Commercial property insurance uses one of three standardized causes of loss forms to define which events will actually trigger a claim payment: the Basic Form (CP 10 10), the Broad Form (CP 10 20), and the Special Form (CP 10 30). The Basic and Broad forms pay only when damage comes from a peril the policy specifically lists. The Special Form flips that logic and pays for any direct physical loss unless the policy specifically excludes it. That difference decides how much is covered, who has to prove what at claim time, and whether theft is covered at all.
Basic Form: Eleven Named Perils
The Basic Form is the narrowest option. If the damage didn’t come from one of the eleven listed perils, the insurer owes nothing. The covered causes are fire and lightning, explosion, windstorm or hail, smoke, aircraft or vehicles, riot or civil commotion, vandalism, sprinkler leakage, sinkhole collapse, and volcanic action.
Several of those perils carry conditions that catch people off guard. Lightning has to actually strike; static discharge without combustion doesn’t count. Explosion coverage carves out explosions from steam boilers, steam pipes, steam engines, or steam turbines you own, lease, or operate, though a fire that follows such an explosion is covered. Windstorm and hail only reach interior damage if the wind or hail first opened the roof or walls. Smoke must be sudden and accidental, not drift from agricultural smudging or nearby industrial operations. Sinkhole collapse means a sudden sinking into underground voids, not gradual settling.
The conspicuous gap is theft. The Basic Form does not cover stolen property. If burglars break through a wall, the structural damage from the break-in may fall under vandalism, but the value of what they took is not covered. For most businesses, that gap alone rules the Basic Form out.
Broad Form: Three More Perils, Still No Theft
The Broad Form includes all eleven Basic Form perils and adds three more, each aimed at weather or building-system failures.
- Falling objects. The object has to damage the roof or an exterior wall first. A tree limb that crashes through the roof and destroys equipment inside is covered. Merchandise that falls off a high shelf is not.
- Weight of snow, ice, or sleet. Pays when accumulated weight causes structural failure of a roof, wall, or other building component. Cosmetic cracking from thermal expansion typically doesn’t qualify.
- Water damage. Covers accidental discharge or leakage of water or steam from a plumbing, heating, or air-conditioning system on the insured premises. Gradual seepage over weeks or months is excluded; the event needs to be sudden or at least identifiable as a discrete incident rather than slow deterioration.
The Broad Form also includes an additional coverage for collapse, but the definition is strict. The building or part of it must abruptly fall down or cave in to the point it can no longer be occupied for its intended purpose. Cracking, bulging, leaning, or visible settling isn’t enough, even if the structure is clearly in danger. Collapse coverage applies only when caused by hidden decay, hidden insect or vermin damage, weight of people or personal property, weight of rain on a roof, or defective construction materials or methods.
Theft is still absent. The Broad Form pays only for damage from a peril on the list, and theft isn’t on it.
Special Form: Open Perils and the Shift in Burden of Proof
The Special Form is the broadest coverage available and works on different logic. Instead of listing what’s covered, it covers all causes of direct physical loss unless the policy specifically excludes them. That reversal matters enormously at claim time. The insurer has to prove an exclusion applies to deny a claim, rather than the policyholder proving the cause matches a named peril.
Open perils reach unusual or hard-to-categorize events that would never appear on a named-perils list: a chemical spill from a passing truck, an unexpected steam rupture from a neighboring building, damage from a construction crane collapse next door. The premium typically runs 25 to 30 percent more than the Basic Form.
Theft Coverage, With Sublimits
Because the Special Form covers everything not excluded, it covers theft. It is the only standard causes of loss form that does. The coverage comes with dollar caps on certain high-value items. Unless the declarations page shows a higher limit, theft losses are capped at:
- $2,500 for jewelry, watches, precious stones, bullion, gold, silver, platinum, and other precious metals (items worth $100 or less per piece are exempt from this cap)
- $2,500 for furs and fur garments
- $2,500 for patterns, dies, molds, and forms
- $250 for stamps, lottery tickets held for sale, and letters of credit
These caps apply per occurrence. A jeweler, furrier, or business holding significant cash-equivalent inventory will blow through them instantly and needs scheduled coverage or an inland marine policy to close the gap. Employee theft is excluded under all forms; dishonest acts by employees, managers, or authorized representatives require a separate crime or fidelity policy.
What “Direct Physical Loss” Means
The phrase “direct physical loss” does more work in insurance disputes than almost any other policy term. Courts have historically required some tangible alteration to the property, meaning actual damage you can see, touch, or measure, rather than a mere loss of the ability to use it. The COVID-19 pandemic generated thousands of lawsuits testing whether government shutdown orders amounted to direct physical loss when no physical damage occurred. Federal courts largely ruled against policyholders on that theory, though some state courts found the language ambiguous enough to allow coverage. Don’t assume “loss” means “can’t use.” Most insurers and most courts still require a physical change to the property itself.
