Contingent Consideration Tax Treatment: Earnouts, OID, and Reporting

The tax treatment of contingent consideration in a merger or acquisition depends almost entirely on how the deal is structured. An earnout or milestone payment attached to an asset purchase, a stock purchase, and a tax-free reorganization each runs on a different set of rules under the Internal Revenue Code, and each can convert what the parties expected to be long-term capital gain into ordinary income if the structure is wrong. On top of the structural rules, every deferred payment is subject to mandatory imputed interest, which carves an ordinary-income slice out of the earnout no matter what the purchase agreement says about interest.

Open Transactions Versus Closed Transactions

Before the structural rules kick in, the IRS asks a threshold question about any sale with contingent payments: is the transaction open or closed?

Under the open transaction doctrine, a seller defers recognizing gain until total payments exceed basis in whatever was sold. The Supreme Court established this in Burnet v. Logan, holding that a contingent payment right with no ascertainable fair market value did not close the transaction at the time of sale.1Justia Law. Burnet v. Logan, 283 U.S. 404 (1931) The Court reasoned that when future payments are “wholly contingent upon facts and circumstances not possible to foretell with anything like fair certainty,” the promise is not equivalent to cash.

Open treatment is now rare. The regulations provide that the amount realized from a sale includes the fair market value of all property received, and that “only in rare and extraordinary cases will property be considered to have no fair market value.”2eCFR. 26 CFR 1.1001-1 – Computation of Gain or Loss In practice, almost every earnout deal is a closed transaction. The seller includes the present value of expected earnout payments in the amount realized on the sale date, even though the cash has not yet arrived.

Taxable Asset Acquisitions

In an asset deal, the earnout consequences fall out of the purchase price allocation rules on both sides.

The Seller’s Gain

Under closed transaction treatment, the seller’s amount realized is the cash at closing plus the face amount of any promissory notes plus the fair market value of the contingent right. Gain or loss is the difference between that amount realized and adjusted basis.

If actual earnout payments later exceed the fair market value the seller originally reported, the excess is additional sale proceeds, capital in character if the underlying assets were capital assets. If the earnout underperforms, the seller can recognize a capital loss when the right expires or the final payout is fixed.

Character travels with the specific asset each dollar is allocated to. Both sides must allocate total consideration across seven asset classes using the residual method under Section 1060.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1060 – Special Allocation Rules for Certain Asset Acquisitions Amounts allocated to inventory or receivables produce ordinary income; amounts allocated to goodwill or capital assets produce capital gain. The regulations require the allocation to fill lower asset classes before any residual reaches goodwill.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.1060-1 – Special Allocation Rules for Certain Asset Acquisitions

The Buyer’s Basis and Amortization

The buyer’s basis in the acquired assets equals total consideration paid. When an earnout payment is made in a later year, the buyer adds it to total consideration and reallocates across the seven classes. In most deals the incremental payment flows into the higher classes, particularly intangibles and goodwill, because the lower classes were filled by the closing payment.

Amounts allocated to goodwill are amortized ratably over 15 years from the date the underlying intangible was originally acquired.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 197 – Amortization of Goodwill and Certain Other Intangibles The buyer does not get a fresh 15-year clock when the earnout is paid. The additional basis slots into the original schedule, so the buyer recovers the earnout allocation over whatever remains of the initial period. That lag is one of the less obvious costs of earnout structures for buyers.

The imputed interest component of the earnout is not added to asset basis. The buyer deducts it as ordinary interest expense.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 163 – Interest

Taxable Stock Acquisitions

In a stock deal, the buyer purchases shares from the target’s shareholders. The target continues to exist, and the earnout flows between the buyer and the shareholders rather than through the target entity.

Selling Shareholders

Selling shareholders treat contingent payments as additional proceeds from the sale of their stock. If the holding period exceeded one year, the gain is long-term capital gain. The important question is timing: pay tax on the expected value of the earnout right at closing, or defer until cash arrives?

