CGL ‘Your Work’ Exclusion: Subcontractor Exception and Completed Operations

The subcontractor exception to the CGL “your work” exclusion restores coverage when property damage to a general contractor’s completed project was caused by work a subcontractor performed on the GC’s behalf. In other words, Exclusion l of a standard Commercial General Liability policy normally blocks payment to fix a contractor’s own defective workmanship, but the exception reopens that coverage when the defective work came from a sub rather than the named insured’s own forces. Whether the exception actually delivers in a given claim depends on policy endorsements, the stage of construction when the damage occurred, and how the state treats defective workmanship as an “occurrence.”

What the Exception Does

Exclusion l eliminates coverage for property damage to “your work” arising out of it or any part of it, when the damage falls within the products-completed operations hazard. The exception written into that same exclusion states that it “does not apply if the damaged work or the work out of which the damage arises was performed on your behalf by a subcontractor.”1International Risk Management Institute. Full Circle Regression: The New ISO Your Work Endorsements

ISO added that language in 1986. The rationale is practical: general contractors routinely hire specialists for electrical, plumbing, HVAC, and dozens of other trades, and cannot physically supervise every aspect of that work the way they oversee their own employees. Without the exception, a GC would carry enormous uninsured exposure on every project that involves anyone else.

When the exception applies, the insurer picks up the cost of damage even though it falls within “your work” in the broader sense. A framing sub installs structural supports incorrectly, the failure damages interior finishes, and the GC’s CGL policy should respond rather than defaulting to a denial under Exclusion l.

The phrase “on your behalf” typically requires that the subcontractor was working under a contractual arrangement with the named insured. Courts have generally read this as a direct contractual relationship, and the analysis gets more complicated with lower-tier subs hired by your subcontractor rather than by you.

What Counts as “Your Work”

The standard ISO form CG 00 01 defines “your work” as work or operations performed by the named insured or on the insured’s behalf, and it extends to materials, parts, and equipment furnished in connection with the work.2New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form CG 00 01 01 96 – Section: Definitions Custom windows a contractor supplies as part of a renovation are part of “your work” regardless of where they were manufactured.

The definition also sweeps in warranties and representations about the fitness, quality, durability, or performance of the work.2New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form CG 00 01 01 96 – Section: Definitions A roofer’s ten-year leak-free guarantee becomes part of “your work” under the policy. That breadth is what gives Exclusion l so much reach, and it is why the subcontractor exception matters as much as it does.

The Exception Only Lives in Completed Operations

Exclusion l applies only to damage within the products-completed operations hazard. Work qualifies as completed at the earliest of three trigger points: all work called for under the contract is finished; all work at a particular job site is done even if the same contract involves other sites; or the completed portion has been put to its intended use by someone other than another contractor or subcontractor on the same project.3International Risk Management Institute. The Hazards of Products and Completed Operations: Understanding the Fundamentals Work still counts as completed even if it needs routine service, maintenance, or future repairs.

A plumbing defect that causes damage six months after the owner moves in sits squarely inside Exclusion l, which is where the subcontractor exception can rescue the claim. The same defect that leaks while the building is still under construction raises a different set of exclusions, discussed below.

Defective Work Versus Resulting Damage

Even with the subcontractor exception in play, insurers and courts separate the cost of fixing the defective component itself from the cost of repairing damage the defect caused to other parts of the project.

A subcontractor installs windows improperly. Water infiltration ruins drywall, insulation, and flooring. Replacing the damaged drywall, insulation, and flooring is “resulting damage” — consequential harm to property other than the defective work — and most jurisdictions treat that as covered property damage under the CGL policy. Removing and reinstalling the windows themselves is the defective work, and coverage for that component depends heavily on state law and how broadly courts read the subcontractor exception.

Rip-and-tear costs, the expense of removing sound work to reach the defective component underneath, split the courts. Some treat the demolition as part of correcting the defect; others view it as damage to otherwise sound work caused by the defect. The answer in your jurisdiction will significantly affect the size of a covered claim.

The Occurrence Gate Comes First

Before Exclusion l or its exception matters, the property damage has to arise from an “occurrence,” which the policy defines as an accident. States split on whether defective workmanship qualifies.

Most states hold that defective workmanship is an occurrence as long as the contractor did not intend to cause the damage. A second group finds an occurrence only when the defective work damages something other than the work itself; faulty window installation that damages surrounding walls is an occurrence, the faulty windows standing alone are not. Some courts in these states treat the entire construction project as the GC’s “work,” which can collapse the distinction between the defective component and the rest of the building. A small number of states take the position that defective workmanship is never an occurrence. Pennsylvania is the leading example, where courts have held that faulty workmanship claims “do not present the degree of fortuity” required by the policy’s accident definition.

