Construction Surety Bonds: Types, Costs, and Claims

Construction surety bonds are three-party financial guarantees that protect a project owner when a contractor fails to honor a bid, complete the work, or pay subcontractors and suppliers. The three parties are the contractor (the principal), the project owner (the obligee), and the surety company that stands behind the guarantee. On federal construction contracts over $150,000, performance and payment bonds are required by regulation, and nearly every state imposes similar requirements on its own public projects.1Acquisition.GOV. Federal Acquisition Regulation 28.102-1 General The bonds protect governments and developers, and they also protect the subcontractors and suppliers who do the actual work.

The Three Main Types of Construction Bonds

Most construction projects involve a package of three bonds, each covering a different stage of the job.

Bid Bonds

During competitive bidding, a bid bond guarantees that a contractor who wins the award will actually sign the contract and furnish the required performance and payment bonds. Without that safeguard, a contractor could submit an unrealistically low price to win and then walk away once the real costs became apparent, leaving the owner to rebid at a higher number.

If the winning bidder refuses to execute the contract, the owner can claim the difference between the defaulting bidder’s price and the next-lowest bid, up to the bond’s penalty amount. Bid bonds are typically written at 5%, 10%, or 20% of the bid price, depending on the project’s requirements. On public work, where the lowest responsive and responsible bidder generally has to be accepted, bid bonds are the main tool for screening out contractors who lack the financial backing to follow through.

Performance Bonds

Once the contract is signed, a performance bond guarantees the owner that the work will be completed according to the plans, specifications, and schedule. If the contractor defaults, through bankruptcy, site abandonment, persistent quality failures, or refusal to correct defective work, the owner can make a claim against the bond. On federal contracts, the performance bond’s penalty amount equals 100% of the contract price.2Acquisition.GOV. Federal Acquisition Regulation 52.228-15 – Performance and Payment Bonds Construction

Triggering a performance bond claim is not as simple as calling the surety to complain about the work. The owner must formally declare the contractor in default, usually by following the termination procedures spelled out in the contract. The surety then investigates and decides how to respond. It may support the original contractor financially so the job can be finished, take over the project and hire a completion contractor, agree with the owner on a replacement, or pay damages up to the bond’s penalty amount. Any of those outcomes is dramatically better for the owner than being stuck with an unfinished building and no recourse, which is what happens on unbonded projects when a contractor goes under.

Payment Bonds

Construction projects run on layers of subcontractors and material suppliers who often have no direct relationship with the owner. A payment bond guarantees that those parties get paid for their labor and materials even if the general contractor runs into financial trouble. On federal projects, the Miller Act requires both performance and payment bonds before any construction contract exceeding $150,000 is awarded, and the payment bond amount equals 100% of the contract price.1Acquisition.GOV. Federal Acquisition Regulation 28.102-1 General2Acquisition.GOV. Federal Acquisition Regulation 52.228-15 – Performance and Payment Bonds Construction

Payment bonds matter most on public projects because unpaid subcontractors and suppliers cannot place liens on government-owned property the way they could on a private building. The bond substitutes for the lien right, giving lower-tier parties a direct path to payment that bypasses the owner.

Maintenance and Warranty Bonds

A performance bond protects the owner during construction, but defects sometimes appear after the project is finished. A maintenance bond, sometimes called a warranty bond, guarantees that the contractor will repair or replace defective workmanship and materials for a set period after completion, typically one to two years. Coverage applies to defects caused by the contractor, not to normal wear and tear, owner misuse, or unforeseeable events. These bonds are most common on public infrastructure projects where the owner needs assurance that roads, bridges, or utility systems will hold up through an initial service period. Some owners require a separate maintenance bond; others fold warranty obligations into the performance bond itself.

How a Surety Bond Differs From Insurance

A surety bond looks like an insurance policy at first glance, but the financial logic runs in the opposite direction. Insurance expects losses and prices them into premiums across a pool of policyholders. A surety issues a bond with the expectation that no loss will occur, because the contractor was carefully underwritten before approval. When a surety does pay a claim, it has the legal right to recover every dollar from the contractor through an indemnity agreement the contractor signed upfront. Insurance transfers risk away from the policyholder; a surety bond guarantees the contractor’s performance to a third party while holding the contractor ultimately responsible.

Contractors who treat bond premiums as just another insurance cost sometimes underestimate what happens after a claim. The surety will come after the contractor, and often the contractor’s individual owners, to recoup its losses. That recovery right is the engine that makes the entire bonding system work and keeps premiums relatively low.

