Dependent Care FSA Nondiscrimination Testing: Three Tests and Corrections

A Dependent Care FSA must pass three annual nondiscrimination tests under IRC Section 129, and a failure costs highly compensated employees and large owners the tax-free treatment on their benefits. The three tests look at eligibility, average benefits, and owner concentration. Pass all three and the exclusion holds up to $7,500 per employee ($3,750 if married filing separately). Fail any one and the “discriminatory excess” gets reclassified as taxable wages for the affected HCEs and more-than-5-percent owners, subject to income tax plus Social Security and Medicare.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs Dependent care FSA nondiscrimination testing is the annual exercise that keeps that exclusion intact.

Who the Tests Are Looking At

Two groups drive the analysis, and they overlap without being identical.

Highly Compensated Employees

Under IRC Section 414(q), an employee is an HCE if they are a 5-percent owner at any time during the current or preceding plan year, or if their prior-year compensation exceeded the annual threshold. For the 2026 plan year, that threshold is 2025 compensation above $160,000.2Internal Revenue Service. Notice 2025-67 – 2026 Amounts Relating to Retirement Plans and IRAs Employers can narrow the compensation-based group by making the top-paid group election, which limits HCE status to the top 20 percent of earners.3Internal Revenue Service. Identifying Highly Compensated Employees in an Initial or Short Plan Year

More-Than-5-Percent Owners

The concentration test focuses on a narrower group under Section 129(d)(4): individuals who own more than 5 percent of the company’s stock, capital, or profits interest, plus their spouses and dependents.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs Every more-than-5-percent owner is automatically an HCE too, so they sit inside all three tests, not just the concentration test.

Family Attribution

Ownership isn’t limited to what someone personally holds. Under IRC Section 318, stock owned by a spouse, children, grandchildren, or parents is attributed to the individual.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 318 – Constructive Ownership of Stock An executive who personally owns 2 percent but whose spouse owns 4 percent is a more-than-5-percent owner. A founder who transferred her shares to her adult children is still treated as owning them. Attribution runs through spouses, children, grandchildren, and parents, and it doesn’t chain: stock attributed from a child to a parent can’t then be re-attributed from that parent to a sibling.

The Three Tests

Section 129(d) sets out three distinct fairness checks. Each answers a different question, and each has to pass on its own.

Eligibility Test

Section 129(d)(3) requires the plan to benefit employees under a classification the IRS would not consider discriminatory toward HCEs. The eligible group has to look broadly representative of the workforce rather than a hand-picked set of executives, using principles similar to the coverage rules under Section 410(b).5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 410 Minimum Participation Standards A safe approach is to open the plan to all employees, or at least to a group where the non-HCE coverage rate is at least 70 percent of the HCE coverage rate. Plans that restrict eligibility to salaried employees, management, or certain locations need to show the resulting group doesn’t tilt heavily toward HCEs.

55-Percent Average Benefits Test

Even a plan open to everyone can fail if the dollars flow to the top. Section 129(d)(8) requires that the average benefit received by non-HCEs is at least 55 percent of the average benefit received by HCEs.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs The calculation divides total dependent care benefits used by each group by the total number of eligible employees in that group, including those who chose not to participate. That denominator is where most failures come from. If 200 non-HCEs are eligible but only 15 enroll, the average non-HCE benefit gets diluted across all 200, and clearing 55 percent becomes very difficult.

One relief valve exists. Section 129(d)(8)(B) lets the plan exclude employees earning under $25,000 from the average benefits calculation when benefits are provided through salary reduction.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 129 – Dependent Care Assistance Programs Low earners rarely participate, and including them in the denominator is often what drags the non-HCE average down. The exclusion is optional; model results both ways before deciding.

25-Percent Owner Concentration Test

Section 129(d)(4) sets a hard cap. No more than 25 percent of all dependent care assistance the employer pays or incurs during the year can go to more-than-5-percent owners and their spouses and dependents.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs The total counts direct employer contributions and salary-reduction amounts.

