Can You Refinance With a PACE Loan? Lien Payoff and Equity

Refinancing with a PACE loan is possible, but in nearly every case the Property Assessed Clean Energy balance has to be paid off as part of the transaction. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and FHA all refuse to buy or insure a mortgage on a home that still carries a first-lien PACE obligation. The practical path forward is to fold the PACE payoff into your new loan or cover it in cash before closing.

Why the PACE Lien Forces a Payoff

A PACE obligation is structured as a non-ad valorem tax assessment rather than a conventional loan. It attaches to the property, shows up on your annual tax bill, and stays with the home if you sell. In most jurisdictions, that tax status gives the PACE assessment what lenders call super-priority: it gets paid before the mortgage in a foreclosure sale.

Mortgage lenders build their risk model around holding the first claim to the property. When a PACE lien can jump ahead of the mortgage, the lender’s collateral is reduced by the full PACE balance. The Federal Housing Finance Agency has stated the policy plainly: “Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s policies prohibit the purchase of a mortgage where the property has a first-lien PACE loan attached to it.”1Federal Housing Finance Agency. Statement of the Federal Housing Finance Agency on Certain Super-Priority Liens That single rule is what forces nearly every homeowner with a PACE assessment to pay it off before a new mortgage can be recorded.

What Each Loan Type Requires

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide requires lenders to qualify you for either a limited cash-out or cash-out refinance that pays off the PACE balance at closing.2Fannie Mae. Property Assessed Clean Energy Loans If the PACE obligation happens to be structured as a subordinate lien or an unsecured loan rather than a first-lien tax assessment, the mortgage can be underwritten under standard guidelines, but most residential PACE programs use first-lien tax assessments, so the payoff requirement applies to the vast majority of borrowers. Fannie Mae also states that borrowers who have enough equity to pay off the PACE loan but choose not to are ineligible for a cash-out refinance.3Fannie Mae. Cash-Out Refinance Transactions

Freddie Mac takes essentially the same approach. The PACE obligation must be paid off, and the new loan must be originated as a cash-out refinance under Freddie Mac’s Guide Section 4301.5.4Freddie Mac. Refinancing and Energy Retrofit Programs

FHA

Mortgagee Letter 2017-18 stated that properties encumbered by PACE obligations are not eligible for FHA-insured forward mortgages. FHA does allow the PACE balance to be paid off through a Rate and Term Refinance or a Cash-Out Refinance as part of the transaction.5U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Mortgagee Letter 2017-18 The result is the same as with the conventional investors: you can refinance into an FHA loan, but the PACE assessment has to be zeroed out at closing.

VA

VA guidelines in Circular 26-16-18 are somewhat different. The VA may allow a guaranteed loan on a property with PACE financing if certain conditions are met, including full disclosure of the PACE terms to the borrower and appraiser and no restrictions on the property’s transferability. In practice, many VA lenders apply the same payoff requirement as conventional loans because the super-priority lien still creates risk for the guaranty. If you’re refinancing through the VA, ask your lender specifically how they handle an existing PACE assessment before you commit to the application.

Rolling the PACE Balance Into Your New Mortgage

Limited Cash-Out Refinance

The cleanest path for most borrowers is a limited cash-out refinance. Fannie Mae specifically allows the proceeds of a limited cash-out refinance to pay off a PACE loan, even though the general rule restricts payoff of debts not used to purchase the property. The PACE balance is simply added to your existing mortgage payoff. If you owe $200,000 on your current mortgage and $15,000 on the PACE assessment, your new loan would be $215,000 plus closing costs. Fannie Mae allows LTV ratios up to 97% on a limited cash-out refinance for a one-unit primary residence, though not every borrower will qualify at that ceiling.6Fannie Mae. Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions

One quirk worth flagging to your loan officer: Fannie Mae’s automated underwriting system (Desktop Underwriter) may return an “Ineligible” result when it detects the borrower is receiving more than $2,000 or 1% of the loan amount in apparent cash back from paying off the PACE balance. The loan can still be delivered with that flag, but the lender has to understand the PACE-specific exception.2Fannie Mae. Property Assessed Clean Energy Loans