For stock sales with at least one payment after the year of sale, the installment method under Section 453 is generally available unless the stock is publicly traded.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 453 – Installment Method Publicly traded stock and securities on an established market are excluded; the full amount is treated as received in the year of sale. In private company deals, though, the installment method lets shareholders defer gain until cash is actually received, a meaningful advantage over the closed transaction treatment applied to asset sales.

Under the installment method, the seller computes a gross profit ratio and applies it to each payment. When the deal sets a maximum earnout amount, that ceiling is the total selling price for computing the ratio.8eCFR. 26 CFR 15a.453-1 – Installment Method Reporting for Sales of Real Property and Casual Sales of Personal Property

The Buyer Corporation

In a standard stock acquisition without a Section 338 election, the buyer has no immediate tax consequence from the earnout. The target’s assets keep their historical basis, its tax attributes such as net operating losses carry forward, and each earnout payment simply increases the buyer’s investment basis in the target’s stock.

A Section 338(g) or Section 338(h)(10) election flips the deal. The stock purchase is recharacterized as an asset purchase for tax purposes, with the target treated as having sold all of its assets at fair market value and then repurchased them as a new corporation.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 338 – Certain Stock Purchases Treated as Asset Acquisitions With a 338 election in place, contingent consideration follows the asset acquisition rules above, including residual allocation and 15-year goodwill amortization.

Imputed Interest and Original Issue Discount

Regardless of what the sale agreement says, the IRS will recharacterize part of any deferred earnout payment as interest income. This is one of the most commonly missed pieces of earnout planning, and it converts what the parties expected to be capital gain into ordinary income for the seller.

Which Rules Apply

Two overlapping provisions govern the interest recharacterization. Section 1274 applies to debt instruments issued in exchange for property when total consideration exceeds $250,000.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1274 – Determination of Issue Price in the Case of Certain Debt Instruments Issued for Property Below that threshold and in certain other cases, Section 483 picks up the transaction.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 483 – Interest on Certain Deferred Payments

Both provisions do the same thing. If the deal does not provide for interest at or above the Applicable Federal Rate, the IRS imputes interest at the AFR and carves that amount out of what the parties treated as purchase price. The AFR varies by term. Short-term applies for terms of three years or less, mid-term for terms over three but not over nine years, and long-term for terms over nine years. For March 2026, the annual-compounding AFRs are 3.59% short-term, 3.93% mid-term, and 4.72% long-term.12Internal Revenue Service. Revenue Ruling 2026-6

The seller recognizes the imputed interest portion as ordinary income. The buyer generally deducts the same amount as ordinary interest expense. When the seller was expecting capital gain treatment on the full payment, that ordinary-income carveout is where the character mismatch shows up.

Contingent Payment Debt Instruments

When a contingent payment right qualifies as a contingent payment debt instrument, the OID regulations under Treasury Regulation Section 1.1275-4 impose a more detailed framework known as the noncontingent bond method.13eCFR. 26 CFR 1.1275-4 – Contingent Payment Debt Instruments Both parties accrue OID annually based on a projected payment schedule built from a comparable yield, and adjust in each year that actual payments diverge from the projection. Positive adjustments add to the seller’s ordinary interest income; negative adjustments reduce it.

The 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax

Individual sellers whose modified adjusted gross income exceeds the statutory thresholds also face a 3.8% surtax on net investment income under Section 1411. Net investment income includes both capital gains from the disposition of property and interest income, so both the capital gain and the imputed interest components of an earnout can be subject to this additional tax.14Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1411 – Imposition of Tax The thresholds are $250,000 for married taxpayers filing jointly, $200,000 for single filers, and $125,000 for married filing separately. These thresholds are not indexed for inflation.

When the Earnout Is Really Compensation

Not every earnout is treated as part of the purchase price. If the IRS concludes that an earnout is compensation for post-closing services, the seller recognizes ordinary income instead of capital gain, the buyer gets a compensation deduction instead of a basis increase, and employment taxes may apply.

