You can sue an insurance company for more than the policy limits, but only in specific situations: when your own underinsured motorist or umbrella coverage can fill the gap, when the at-fault person has personal assets worth pursuing, or when the insurer itself behaved badly enough that a court will make it pay the entire judgment. That last path, called an insurance bad faith claim, is how injured people most often collect well above a policy’s stated ceiling.
Why the Policy Limit Matters
Every liability policy caps what the insurer will pay. If a driver carries $50,000 in bodily injury coverage and a jury awards $120,000, the insurer pays its $50,000 and walks away. The remaining $70,000 is an “excess judgment,” and it belongs to the policyholder personally unless someone else can be made to pay it. Everything that follows is about finding that someone else.
Check Your Own Coverage First
Before you sue anyone, look at your own policy. Two coverages exist for exactly this problem.
Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage pays the gap when the at-fault driver’s liability limit is too low to cover your losses. If your damages total $100,000 and the other driver’s policy pays $30,000, UIM coverage up to $100,000 can cover the remaining $70,000. You file the claim with your own insurer. Not every state requires UIM, but most offer it, and many drivers carry it without realizing.
A personal umbrella policy works from the defense side. If you are the one being sued and your primary auto or homeowner’s policy is exhausted, an umbrella adds another layer of liability coverage, usually starting at $1 million. It activates once the underlying policy is tapped out.
Suing the At-Fault Person Personally
A court judgment runs against the person, not their insurer. Once the insurance money is paid, you can try to collect the rest from the defendant directly. Courts can authorize wage garnishment, place liens on real estate, or freeze bank accounts.
In practice, this is where many excess claims die. Federal law caps most wage garnishment at 25 percent of disposable earnings. Social Security, disability, and veterans’ benefits are off-limits to creditors. State homestead exemptions can shield a primary residence. A defendant with minimal assets and protected income is effectively “judgment proof,” meaning the court can enter the judgment but there is nothing to collect against. Judgments usually last years and can often be renewed, so some plaintiffs wait for the defendant’s finances to improve. It is a gamble.
Making the Insurer Pay Above Its Limit
The more reliable route above the policy limit is a bad faith claim against the insurer itself. Every insurance policy carries an implied promise of fair dealing: the insurer agrees not just to pay covered claims but to handle them honestly, investigate reasonably, and protect its policyholder’s interests when deciding whether to settle. When it fails that duty and the policyholder ends up with an excess judgment because of it, the insurer can be held responsible for the full amount.
The landmark case is Crisci v. Security Insurance Co. The California Supreme Court held that liability attaches not from breaching the contract but from refusing to accept a reasonable settlement when it should have. The test it set out: would a prudent insurer with no policy limit at all have accepted the offer?1Justia Law. Crisci v. Security Ins. Co. That standard, or close variants, has been widely adopted.
What Counts as Bad Faith
Courts look at specific conduct, not vague accusations. The clearest category is unreasonable refusal to settle. When liability is obvious and damages plainly exceed the policy limit, the insurer has a duty to settle within its limits if given a fair chance. Turning down a reasonable offer to roll the dice at trial, knowing the policyholder bears the excess if the gamble fails, is a textbook breach. The insurer must weigh its policyholder’s exposure at least as heavily as its own.1Justia Law. Crisci v. Security Ins. Co.
Failure to investigate is another. A superficial review that ignores key evidence, or deliberate delay that prevents a fair evaluation, can be bad faith on its own. An insurer that never bothered to understand the claim against its policyholder cannot credibly claim it made a reasoned settlement decision.
Unjustified delays in payment, misrepresenting what the policy covers, twisting policy language to avoid a covered loss, and refusing to defend a policyholder in a covered lawsuit all qualify independently.
Time-Limited Settlement Demands
A common trigger for bad faith liability is the time-limited demand. The injured party’s attorney offers to settle for the policy limit but gives the insurer a short window, sometimes five to ten days, to accept on precisely stated terms. Any deviation can be treated as a counteroffer, which legally counts as a rejection. If the insurer lets the deadline pass or tries to modify the terms, the demand expires, the case goes to trial, and a verdict well above the policy limit becomes possible. That missed chance to settle within limits often becomes the heart of the later bad faith case.
Several states have pushed back by setting minimum response windows. California requires at least 30 days. Florida and Missouri provide 90 days. Georgia has a safe harbor for disputes over immaterial terms. In states without such protections, a short-fuse demand that the insurer fumbles can be devastating for the carrier.
First-Party vs. Third-Party Claims
Whether you can bring a bad faith case depends on whose policy is involved.
A first-party claim is against your own insurer, after it unreasonably denies, delays, or lowballs a legitimate claim on your own policy. UIM denials and underpaid homeowner’s claims are typical examples.
A third-party claim involves the at-fault person’s insurer, and here is the catch: in most states, you cannot directly sue someone else’s insurer for bad faith, because that duty of good faith runs to its own policyholder, not to you. The workaround is assignment. The policyholder, facing an excess judgment they cannot pay, assigns their bad faith claim against the insurer to the injured party. In exchange, the injured party typically agrees not to collect the excess from the policyholder’s personal assets. That gives you standing to sue the insurer for the full judgment plus bad faith damages. Rules vary: some states require an excess verdict before assignment is possible, and a handful restrict assignment of bad faith claims entirely.
What You Can Recover
A successful bad faith case can produce far more than the original policy would have paid.
The most direct recovery is the excess judgment itself. If the insurer’s refusal to settle within a $50,000 limit led to a $200,000 verdict, the insurer can be ordered to pay the full $200,000. The policyholder would not have faced any excess exposure if the insurer had done its job.
Many states also allow emotional distress damages. The reasoning, recognized in Crisci, is that people buy liability insurance partly for peace of mind, and an insurer that destroys that security through bad faith should compensate the resulting anxiety and worry.1Justia Law. Crisci v. Security Ins. Co. States vary in how generous they are with this category.
Punitive damages are available in egregious cases. Most states require proof that the insurer acted with malice, fraud, or conscious disregard for the policyholder’s rights, often by clear and convincing evidence. The awards are not unlimited. The U.S. Supreme Court held in State Farm v. Campbell that few punitive awards exceeding a single-digit ratio to compensatory damages will survive due process review; the 145-to-1 ratio in that case was grossly excessive.2Justia U.S. Supreme Court. State Farm Mut. Automobile Ins. Co. v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408 (2003) Many states add their own statutory caps.
Attorney fees may also be recoverable. The default American rule has each side pay its own costs, but many states carve out exceptions for insurance bad faith, either by statute or through case law when the insurer’s conduct was particularly unreasonable. Whether fees are available depends entirely on your state.
Don’t Miss the Deadline
Bad faith claims have statutes of limitations, and they vary enormously. Some states give as little as one year. Others allow six or more. Tort and contract versions of the claim often have separate deadlines, with the contract deadline frequently longer. The clock usually starts when you knew or should have known about the bad faith conduct, but that date can be contested. Missing it kills the claim no matter how strong the underlying facts. If you think an insurer mishandled a claim that led to an excess judgment, pin down your state’s deadline early.