Cash-Out Refinance

A standard cash-out refinance works if you want to pay off the PACE lien and pull additional equity for other purposes. The lender calculates a new loan-to-value ratio based on your combined payoff amounts plus whatever extra cash you want. At least one borrower must have been on title for at least six months before the new loan’s disbursement date, and the existing first mortgage must generally be at least 12 months old.3Fannie Mae. Cash-Out Refinance Transactions The 12-month seasoning requirement doesn’t apply to the PACE lien itself.

The financial trade-off matters. Residential PACE assessments typically carry fixed rates in the 6.5% to 9% range, so rolling that debt into a mortgage at a lower rate can cut your annual interest costs and consolidate two payments into one. The flip side is that you’re stretching what may have been a 10- or 20-year PACE term across a 30-year mortgage, which can mean more total interest over the life of the loan even at a lower rate.

Documentation and the Payoff at Closing

Gathering the paperwork early prevents delays that can push your closing date:

  • A formal PACE payoff statement from your program administrator, including a per-diem interest figure so the title company can calculate the exact amount owed on your closing date. Some administrators charge a processing fee to issue the statement.
  • Your most recent property tax bill showing the PACE assessment as a separate line item. Underwriters use this to verify the debt and confirm your tax payments are current.
  • The original PACE contract, which the lender may want to see to confirm that terms, rate, and remaining balance match the payoff quote.

Once the refinance is approved, the title company runs a search to verify the PACE lien’s status against public records. At closing, the title company wires the payoff directly to the PACE administrator or local tax collector. The administrator then issues a satisfaction of lien, which is recorded with the county. That recording clears the super-priority lien from the title and allows the new mortgage to take first position.

Real estate taxes on the PACE assessment must be paid through closing and disbursed directly to the taxing authority; no funds for taxes can be disbursed to you as the borrower.6Fannie Mae. Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions If PACE-related property taxes are more than 60 days delinquent, the transaction may no longer qualify as a limited cash-out refinance and could be reclassified as a cash-out refinance with tighter LTV requirements.

If You Don’t Have Enough Equity

The math doesn’t always work. If your current mortgage balance plus the PACE payoff exceeds what a lender will approve based on your home’s appraised value, the refinance stalls. This is where most PACE refinancing efforts actually fall apart, and the realistic options are limited:

  • Bring cash to closing to cover the portion of the PACE balance that won’t fit in the new loan. This is the simplest fix when the shortfall is a few thousand dollars.
  • Wait for appreciation or pay down the balance. If your home’s value is rising or you can make extra payments on the PACE assessment, time may close the equity gap. Some PACE programs allow partial prepayments above a minimum amount, which lowers the principal and may bring the numbers into range.
  • Look at portfolio or non-QM lenders. A small number of lenders that hold loans on their own books rather than selling to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac may refinance a property with a PACE lien still in place. Expect higher interest rates and less favorable terms.

What you should not do is ignore the PACE assessment and hope a lender won’t notice. The lien shows up in the title search, and every conforming and government-insured underwriter will flag it.

Prepayment Penalties and Payoff Costs

Most current PACE programs do not charge prepayment penalties. The CFPB noted during its rulemaking that while some early PACE contracts did include them, more recent transactions generally do not.7Federal Register. Residential Property Assessed Clean Energy Financing (Regulation Z) Check your original contract before assuming yours is penalty-free, especially if the assessment was taken out before 2018.

The administrative costs of paying off a PACE assessment are generally modest. Most providers allow full early payoff, though some charge a processing fee or require a minimum payment amount. Contact your PACE administrator directly for the exact payoff figure and any associated fees. The payoff statement will typically include a per-diem interest calculation so the title company can determine the precise amount owed on the day of closing. County recording fees for filing the lien release typically run under $100.