GEICO does not cover OEM parts as a standard benefit. Like most major auto insurers, GEICO writes repair estimates using a mix of new aftermarket parts, recycled parts, and sometimes original equipment manufacturer parts, choosing based on availability and cost. If you want guaranteed OEM parts on a GEICO claim, you generally need to add an endorsement before an accident, pay the price difference out of pocket, or use state law and your vehicle’s safety requirements to push the adjuster.
What GEICO’s Policy Actually Allows
GEICO’s insurance glossary states that “several types of parts may be used when your vehicle is repaired: new parts, both original equipment manufacturer and after-market; and recycled parts.” The company says new or aftermarket parts will be used when recycled parts of comparable quality are not available, and it describes its standard as restoring the vehicle to the condition it was in before the loss. A five-year-old car, by that standard, gets parts “at least as good as the parts that had been in the car.”1GEICO. Insurance Terms
GEICO calls its approved aftermarket components “Competitive Auto Repair Parts” and says they “meet or exceed the quality of the manufacturer’s parts, but cost less,” guaranteeing them for as long as you own the vehicle.1GEICO. Insurance Terms The underlying contract gives the company wide discretion. The Nevada edition of GEICO’s auto policy says the estimate may be based on “the cost of repair or replacement parts and equipment with new, refurbished, restored, or used, including, but not limited to: (i) Original manufacturer parts or equipment; and (ii) Non-original manufacturer parts or equipment.”2Nevada Division of Insurance. GEICO Auto Policy Form A438NV In plain terms: the insurer picks the part category, and OEM is one option among several.
The driver behind the default is cost. Aftermarket parts are cheaper than OEM, and courts have mostly upheld insurers’ use of them. In Patchen v. Government Employees Insurance Company, a 2011 federal case in New York, a judge dismissed a class action arguing that GEICO’s non-OEM parts breached the “like kind and quality” promise, finding that state regulations expressly authorized non-OEM parts and that the plaintiffs had not shown an actual defective part.3Rivkin Radler LLP. Court Dismisses Class Action Challenging Automobile Insurers Specification of Non-OEM Crash Parts in Repair Estimates
When Your State Changes The Answer
Roughly 35 states have statutes or regulations addressing insurers’ obligations around non-OEM crash parts. Of those, 31 require a disclosure statement on the repair estimate, 20 require identification of the aftermarket part manufacturer, 13 require that non-OEM parts be of “like kind and quality,” and six require the policyholder’s consent before aftermarket parts are used.4Marshall Wallach Law. Use of Aftermarket Non-OEM Crash Parts to Repair Damaged Vehicles GEICO has to comply with whichever rule applies to you.
A few examples show how different that can look:
- In New York, Regulation 64 (11 NYCRR ยง 216.7) permits non-OEM parts only if they equal or exceed OEM parts in “fit, form, finish, quality and performance.” Each non-OEM part and its supplier must be identified on the estimate, and warranty coverage must be at least as long as comparable OEM parts. If the non-OEM manufacturer fails to honor the warranty, the insurer must restore the vehicle to pre-loss condition at no cost to the policyholder.5New York Department of Financial Services. 11 NYCRR 216.7 – Standards for Prompt, Fair and Equitable Settlement of Motor Vehicle Physical Damage Claims
- In New Hampshire, RSA 407-D requires OEM parts if the vehicle is less than two years old with 30,000 miles or fewer, or if the vehicle is leased and the lease stipulates that aftermarket parts would reduce residual value. Past that, aftermarket parts are allowed if they are of “like kind and quality.”6New Hampshire Insurance Department. Frequently Asked Questions – Repair Shop Facilities
- In California, Nevada, and Utah, repair shops must disclose the types of parts they plan to use before work begins.7AAA. What Is OEM Insurance
Before you argue with an adjuster, pull up your state’s insurance regulations on auto physical damage claims. A rule that gives you the right to refuse aftermarket parts, or that forces disclosure of the supplier, is often the strongest piece of leverage you have.
How To Get OEM Parts Approved By GEICO
You have several options, and they stack. Use whichever ones your situation gives you.
- Add an OEM endorsement before you need it. Some insurers sell an optional rider that contractually requires OEM parts for covered repairs. If GEICO offers one in your state, buying it in advance is the cleanest path. The typical industry cost is $20 to $50 per year. Even with an endorsement, OEM parts are only guaranteed when actually available from the manufacturer.8American Family Insurance. OEM Coverage
- Make a safety and sensor-calibration argument. For vehicles with advanced driver-assistance systems, policyholders have reported success by pointing out that aftermarket parts can interfere with sensors and calibration. Owners on vehicle forums describe GEICO adjusters approving OEM windshields and bumpers after this argument was made in writing.9Bimmerpost. Windshield Replacement GEICO and Safelite Experience
- Choose a manufacturer-certified body shop. Dealership and manufacturer-certified shops often have a professional obligation to use OEM parts and will advocate with the adjuster. GEICO states that “vehicle owners always have the right to choose the body shop of their choice,” though picking a different shop does not force GEICO to pay above its estimate.1GEICO. Insurance Terms
- Pay the difference yourself. If GEICO’s estimate funds aftermarket parts, you can typically upgrade to OEM and cover the gap. Ask the shop for a written side-by-side so you know what you are paying for.10Progressive. Aftermarket Parts and Insurance
- File a diminished value claim if you were not at fault. The at-fault driver’s insurer may owe you for the reduction in your car’s resale value, which can offset the OEM upgrade.11Torque News. I Was Rear-Ended in My Tesla Model 3 – GEICO Refuses OEM Parts and Now Im Stuck Paying Huge Bill
- Complain to your state insurance department. A formal complaint creates an official record and sometimes prompts the insurer to reconsider a denial, especially where state disclosure or consent rules were skipped.
