Deferred Outflows of Resources: Pension and OPEB Sources

Deferred outflows of resources are balances a government reports on its Statement of Net Position for costs it has already incurred but has not yet recognized as expense. They are not assets and not liabilities. They sit in their own section and flow into expense gradually over future reporting periods, which keeps volatile items like pension and OPEB actuarial changes from producing sudden one-year swings in reported results.

The Formal Definition

The Governmental Accounting Standards Board defines a deferred outflow of resources as “a consumption of net assets by the government that is applicable to a future reporting period.”1Governmental Accounting Standards Board. GASBCS 4 Elements of Financial Statements That definition comes from GASB Concepts Statement No. 4, which lists five elements of a government’s statement of financial position: assets, liabilities, deferred outflows, deferred inflows, and net position.

On the Statement of Net Position, deferred outflows appear in their own section after assets, and deferred inflows appear in a separate section after liabilities.2Governmental Accounting Standards Board. GASBS 63 Financial Reporting of Deferred Outflows of Resources, Deferred Inflows of Resources, and Net Position That placement is deliberate. A deferred outflow will reduce net position in future periods as the related expense is recognized, but it is not a resource the government can spend or convert to cash. It is a placeholder for a cost already locked in.

The practical effect is timing. A $10 million actuarial loss recorded this year does not have to strike the financial statements all at once. It can flow through over several years, matching costs to the periods in which the related employee services are consumed.

Where Deferred Outflows Come From in Pension Accounting

GASB Statement No. 68 governs defined benefit pension accounting for state and local governments. Any change in the net pension liability that is not recognized in the current period’s pension expense must be reported as either a deferred outflow or a deferred inflow, depending on the direction of the change.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68 Four sources account for most pension-related deferred outflows.

Investment Earnings Below Projections

The actuary projects a rate of return on plan investments each year. When actual returns fall short of that projection, the shortfall raises the net pension liability, and the unfavorable difference is reported as a deferred outflow. When actual returns beat expectations, the favorable difference is a deferred inflow instead.

Assumption Changes That Increase the Liability

Plans periodically update economic and demographic assumptions such as the discount rate, projected salary growth, or mortality tables. When a change increases the total pension liability, the portion of that increase not immediately recognized in expense becomes a deferred outflow.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68 Adopting updated mortality tables showing longer life expectancies is a common trigger. An assumption change that decreases the liability produces a deferred inflow.

Experience Different From Expectations

Actuarial models rest on assumptions about employee turnover, retirement ages, disability rates, and similar factors. When actual experience differs in a way that increases the total pension liability, the unrecognized portion is reported as a deferred outflow. Experience that reduces the liability generates a deferred inflow.

Employer Contributions After the Measurement Date

Employer contributions made to the pension plan after the measurement date of the net pension liability but before the end of the employer’s fiscal year are reported as a deferred outflow.4Governmental Accounting Standards Board. GASBS 68 Accounting and Financial Reporting for Pensions This category behaves differently from the other three. The balance is not amortized. It reduces the net pension liability in the next reporting period.

Where Deferred Outflows Come From in OPEB Accounting

GASB Statement No. 75 applies the same framework to Other Post-Employment Benefits, meaning retiree healthcare, dental, vision, and life insurance. The sources of OPEB-related deferred outflows are structurally identical to those in pension accounting: unfavorable investment return differences, assumption changes that increase the total OPEB liability, experience losses, and employer contributions made after the measurement date.5Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 75

One assumption deserves special attention in OPEB. The healthcare cost trend rate projects future growth in medical costs, and even small revisions can produce large swings in the total OPEB liability. A revision that increases projected healthcare inflation raises the liability and generates a deferred outflow for the portion not immediately recognized as expense. OPEB deferred outflow balances often fluctuate more from year to year than pension balances for this reason.

How Deferred Outflows Move Into Expense

The amortization period depends on the source.

  • Investment earnings differences are amortized over a closed five-year period beginning in the year the difference arises. The window is deliberately short because investment returns can reverse quickly.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68
  • Assumption changes and experience differences are amortized over the average of the expected remaining service lives of all employees, active and inactive, who receive benefits through the plan. This is usually longer than five years and reflects the long-term nature of demographic changes.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68
  • Contributions made after the measurement date are not amortized. The full balance is applied against the net pension or OPEB liability in the next reporting period.

Each year, the amortized portion moves from the Statement of Net Position into pension or OPEB expense on the Statement of Activities. Governments typically carry multiple overlapping layers of deferred outflows from different years and sources, each with its own remaining schedule. That layering is why annual pension or OPEB expense often does not track the cash contributions a government made that year.

Why the Measurement Date Creates a Deferred Outflow

GASB 68 requires the net pension liability to be measured as of a date no earlier than the end of the employer’s prior fiscal year, and the same measurement date must be applied consistently from year to year.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68 Many governments use a measurement date that falls a full year before their fiscal year-end. A June 30 fiscal year-end paired with a prior June 30 measurement date is common.

The employer keeps contributing to the plan during the intervening months. Those contributions cannot reduce the net pension liability as of the current measurement date, because they happened afterward. They sit as deferred outflows until the next cycle. A large balance in this category is not a signal of trouble. It reflects the calendar mismatch the standard builds in.

Cost-Sharing Plans and an Extra Source

Governments that participate in cost-sharing multiple-employer pension plans report their proportionate share of the collective net pension liability, collective deferred outflows, and collective deferred inflows.3Governmental Accounting Standards Board. Summary – Statement No. 68

Cost-sharing plans add a source of deferred outflows that does not exist in single-employer or agent plans: changes in the employer’s proportion of the collective liability. If a government’s share increases from one measurement period to the next, the resulting increase in its allocated net pension liability generates a deferred outflow. Differences between what the employer actually contributed during the measurement period and its proportionate share of total employer contributions also create deferrals. These proportion-related deferrals are amortized over the average remaining service lives of plan members, on the same schedule as assumption changes and experience differences.

How Deferred Outflows Differ From Assets, Liabilities, and Deferred Inflows

A deferred outflow sits between familiar categories, and that is what makes it easy to confuse with something else.

An asset provides a future economic benefit. Cash can be spent; a building can be used. A deferred outflow provides no such benefit. It represents a cost already locked in that has not yet reached the expense line.

A liability is a present obligation the government has little discretion to avoid. The net pension liability itself is a liability. Deferred outflows related to that pension plan increase the government’s total pension-related burden, but they do so gradually. Reading a Statement of Net Position with that in mind, the net pension liability plus outstanding deferred outflows, minus deferred inflows, gives a fuller picture of the pension cost still working through the statements.

A deferred inflow is the mirror image of a deferred outflow. Where a deferred outflow represents future expense, a deferred inflow represents a future reduction in expense or a revenue applicable to a later period. In pension and OPEB accounting, deferred inflows arise from the same events as deferred outflows but in the opposite direction: investment returns that beat expectations, assumption changes that lower the liability, and experience more favorable than projected.1Governmental Accounting Standards Board. GASBCS 4 Elements of Financial Statements

A growing deferred outflow balance is worth watching. It signals that more pension or OPEB expense is already in the pipeline, waiting to arrive on the operating statement over the coming years.