excluded across Highmark plans regardless of state or benefit design:
- Reversal of voluntary sterilization. Tubal ligation and vasectomy reversals are not covered.14Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-027
- Surrogate fees, living expenses, and travel costs. Medical services for a gestational carrier may be covered when the indication qualifies, but the surrogate’s compensation is not.14Highmark. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-027
- Services considered experimental or investigational, including immunotherapy for recurrent fetal loss, co-culture of embryos, and sperm DNA integrity testing.2Highmark BCBS Delaware. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-014
- Cryopreservation performed solely to produce donor oocytes, which Highmark considers not medically necessary.2Highmark BCBS Delaware. Assisted Reproductive Technology Medical Policy U-5-014
How to Confirm Your Own Coverage
Read the actual benefit contract, not just the summary of benefits. The Barta case showed that a plan without a named “IVF” benefit can still pay for most of the individual procedures in an IVF cycle, and the opposite is also possible: a plan that sounds generous can carry exclusions that only show up in the full contract. Call Highmark member services and request written verification of benefits before starting treatment, and ask the fertility clinic to run its own benefits check so you can compare answers.7WTAE Pittsburgh. IVF Coverage Dispute Between UPMC and Highmark
If a claim is denied, appeal. Resolve, the national infertility advocacy organization, reports that denials for treatments that should be covered are common and that patients regularly win coverage after one or more rounds of appeals.7WTAE Pittsburgh. IVF Coverage Dispute Between UPMC and Highmark New York members who believe they have been improperly denied can also file a complaint with the state Department of Financial Services.6New York Department of Financial Services. Infertility Consumer FAQ