Tesla And Other Vehicles With Strict Manufacturer Repair Rules
The clash between GEICO’s cost-first approach and manufacturer repair requirements shows up most clearly with Teslas. Tesla’s position statement says the company “does not allow the use of any used, recycled, alternative, aftermarket, or third-party replacement parts” and warns that such parts “might compromise vehicle integrity and occupant safety.”11Torque News. I Was Rear-Ended in My Tesla Model 3 – GEICO Refuses OEM Parts and Now Im Stuck Paying Huge Bill Tesla-certified collision centers are contractually bound to use OEM parts.
That has produced real out-of-pocket costs. In a widely reported Virginia case, a Model 3 owner whose car was rear-ended paid $663.84 after GEICO refused to cover OEM parts, citing state “like kind and quality” rules while the certified shop could not install aftermarket structural components.11Torque News. I Was Rear-Ended in My Tesla Model 3 – GEICO Refuses OEM Parts and Now Im Stuck Paying Huge Bill In the Phoenix area, Tesla-certified repair shops reportedly stopped accepting GEICO-insured customers for collision work; one owner reported roughly $2,100 in out-of-pocket costs and ultimately filed through a different insurer. At least one law firm has publicly said it is investigating potential class-action claims against GEICO over these Tesla disputes, looking at breach of contract, insurance bad faith, and unfair business practices.12InsideEVs. Tesla Repair Shop Wont Deal With GEICO
If you drive a Tesla or any vehicle whose certified network refuses aftermarket parts, call the shop before filing the claim. The repair position statement in writing is the single most useful document to put in front of the adjuster.
Windshields And Auto Glass
Glass follows the same pattern. GEICO covers windshield damage under comprehensive and waives the deductible if the glass is repaired rather than replaced.13GEICO. Glass Claims Guide The company routinely routes claimants to Safelite, its contracted glass vendor, and generally does not pay for OEM glass unless aftermarket or “original equipment equivalent” glass is unavailable. If you insist on OEM, expect to pay the difference.
Luxury and ADAS-equipped vehicles are where owners have had the most success pushing back, usually by documenting that aftermarket glass can cause optical distortion, dashboard reflections, or rain-sensor and camera calibration problems. Others simply pay the gap directly to the glass shop at the time of service.14Club Lexus. Windshield Replacement GEICO and Safelite Experience
Are Aftermarket Parts Actually Worse?
This is genuinely contested, and it matters when you decide whether to spend money or energy fighting. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has conducted crash tests concluding that aftermarket parts performed equally to OEM parts, and the Certified Automotive Parts Association tests and certifies aftermarket components.15IRMI. Auto Manufacturer Parts Versus Aftermarket Parts – A Question of Quality
Body shop professionals, on the other hand, have reported that non-OEM hoods and fenders sometimes do not fit correctly and need extra labor to reshape. Critics cite thinner sheet metal, inadequate primer that invites rust, and cosmetic issues such as misaligned body lines.15IRMI. Auto Manufacturer Parts Versus Aftermarket Parts – A Question of Quality Aftermarket parts can also affect resale value, though the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act bars manufacturers from voiding a warranty solely because aftermarket parts were used, unless they can prove the aftermarket part caused the specific failure.
The ceiling on legal remedies was set by Avery v. State Farm. A jury initially awarded $1.18 billion, later reduced on appeal to roughly $1.05 billion, but the Illinois Supreme Court reversed in 2005, holding that specifying non-OEM parts is not automatically a breach of “like kind and quality” language, that class certification had been improper, and that calling aftermarket components “quality replacement parts” was puffing rather than fraud.16CCB Journal. Avery v. State Farm Reversed – Illinois Supreme Court That ruling dampened the appetite for class actions on this question and is a large reason insurers, including GEICO, have kept the practice.
So if OEM parts matter to you, the practical answer is to secure the result before the accident: ask GEICO whether an OEM endorsement is available in your state, know your state’s disclosure and consent rules, and keep your vehicle’s manufacturer repair guidance on hand. If the accident has already happened, your strongest cards are the certified shop’s written requirements, a documented ADAS calibration argument, and your right to pay the difference and preserve the repair you want.