Do Amish Pay Taxes? What They Pay and the Social Security Exemption

Yes, the Amish do pay taxes. They pay federal and state income tax, property tax, sales tax, and fuel tax on the same terms as anyone else. The one meaningful carve-out is a religious exemption from the self-employment tax that funds Social Security and Medicare, available under Internal Revenue Code Section 1402(g) to members of qualifying sects who meet strict conditions. Everything else on a tax return looks the same as their neighbors’.

Which Taxes the Amish Pay

Amish earnings from farming, furniture making, construction, and other trades are subject to federal income tax at the same rates that apply to any other taxpayer. They file returns, claim deductions, and pay what they owe. In states with an income tax, they pay that too. There is no religious exemption from income tax at any level of government.

Property tax works the same way. Amish families often own significant farmland, and those parcels carry the same property tax obligations as any other privately held land. A large share of local property tax funds public school districts, and the Amish pay that share in full even though their children attend private one-room schoolhouses that the community builds and maintains at its own expense.

Sales tax applies to Amish purchases like anyone else’s. Lumber, hardware, fabric, groceries — where a state taxes the item, the tax is built into the transaction. Fuel taxes apply at the pump. Amish farmers who use gasoline or kerosene for off-road purposes such as running farm equipment or heating homes can claim the same federal fuel tax credit available to any farmer through IRS Form 4136, but the underlying excise tax is paid up front like everyone else’s.1Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 4136 and Schedule A

The One Exemption: Social Security and Medicare

The exemption that draws all the attention is narrow. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1402(g), a member of a qualifying religious sect who is conscientiously opposed to accepting benefits from any public or private insurance may apply for an exemption from self-employment tax, which is the mechanism through which self-employed people fund Social Security and Medicare.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1402 Definitions – Section: Members of Certain Religious Faiths

This is not a blanket waiver from “all taxes” or even from all payroll taxes. It removes only the Schedule SE line item that would otherwise fund Social Security retirement, disability, and survivor benefits plus Medicare hospital insurance. An Amish dairy farmer, a woodworker selling furniture, and a family running a roadside market would all otherwise file Schedule SE; an approved exemption removes that obligation and, along with it, any future right to those benefits.

The objection has to be to insurance itself, not just to government programs. The statute requires opposition to benefits from “any private or public insurance” covering death, disability, old age, retirement, or medical care.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1402 Definitions – Section: Members of Certain Religious Faiths That reflects the Amish belief that the community, not an insurer or a federal agency, bears responsibility for its members.

How the Exemption Is Granted

Nothing about the exemption is automatic. The individual has to file IRS Form 4029, “Application for Exemption From Social Security and Medicare Taxes and Waiver of Benefits.”3Internal Revenue Service. About Form 4029, Application for Exemption From Social Security and Medicare Taxes and Waiver of Benefits The application requires evidence of membership in and adherence to the sect’s teachings, along with a waiver of all Social Security and Medicare benefits, including any the applicant might otherwise receive on someone else’s earnings record.

The Commissioner of Social Security must then make three findings about the sect itself:

  • Established tenets opposing participation in insurance programs.
  • A longstanding practice of making reasonable provision for members who are sick, disabled, or elderly.
  • Continuous existence since December 31, 1950.

All three have to be satisfied.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1402 Definitions – Section: Members of Certain Religious Faiths The 1950 cutoff blocks newly organized groups from forming a sect to escape payroll tax. The community-care requirement ensures that members who opt out of federal safety nets are not left without one.

One further bar: anyone who has already received or become entitled to a Social Security or Medicare benefit before filing Form 4029 is disqualified. You cannot draw benefits and then opt out of paying in.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1402 Definitions – Section: Members of Certain Religious Faiths

Where the Exemption Stops

Section 1402(g) covers self-employment income. Wages are a different story, and this is where the “Amish don’t pay Social Security” idea breaks down.

Amish Employee, Amish Employer

Under 26 U.S.C. § 3127, both sides of an employment relationship can be exempt from FICA taxes, but only if both the employer and the employee are members of a qualifying sect and both have individually filed and received approved exemptions.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 3127 – Exemption for Employers and Their Employees Where Both Are Members of Religious Faiths Opposed to Participation in Social Security Act Programs Qualifying employers are individuals, partnerships, and certain LLCs, not corporations. When both sides qualify, no FICA is withheld and no employer share is owed.

Amish Employee, Non-Amish Employer

If the employer is not a member of a qualifying sect, Section 3127 does not apply. The employer withholds FICA from the Amish worker’s wages and pays its matching share, exactly as with any other employee. Those workers pay into Social Security and Medicare even though their religious beliefs prevent them from ever collecting benefits.

Non-Amish Employee, Amish Employer

The reverse also matters. An Amish business owner with an approved Form 4029 who employs non-Amish workers, or Amish youth who have not yet been baptized into the church, must withhold and remit FICA for those workers. The employer’s own exemption does not extend to employees who do not independently qualify.

Why the Exemption Is Allowed to Exist

The statute grants the exemption only because the community actually replaces what Social Security and Medicare would otherwise provide. Amish congregations collect voluntary tithes known as alms, with members typically encouraged to give around 10% of annual income, and deacons distribute the funds to those who need help.5PMC (PubMed Central). Sharing the Load: Amish Healthcare Financing For larger medical bills, many communities participate in mutual aid programs that pool contributions and negotiate directly with hospitals. Elderly members are housed and supported by family and congregation rather than by a federal check. The Commissioner has to find that provision “reasonable” before any exemption is approved, and the “reasonable provision for members” test is what turns a religious objection into a workable legal accommodation.

The Short Version

The Amish pay income tax, property tax, sales tax, and fuel tax the same as anyone else. They can be exempted from self-employment tax on Social Security and Medicare if they belong to a qualifying sect, file Form 4029, and waive all future benefits. That exemption stops at the edge of self-employment and at any employment relationship where both parties do not independently qualify. The idea that the Amish “don’t pay taxes” confuses one narrow religious accommodation with a blanket exemption that has never existed.