Does Freddie Mac Require a Private Road Maintenance Agreement?

Freddie Mac does not require a private road maintenance agreement. Its Seller/Servicer Guide focuses instead on whether the property has a permanently recorded easement granting legal access. That is a meaningful difference from Fannie Mae, which does require a recorded maintenance covenant, and the two agencies get conflated often enough that borrowers and even loan officers assume both rules apply to every conventional loan. They don’t.

What Freddie Mac Actually Requires

Freddie Mac addresses private road properties through its appraisal and property eligibility sections. Section 5605.4 directs lenders to Section 4702.4(e) for requirements covering access provided by a private road, joint driveway, or easement. The test is whether you have a legally recorded easement ensuring permanent ingress and egress, not whether neighboring owners have signed a cost-sharing contract.

In practice, the easement must appear in the public land records and run with the land, so it transfers automatically to future owners. If the title search turns up no recorded easement, or if the easement is limited in duration or revocable at the grantor’s discretion, the property will likely fail underwriting regardless of the home’s condition or value.

Why Your Lender May Still Ask for One

Many lenders apply overlays that go beyond Freddie Mac’s baseline. Your lender might still ask for a maintenance agreement even though Freddie Mac itself does not mandate one. Overlays are internal risk policies, not GSE requirements, and they vary from company to company.

If a maintenance agreement is being treated as mandatory on your file, ask two questions. First, is the loan being underwritten to Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae guidelines? Lenders sometimes apply Fannie Mae’s rule across all conventional conforming loans without distinguishing which agency will purchase the mortgage. Second, if the loan is headed to Freddie Mac, is the requirement coming from the Seller/Servicer Guide or from the lender’s own guidelines? The answer determines whether you actually need to produce the document or whether you can push back.

How Fannie Mae’s Rule Differs

Fannie Mae takes a stricter position. Its Selling Guide requires lenders to confirm that an adequate, legally enforceable agreement or covenant for maintenance of the private street exists. The agreement must be recorded, must bind future property owners, and must spell out how costs are shared among the benefiting parcels.

Some states have statutes requiring owners who share a private road to split upkeep costs when no written agreement exists. Where such a statute is in force, Fannie Mae may accept the statutory obligation as satisfying its maintenance agreement requirement. For a Freddie Mac loan, that question is largely moot, because no standalone agreement is required in the first place.

Documentation You Do Need

Skipping the maintenance agreement does not mean skipping paperwork. Freddie Mac still requires proof that your legal right to reach the property is permanent and enforceable.

  • A recorded easement document, with the county recorder’s stamp, book, and page number, granting permanent access and running with the land so it binds all future owners of both the dominant and servient parcels.
  • A title commitment or title search confirming no gaps, conflicts, or limitations on the easement. If multiple parcels share the road, each parcel’s deed should reference the same easement.
  • A lender’s title insurance policy that reflects the access easement and shows no competing claims or encumbrances threatening your right to use the road.

Pull these documents early. A missing or defective easement discovered late in underwriting can delay closing by weeks while attorneys reconstruct the chain of title, and in some cases neighboring owners have to sign and record new easement documents before the loan can proceed.

Appraisal Standards for the Road Itself

Even without a maintenance agreement requirement, Freddie Mac imposes appraisal standards that affect private road properties directly. The appraiser must evaluate the physical condition of the road and confirm it has an all-weather surface, meaning a material such as asphalt, concrete, or compacted gravel that stays passable for emergency vehicles and passenger cars year-round. A dirt path that turns to mud each spring will not pass.

The appraisal report must note that the road is private, describe its condition, and comment on whether a maintenance agreement was observed or disclosed. Deep ruts, washed-out shoulders, or missing drainage are expected to factor into the property’s valuation, and a property that lacks reliable vehicle access can be deemed ineligible for sale to Freddie Mac regardless of the home’s interior quality.

This is where the absence of a maintenance agreement sometimes bites indirectly. A road with no formal upkeep plan is more likely to deteriorate to the point where the appraiser flags access as inadequate. Getting an agreement in place before the appraisal can head off that problem even when the guide does not technically demand one.

Why to Put One in Place Anyway

A recorded maintenance agreement protects you in ways that go beyond mortgage eligibility. Without one, you have no enforceable mechanism to make your neighbors contribute to road repairs. If the road needs resurfacing or drainage work, the cost can fall on whoever is willing to pay. A recorded agreement with clear cost-sharing provisions settles that question before it becomes a dispute.

Resale is the other consideration. When you sell, your buyer’s lender may underwrite to Fannie Mae guidelines, and Fannie Mae will require the agreement. Having one already recorded and running with the land means your buyer faces no additional hurdle at underwriting.

If your property sits in a state with a shared-maintenance statute, that law gives you some baseline protection and lets any owner sue a non-paying neighbor for their share. A statute is a backup, though, not a plan. Enforcing it still requires litigation, which costs more time and money than a written agreement.

Common Mistakes That Derail These Loans

The most frequent problem is the easement itself, not the maintenance agreement. An easement referenced in the deed but never separately recorded is common with older rural properties. Language like “together with an easement for ingress and egress over Parcel B” in your deed is not enough on its own; if no separate easement document was filed, the lender has no proof the access right is enforceable against future owners of the neighboring parcel.

Easements with expiration dates or revocation clauses are another sticking point. An easement that terminates after a fixed number of years, or that can be revoked at the grantor’s discretion, does not satisfy the permanent access requirement. Informal handshake arrangements, licenses, and verbal permissions fail for the same reason. None of them creates a property interest that transfers with the land, and none will survive underwriting.