The analysis is facts-and-circumstances. The biggest red flag is conditioning the earnout on the seller’s continued employment with the acquired company. Other factors include whether payments track the seller’s equity stake (disproportionate payments suggest compensation), whether the seller is already receiving reasonable compensation for post-closing work, and how the parties report the payments. An earnout that arose from a genuine valuation disagreement in negotiations, by contrast, supports purchase price treatment.

Section 83 and the 83(b) Election

When an earnout is compensation, Section 83 governs timing. If the right is subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture (for example, three years of continued employment), the seller does not recognize income until the risk lapses or the right becomes transferable, whichever comes first.15Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 83 – Property Transferred in Connection with Performance of Services At that point, the seller includes the fair market value of the right in ordinary income.

A Section 83(b) election accelerates the recognition to the date the right is received, based on then-current fair market value. It is a gamble. Upside above the elected value is taxed as capital gain. Downside is not refundable if the earnout underperforms.

Section 409A

A compensation-classified earnout is also likely subject to the deferred compensation rules under Section 409A. Noncompliance triggers immediate taxation of all deferred amounts, a 20% penalty, and an interest charge. Two paths generally keep deals out of that outcome. The short-term deferral exception requires payment by March 15 of the year after the risk of forfeiture lapses. A separate regulatory safe harbor under Treasury Regulation Section 1.409A-3(i)(5)(iv)(A) treats an earnout as having a permissible payment date if payouts follow the same schedule and conditions applicable to other shareholders and the earnout period does not exceed five years.

Tax-Free Reorganizations

Contingent consideration in a Section 368 reorganization carries an extra risk: the wrong structure can blow up the entire deal’s tax-free status.16Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 368 – Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations

Continuity of Interest

Continuity of interest requires that a substantial portion of the consideration received by target shareholders consist of stock of the acquirer. The IRS has historically treated 40% as the floor, and the regulations show that 50% stock satisfies the requirement while 20% does not. A contingent payment structured as cash, or a contingent component large enough that the initial stock issuance falls below the threshold, can cause the reorganization to fail and make the entire transaction taxable.

The Revenue Procedure 84-42 Safe Harbor

Revenue Procedure 84-42 provides a safe harbor for contingent stock arrangements. To qualify, all contingent stock must be issued within five years of the reorganization. At least 50% of the maximum shares of each class that could be issued must be distributed at closing. The right to receive additional shares cannot be assignable or evidenced by negotiable certificates. Only additional stock of the acquirer, not cash or other property, can be delivered. The trigger for issuance must be objective and outside the shareholders’ control. And there must be a valid business reason for not issuing all the stock up front, such as difficulty valuing one of the companies.

When Contingent Stock Is Later Issued

Stock issued within the safe harbor is treated as additional consideration received in the original reorganization. The seller recognizes no gain or loss on the principal value. The delay between closing and issuance, however, triggers Section 483’s imputed interest rules.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 483 – Interest on Certain Deferred Payments The seller recognizes the imputed interest as ordinary income. The acquirer generally cannot deduct that imputed interest because it relates to the issuance of its own stock rather than a cash payment.

Reporting the Earnout

In asset acquisitions, both sides must file Form 8594 to report the purchase price allocation, and each contingent payment that changes the allocation in a later year triggers a supplemental Form 8594 for the year the adjustment is taken into account.17Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8594 Missing this filing invites penalties and creates buyer-seller inconsistencies that draw IRS scrutiny.

Section 1060 also makes any written buyer-seller agreement on the allocation or on the fair market value of specific assets binding for tax purposes.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1060 – Special Allocation Rules for Certain Asset Acquisitions The allocation negotiated in the purchase agreement directly determines each party’s tax outcome, and the IRS will hold both sides to it unless it is clearly unreasonable.

Buyers paying imputed interest must issue Form 1099-INT to the seller for interest of $10 or more paid during the year.18Internal Revenue Service. About Form 1099-INT, Interest Income Sellers using the installment method file Form 6252 each year to report the payment received and the gain recognized. In stock sales, selling shareholders report capital gains on Schedule D, with installment calculations flowing from Form 6252.