What the Special Form Still Excludes
Because the Special Form covers everything not excluded, its exclusion list is longer. The theme across them is maintenance versus accident. Wear and tear, rust, corrosion, and decay are not covered, though if a rusted pipe bursts, the resulting water damage from the burst may be covered as a specified cause of loss. Mechanical breakdown, meaning internal failure of machinery and electrical equipment, is excluded under all standard property forms and requires a separate Equipment Breakdown endorsement. Fungus, wet rot, dry rot, and bacteria are excluded, with narrow exceptions when mold develops as a direct result of a covered cause like fire or a sudden pipe burst. Gradual settling, cracking, shrinking, and expansion are excluded, as is damage from insects, birds, or rodents. Voluntarily handing over property to a fraudster falls under crime coverage, not property coverage.
The pattern is consistent: sudden and accidental events are covered; slow deterioration and deferred maintenance are not.
Exclusions That Apply to All Three Forms
Some risks are carved out of every standard commercial property policy, whichever form you choose. They exist either because the risk is catastrophic enough to need its own insurance market, or because the damage is treated as a maintenance problem.
- Ordinance or law. After a loss, rebuilding often triggers current building codes that didn’t apply when the structure went up. The standard policy won’t pay the increased cost to bring the undamaged or damaged portions up to current code. A separate ordinance or law endorsement covers that gap, and skipping it is one of the most common and expensive mistakes in commercial property insurance.
- Earth movement. Earthquakes, landslides, mine subsidence, and mudflows all need separate coverage. Earthquake policies typically carry percentage-based deductibles ranging from 2 to 20 percent of the building’s insured value, depending on location and construction type.
- Flood and surface water. Standard policies exclude flood, surface water, tidal waves, sewer backups, and water that backs up from drains. Flood coverage is available through the National Flood Insurance Program, which offers up to $500,000 for commercial buildings and $500,000 for commercial personal property, or through the private flood market for higher limits.
- Governmental action. Destruction or seizure of property by government authorities is excluded, with a narrow exception for actions taken to prevent the spread of an existing fire.
- Nuclear hazard and war. Excluded from virtually all private insurance because of the scale of potential losses.
- Utility services. When power, water, or communications fail at an off-premises location and cause damage or lost income, the standard policy doesn’t cover it. Separate endorsements exist for both the direct damage and the lost business income.
The standard forms also exclude whole categories of property regardless of cause: cash, currency, and securities; land and growing crops; vehicles, aircraft, and watercraft; underground pipes; foundations below the lowest basement floor; electronic data; bridges and paved surfaces; and personal property while airborne or waterborne. A server destroyed in a fire may be covered as equipment, but recreating the data on it is not.
Anti-Concurrent Causation
The exclusions above are reinforced by anti-concurrent causation language that trips up many policyholders. The clause says that if any excluded cause contributes to a loss, whether simultaneously with a covered cause or as part of a chain of events, the entire loss is excluded. A hurricane (covered windstorm) drives a storm surge (excluded flood) into a warehouse, and both wind and water destroy inventory at the same time. Under anti-concurrent causation language, the insurer can deny the whole claim because an excluded cause contributed, regardless of whether the wind damage alone would have been covered.
Some states apply an “efficient proximate cause” rule that overrides this clause, requiring courts to identify the dominant cause and base coverage on whether that cause was covered. Most standard ISO policies still contain the anti-concurrent language, and in states that enforce it, the clause gives insurers a powerful tool to deny claims involving mixed causes. This is the single biggest reason that separate flood and earthquake policies matter. Arguing that wind or fire was the “real” cause rarely works when the policy contains this language.
The Vacancy Trap
Every causes of loss form includes a vacancy provision that can gut coverage without warning. If a building has been vacant for more than 60 consecutive days, two things happen. Vandalism and sprinkler leakage coverage disappear entirely. For all other covered causes of loss, the claim payment is reduced by 15 percent.
This catches owners off guard more often than it should. A business relocates, a building sits empty while listed for sale, a seasonal operation shuts down longer than planned, and suddenly a fire claim that should pay $200,000 pays only $170,000, while a vandalism claim pays nothing. An optional vacancy permit endorsement can restore coverage for a specified period, but it has to be in place before the building crosses the 60-day threshold. Requesting it after a loss doesn’t help.
Choosing the Right Form
The Basic Form works for property owners who want minimal premium and can tolerate significant coverage gaps. Few businesses choose it voluntarily; the absence of theft coverage alone makes it inadequate for most operations. The Broad Form adds meaningful weather and water-damage protection but still leaves theft uncovered, which limits its appeal for businesses with valuable inventory or equipment.
The Special Form is the standard recommendation for most commercial properties. The open-perils structure protects against events you haven’t thought of, shifts the burden of proof to the insurer, and includes theft. The premium increase over Basic coverage is real, but so is the difference in claim outcomes.
The mistake is assuming the Special Form covers everything. It doesn’t. Flood, earthquake, equipment breakdown, employee dishonesty, and ordinance-or-law costs are each large enough gaps to bankrupt a business, and each one requires its own endorsement or separate policy. Picking the right causes of loss form is the first decision. Filling the gaps around it is the second, and the one that actually determines whether the policy pays when it matters.