Do vacancy taxes work? The evidence from cities that have tried them says yes and no: they reliably push some empty units back into use, but they have not measurably lowered rents or improved housing affordability. Vancouver’s Empty Homes Tax, the most rigorously studied example, cut the number of vacant properties by 54% while producing no statistically significant effect on average rents or new construction.1C.D. Howe Institute. Ripple Effects – The Impact of an Empty-Homes Tax on the Housing Market That gap between activating housing stock and changing housing costs is the central finding wherever these taxes have been tested.
What the Evidence Shows on Vacancies
Vancouver’s data is the cleanest. Between the 2017 and 2022 reference years, the city recorded a 54% decrease in the number of vacant properties.2City of Vancouver. Empty Homes Tax Annual Report An independent economic study attributed roughly 5,355 fewer vacant units to the tax and estimated it lowered the overall vacancy rate by about 1.5 percentage points.1C.D. Howe Institute. Ripple Effects – The Impact of an Empty-Homes Tax on the Housing Market Those are real units that reached renters.
Other cities show weaker or murkier results. San Francisco’s commercial vacancy tax, which relies heavily on owner self-reporting, saw only 2% to 5% of properties self-report as vacant between 2022 and 2024, a figure hard to reconcile with visibly empty storefronts. Washington, D.C., tracks roughly 3,469 vacant and blighted properties, with about 2,900 paying elevated rates. The direction of the effect is consistent across jurisdictions. The magnitude depends on how the program is designed and enforced.
Why Rents Haven’t Followed
The same C.D. Howe analysis that confirmed Vancouver’s vacancy reduction found no statistically significant effect on average rents or on new housing construction.1C.D. Howe Institute. Ripple Effects – The Impact of an Empty-Homes Tax on the Housing Market Adding roughly 5,000 units to Vancouver’s rental supply barely registered in prices.
Two mechanisms help explain why. In high-demand cities, landlords expect vacancies to rent at prevailing rates eventually, so they hold prices even as more units come on the market. And landlords who might one day owe a vacancy tax can build that risk into current rents, partially canceling any affordability benefit that new supply would have delivered.
The deeper problem is scope. Vacancy taxes address one narrow symptom, units sitting empty, without touching the underlying drivers of housing costs: restricted zoning, insufficient new construction, and population growth that outpaces supply. A few thousand recovered units cannot offset a deficit measured in tens of thousands. Oakland implemented its vacancy tax in 2018, and rents kept climbing.
How These Taxes Are Structured
Understanding the results requires knowing what these programs actually do. A vacancy tax charges owners who leave residential or commercial space empty past a threshold, typically defined by days of non-occupancy in a calendar year. San Francisco’s commercial tax applies after 182 days empty.3Treasurer & Tax Collector. Commercial Vacancy Tax (CVT) Oakland treats a property as vacant when used fewer than 50 days.4City of Oakland. Vacant Property Tax Frequently Asked Questions
Rate designs fall into three families. Some cities charge a percentage of assessed value, as Vancouver does at 3%.5City of Vancouver. Empty Homes Tax Some use flat annual fees. Some tax commercial frontage by the linear foot. San Francisco’s storefront tax starts at $250 per linear foot for a first year of vacancy, rises to $500 for a second consecutive year, and reaches $1,000 for three or more years running.6American Legal Publishing. San Francisco Business and Tax Regulations Code – Section 2904 Imposition of Tax Programs that escalate rates for consecutive vacant years put the most sustained pressure on owners.
Exemptions matter as much as rates. Most laws exclude properties under active renovation with valid permits, owners in hospital or long-term care, and homes used as a primary residence for most of the year. Every exemption is a potential avoidance channel, and the breadth of the list shapes how much the tax actually reaches.
Enforcement Is Where Programs Break Down
The practical effect of a vacancy tax depends almost entirely on enforcement, and this is where most programs falter. Over one-third of Vancouver’s Empty Homes Tax levies have gone unpaid due to noncompliance. San Francisco’s self-reporting model produced roughly 85% response rates between 2022 and 2024, but only 2% to 5% of respondents reported a vacancy.
Appeals systems can hollow out enforcement too. In Washington, D.C., one owner reportedly avoided nearly $400,000 in vacancy-related taxes over 15 years through repeated appeals. Victoria, Australia, assessed about 1,779 properties for its vacant residential land tax in 2024, while the state’s Parliamentary Budget Office estimated the true number of liable properties was closer to 5,000. A vacancy tax without auditing capacity is an honor system, and honor systems favor determined owners. Vancouver has channeled a share of its tax revenue into funding audits, which addresses this directly.
Legal Vulnerability After San Francisco
Anyone weighing whether these programs work should factor in whether they survive court challenge. San Francisco voters passed a residential empty homes tax in 2022. A Superior Court judge struck it down in October 2024, before it collected any revenue. The challengers argued the tax violated the Takings Clause of the U.S. Constitution by forcing owners to rent out property or pay a penalty, and that it violated California’s Ellis Act, which bars the government from compelling residential owners to offer units for rent.7The University of Chicago Law Review. Vacancy Taxes – A Possible Taking The court granted summary judgment to the property owners. The city has appealed, and as of late 2025 no revenue has been collected from the residential tax.
The Takings Clause reasoning is not limited to San Francisco. Any vacancy tax that functions as a penalty for exercising the right to keep property empty can be characterized as a regulatory taking. Cities designing new programs now have to structure rates and exemptions with that risk in view.
Revenue and the Built-In Tension
Vacancy taxes raise money, but the sums are modest against housing need. Vancouver’s Empty Homes Tax has collected over $100 million CAD since inception, with proceeds directed to affordable housing programs and enforcement.2City of Vancouver. Empty Homes Tax Annual Report Oakland’s flat-fee tax generates a few million dollars a year for anti-homelessness work and illegal dumping cleanup. San Francisco’s commercial tax has raised little given how few owners report vacancy.
The design contains a contradiction cities rarely name. If the tax works and owners fill their empty units, revenue falls toward zero. If revenue stays high, the tax isn’t changing behavior. Housing programs funded from vacancy tax proceeds sit on a stream that is unstable by design, and it becomes less stable as compliance improves or as courts narrow what these taxes may do.
The Bottom Line
Vacancy taxes are a targeted tool that does one thing reasonably well: they nudge some empty units back into use. Vancouver’s numbers make that case. What they do not do, in any city that has been carefully studied, is lower rents or expand construction enough to move the affordability needle. Enforcement gaps shrink the effect further, and a recent California ruling has put the residential version of these taxes on uncertain legal ground. Treated as one measure among many for activating unused housing stock, vacancy taxes have a defensible role. Treated as an affordability fix, they have not delivered.