This test bites hardest at smaller companies. A business with two equal owners and 10 rank-and-file employees will blow through the 25-percent cap quickly if both owners max out. If total plan reimbursements are $40,000 and the two owners account for $15,000, they consume 37.5 percent and the test fails. Concentrated-ownership employers need to monitor claims during the year, not discover the problem after the plan year closes.

Employees Who Can Be Excluded From the Population

Not every employee counts. Section 129(d)(9) permits several categories to be dropped from the eligibility and average benefits calculations, which can change the results materially.

  • Employees under age 21 or with less than one year of service.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs
  • Collectively bargained employees whose benefits were the subject of good-faith bargaining, when testing a plan that covers only non-union workers.
  • Nonresident aliens with no U.S.-source earned income from the employer.

Apply exclusions consistently. Selectively excluding union employees one year and including them the next to manipulate results is not permitted.

Controlled Groups Test Together

Companies under common ownership can’t test in isolation. Under IRC Sections 414(b) and 414(c), entities within a controlled group or affiliated service group are treated as a single employer for Section 129 testing.7Internal Revenue Service. Controlled and Affiliated Service Groups – Related Employers Phone Forum Presentation Employees of parent companies, subsidiaries, and brother-sister entities all come into the same testing pool. A professional practice that splits into two entities to isolate its owners from the rank-and-file workforce still combines both populations for testing. The same applies to franchise structures and holding-company arrangements above the statutory ownership thresholds.

Running the Tests

Most employers test as of the last day of the plan year, when participation, elections, and reimbursements are all final. Three categories of data are needed for every employee across the controlled group:

  • Compensation and ownership: prior-year compensation for the HCE determination, current and prior-year ownership percentages for owners and their family members, and officer status.
  • Eligibility: which employees were eligible during the plan year, regardless of whether they enrolled.
  • Utilization: annual elections and actual reimbursements paid.

With those inputs, the arithmetic is mechanical. For the eligibility test, compare the non-HCE eligibility rate against the HCE rate. For the 55-percent test, calculate each group’s average benefit using all eligible employees in the denominator. For the concentration test, sum reimbursements to more-than-5-percent owners and their families and confirm the total stays at or below 25 percent of plan-wide reimbursements.

Timing matters. Finish testing soon after the plan year closes, ideally before W-2s go out. A failure means calculating the taxable excess and reporting it on affected employees’ W-2s for that tax year.

What Happens When a Plan Fails

The consequences land entirely on the HCE and ownership groups. Non-HCE participants keep their tax-free benefit regardless of the failure.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 129 Dependent Care Assistance Programs

The amount that caused the failure, sometimes called the discriminatory excess, is reclassified from tax-free to taxable for the affected employees. For a 55-percent failure, the excess is the portion of each HCE’s benefit that would need to come out to bring the plan into compliance. For a concentration failure, it is the amount exceeding the 25-percent cap allocated back to the owners.

The employer reports the excess as wages on the affected employee’s Form W-2 for the year the benefit was provided. The excess is added to Boxes 1, 3, and 5, while the full dependent care amount (taxable and nontaxable portions combined) appears in Box 10. The reclassified amount is subject to federal income tax, Social Security tax at 6.2 percent, and Medicare tax at 1.45 percent. The employer owes its matching share of payroll taxes on the excess as well.

Correcting a Likely Failure

When preliminary testing signals a problem, options are limited. The most common correction is reducing HCE elections proportionally to bring the plan back into compliance, which means telling an HCE that a $7,500 election is being cut to, say, $4,200. That works best when the plan document reserves the right to adjust elections mid-year.

Increasing non-HCE participation is the better long-term fix. Enrollment campaigns and employee education about the tax savings can bring more non-HCEs into the plan and improve the average benefits ratio organically. That approach takes time, though, and does not rescue a plan year that has already closed.