The Indemnity Agreement Every Contractor Signs

Before a surety issues any bond, it requires the contractor, and typically the contractor’s individual owners and sometimes their spouses, to sign a General Agreement of Indemnity. The agreement obligates every signer to reimburse the surety for any loss, expense, attorney fee, or settlement cost the surety incurs on any bond it issues for the contractor. The obligation is joint and several, which means the surety can pursue any one signer for the full amount, not just a proportional share. If the contracting company goes bankrupt, the surety can go after the individual owners personally.3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). General Agreement of Indemnity Exhibit 10.19.1

The agreement also gives the surety the right to demand cash collateral whenever it believes potential liability exists, even before it has actually paid a claim. Failure to post that collateral is itself a breach. In a worst case, the surety can take possession of the contractor’s equipment, contract rights, and receivables to protect its position.3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). General Agreement of Indemnity Exhibit 10.19.1 This personal exposure is why experienced contractors treat a bond claim with the same urgency as a lawsuit.

Qualifying for a Bond and What It Costs

Sureties underwrite contractors the way banks underwrite borrowers, and the industry sums up the review in three words: character, capacity, and capital.

Applicants provide business financial statements, usually balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow reports, for the most recent two to three years, ideally prepared or audited by a CPA. The surety also reviews personal financial statements for the owners who will sign the indemnity agreement. Working capital, meaning current assets minus current liabilities, is the single most important figure, because it drives how much bonding capacity the surety is willing to extend.

A contractor’s work-in-progress report shows every open project, its original value, costs incurred, estimated costs to complete, and profit trend. Sureties use this report to see whether the contractor is managing current obligations well enough to take on more. Fading profitability on open projects is a warning sign. Beyond the numbers, sureties also look at the contractor’s history of finishing similar projects on time and on budget. A contractor with ten years of successful $2 million projects may still struggle to get bonded for a $15 million job, because the surety has not seen evidence that the team can manage the jump in scale.

Bond premiums for construction contracts typically run 1% to 3% of the contract value. Contractors with strong financials and a clean track record can see rates below 1%. Higher-risk contractors pay at the upper end or may have trouble getting bonded at all. The premium normally covers the bid, performance, and payment bonds together, since the performance and payment bonds are issued as a pair at contract award. Unlike insurance premiums, bond premiums are not pooled against expected losses; each bond is priced to the individual contractor’s risk profile.

Help for Small Contractors: The SBA Program

Small and emerging contractors often cannot qualify for bonds through conventional channels because they lack the financial history or working capital sureties want to see. The U.S. Small Business Administration addresses that gap through its Surety Bond Guarantee Program, which guarantees a portion of the surety’s loss if the contractor defaults. The program covers contracts up to $9 million on non-federal projects and up to $14 million on federal projects.4U.S. Small Business Administration. Surety Bonds

To qualify, the contractor must meet SBA small business size standards, fall within the contract limits, and satisfy the surety’s own underwriting criteria. The SBA charges 0.6% of the contract price for performance and payment bond guarantees, with no fee for bid bonds.4U.S. Small Business Administration. Surety Bonds For contractors who cannot get bonded any other way, the program can be the difference between winning public work and being shut out of it.

Filing a Payment Bond Claim

Payment bond claim deadlines are strict and trip up even experienced subcontractors. Under the Miller Act, first-tier subcontractors and suppliers, those with a direct contract with the general contractor, can bring a claim against a federal payment bond without any advance notice. They need to wait 90 days after their last work or last delivery of materials without full payment, then file suit within one year of that last date.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 40 USC 3133 – Rights of Persons Furnishing Labor or Material

Second-tier parties, those who contracted with a subcontractor rather than the general contractor, have one more hurdle. They must send written notice to the general contractor within 90 days of their last work or delivery. The notice must identify the amount owed with reasonable accuracy, name the subcontractor the claimant worked for, and be delivered by a method that provides third-party verification, such as certified mail or personal service.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 40 USC 3133 – Rights of Persons Furnishing Labor or Material Miss the 90-day notice window and the right to claim against the bond is gone. This is where most second-tier claimants lose their rights.

Any person who supplied labor or materials and has not been paid can request a certified copy of the payment bond and contract from the contracting agency by submitting an affidavit.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 40 USC 3133 – Rights of Persons Furnishing Labor or Material Getting that document early gives the claimant the surety’s name, the bond amount, and the information needed to send notice to the right parties.

Every state has its own version of the Miller Act, usually called a Little Miller Act, requiring bonds on state and local public construction projects. The details vary widely. Some states require bonds on contracts of any size; others set thresholds in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. Bond amounts can be 100% of the contract value in one state and 50% in another. Claim notice deadlines run anywhere from 75 days to a full year. Some states also require notice to the surety, not just the general contractor. The safest approach on any project is to read the actual bond document and the governing statute well before any deadline comes into view.