If you operate in a state that treats defective work as outside the definition of occurrence, the subcontractor exception may be irrelevant: the claim gets denied at the occurrence stage before anyone reaches Exclusion l.

No Subcontractor Safety Net During Operations

Exclusion l governs completed work. Damage during active operations runs through Exclusion j. Exclusion j(5) eliminates coverage for property damage to the particular part of real property on which the insured or any contractors or subcontractors are currently performing operations, if the damage arises out of those operations. Exclusion j(6) eliminates coverage for property damage to any property that must be restored, repaired, or replaced because the insured’s work was incorrectly performed on it.4International Risk Management Institute. Faulty Work and the CGL

Neither j(5) nor j(6) contains a subcontractor exception.4International Risk Management Institute. Faulty Work and the CGL During active construction, damage caused by a subcontractor’s faulty work to the area being worked on is excluded regardless of who did the work. The subcontractor exception only exists inside Exclusion l, which only activates after the work is completed. Contractors who assume they have subcontractor protection throughout the entire project lifecycle are reading the policy wrong.

Endorsements That Strip the Exception

The exception can be removed from the policy entirely through endorsements that many contractors never notice until a claim is denied.

CG 22 94

Endorsement CG 22 94 replaces the standard Exclusion l with identical language minus the subcontractor exception. The revised exclusion reads: property damage to “your work” arising out of it or any part of it and included in the products-completed operations hazard, with no exception.5Independent Insurance Agents of Texas. Exclusion – Damage To Work Performed By Subcontractors On Your Behalf CG 22 94 10 01 If this endorsement is attached to your policy, damage from subcontractor work gets the same denial as damage from your own employees’ work.

CG 22 95

CG 22 95 is more surgical. It eliminates the subcontractor exception only for specific job sites or operations listed in the endorsement’s schedule.1International Risk Management Institute. Full Circle Regression: The New ISO Your Work Endorsements The exception survives for all other projects. Carriers sometimes attach it to policies covering high-risk projects while leaving the standard exception in place for routine work.

Insurers view subcontractor defect claims as among the most expensive and frequent CGL losses in construction. Removing the exception shifts the cost of subcontractor failures back to the general contractor, which is where it sat before ISO added the exception in 1986.

Proving the Exception at Claim Time

When the exception is invoked, the insurer will demand documentation tying the defective work to a specific subcontractor. Vague assertions that “a sub did it” are not enough. The evidence has to establish three things: that a subcontractor relationship existed, that the subcontractor performed the specific work that failed, and that the work was done on the general contractor’s behalf.

  • A written subcontract defining the scope of work, the trade, and the specific tasks assigned. This is the foundational document for the relationship.
  • Daily site logs and inspection records creating a chronological record of who was on site, what they performed, and when. These link the failed component to the subcontractor’s activity on specific dates.
  • Payment records and invoices tied to specific work phases, confirming the subcontractor was compensated for the particular scope of work at issue.

A certificate of insurance from the subcontractor is not enough. It is issued as a matter of information only and confers no rights on the certificate holder.6Independent Insurance Agents of Texas. Best Practices for Certificates of Insurance It proves the sub carried insurance at the time of issuance, but it does not establish scope of work, the contractual relationship, or any coverage obligation running to the GC.

Keeping the Coverage You Think You Have

The exception is only valuable if it is actually in your policy when a claim hits. A few steps make the difference.

Read your endorsement schedule every renewal. Look specifically for CG 22 94 or CG 22 95. Carriers sometimes add them at renewal without fanfare, especially after a prior claim or when construction underwriting tightens. If either appears and you did not request it, raise it with your broker before you bind.

Require every subcontractor to carry its own CGL policy and to name your company as an additional insured through a proper endorsement on the sub’s policy. Additional insured status on the sub’s policy gives you a separate coverage path for claims arising out of the sub’s work, independent of whether your own policy’s subcontractor exception survives. A certificate of insurance that lists you as additional insured is not the same as actually being endorsed onto the policy.6Independent Insurance Agents of Texas. Best Practices for Certificates of Insurance

Keep meticulous project documentation from day one. Contracts, daily logs, inspection reports, and payment records are far easier to organize in real time than to reconstruct after a water-damaged ceiling prompts a claim two years later. The contractor without records is the contractor whose claim gets denied.