Builders Risk Coverage Form: Perils, Exclusions, and LEG Clauses

A builders risk coverage form is a construction-period property insurance contract — most commonly the ISO CP 00 20 — that insures a building, its on-site materials, and temporary structures against physical loss from the start of construction through completion. What it actually pays for depends on three things stacked together: the Causes of Loss form attached to it, the exclusions and endorsements written into it, and the valuation and termination provisions that decide how much and how long. Getting those details wrong is where most coverage disputes begin.

What the Form Covers

The CP 00 20 covers the building or structure itself, starting with the foundation. It also covers materials, supplies, fixtures, and equipment that will become a permanent part of the finished building — HVAC units, electrical panels, plumbing components — even before they are installed.

The location rule matters. These items must be on-site or within 100 feet of the described premises to qualify. Lumber stacked across the street or windows staged in a nearby lot generally fall inside that radius; materials sitting at a supplier’s warehouse a mile away do not, unless the policy is endorsed for off-site storage or transit.

Temporary structures placed on the premises for the project are covered too. Scaffolding, concrete formwork, and storage trailers all fit. Courts have read “temporary structures” broadly in some disputes, extending coverage to items like dewatering wells and submersible pumps used during construction even when the insurer argued they would not be part of the finished building.

What Perils Are Covered

A builders risk form does not define its own perils. It relies on a separate Causes of Loss form, and the choice between them changes everything about what triggers a payout.

  • Special Form (CP 10 30): Covers all risks of direct physical loss unless specifically excluded. The burden sits on the insurer to prove an exclusion applies.
  • Basic or Broad Form: Covers only listed perils such as fire, lightning, windstorm, hail, explosion, vandalism, and vehicle or aircraft impact. If the cause of loss is not on the list, the insurer owes nothing.

The Special Form is the default on significant commercial projects. Fire during construction, theft of copper wiring, vandalism to installed drywall, collapse from a windstorm — all covered unless the policy says otherwise.1New York State Office of General Services. CP 10 30 09 17 – Causes Of Loss – Special Form The practical difference between special and named-peril forms becomes painfully obvious when something unusual damages a project and the insured discovers the peril was not on their list.

Standard Exclusions

Even under the Special Form, certain losses are carved out of virtually every builders risk policy written on an ISO or comparable form:

  • Earth movement, including earthquakes, landslides, and sinkholes
  • Flood and surface water
  • War and military action
  • Nuclear hazard
  • Governmental seizure
  • Pollution or contamination

Flood and earthquake coverage exists but has to be bought separately. In high-exposure zones the cost of these add-ons can be significant, and lenders often require them as a condition of financing.

Other common exclusions include mechanical breakdown of construction equipment, wear and tear, voluntary parting with property (handing materials to someone who turns out to be a thief), and consequential losses like lost rental income unless a specific endorsement is added.

Faulty Workmanship and the LEG Clauses

This exclusion produces more litigation than any other provision in builders risk policies. The underlying principle is simple: insurance covers accidents, not the cost of doing the work correctly. If a subcontractor installs a roof improperly and it has to be torn off and redone, the cost of fixing that roof is not a covered loss.

Where it gets complicated is the ensuing loss provision. Most policies will not pay to redo the defective work, but if that defective work triggers a separate covered peril that damages other parts of the building, the resulting damage may be covered. A plumber who incorrectly joins a pipe is not covered for the pipe repair, but water damage to the floors below from the resulting leak often is, because water damage is otherwise a covered peril.

The London Engineering Group developed three model exclusion clauses that define how aggressively the policy excludes defect-related losses. The LEG clauses appear in many manuscript builders risk policies:

  • LEG 1: The broadest exclusion. No coverage for any loss or damage caused by defects in workmanship, materials, or design, including damage to other parts of the project. Most insurer-friendly, least protection for the insured.
  • LEG 2: Excludes the cost of remedying the defective work itself but covers resulting damage to other parts of the project. The middle ground, and probably the most common version on large commercial projects.
  • LEG 3: The narrowest exclusion. It carves out only the cost of improvements or upgrades to the original defective design, material, or workmanship, covering resulting damage and most of the repair costs.

On a large project the difference between these clauses can run into millions. Check which LEG clause (or equivalent wording) applies before assuming defect-related damage will be covered.

Who Should Be Named on the Policy

A builders risk policy can be purchased by the owner, the general contractor, or both. The construction contract usually specifies which party carries it. Owner-controlled policies are common on large commercial developments; contractor-controlled policies are typical for speculative residential construction.

Whoever buys the policy, the named insured controls it. They can modify coverage, file claims, and make decisions about settlements. Every party with an insurable interest in the project should be identified somewhere on the policy.

Subcontractors create a particular exposure. If a subcontractor is not listed as a named insured or additional insured, two problems appear. They cannot file a claim directly with the insurer, even if their installed work is destroyed; they have to rely on the named insured to make the claim on their behalf. And the insurer can pursue a subrogation claim against the subcontractor after paying for a loss the sub caused, effectively making the subcontractor pay for the damage out of pocket despite insurance existing on the project.

Additional insured status solves both problems. Many policies now require a written contract between the named insured and the subcontractor before additional insured status is granted, so a handshake arrangement will not cut it. A waiver of subrogation endorsement adds another layer of protection by preventing the insurer from pursuing any party involved in the project after paying a claim.

Valuation, Coinsurance, and Reporting

Builders risk forms use a completed value approach. The policy limit should reflect the total anticipated cost of the finished building — all labor and materials — from day one. This feels counterintuitive because the building is only worth a fraction of that amount early on, but the premium is calculated on the increasing exposure as construction progresses.

Most ISO-based forms carry a coinsurance provision requiring the limit to equal 100% of the completed value. If the limit is set too low and a loss occurs, the insurer applies a coinsurance penalty: the payout is reduced proportionally based on the ratio of the actual limit to the required limit. On a project with a $5 million completed value insured at only $4 million, the insurer pays only 80% of an otherwise covered loss. The penalty applies on partial losses too. Underinsuring by 20% doesn’t just leave the top 20% uncovered. It reduces every claim by 20%.

Reporting vs. Non-Reporting Forms

Non-reporting forms set a fixed limit at inception based on the estimated completed value, with the premium calculated on that full amount upfront. Simple to administer, no room for adjustment if scope changes through change orders.

Reporting forms require the insured to submit monthly or quarterly value reports reflecting the current state of construction. The premium adjusts to the reported values, which usually means lower upfront costs. The trade-off is administrative burden and risk: miss a reporting deadline or report inaccurately, and the coinsurance penalty kicks in on any subsequent claim. Values should be updated to reflect change orders as they occur.

Soft Cost and Delay in Completion Coverage

The base builders risk form covers only the physical structure and materials. It does not cover the financial fallout from a construction delay caused by a covered loss. For that, you need a soft cost or delay in completion endorsement. On any project with debt service or a lease-up timeline, skipping it is a serious mistake.

Soft costs are the ongoing expenses that keep accruing while a damaged project sits idle waiting for repairs. A covered loss that adds six months to a timeline can generate hundreds of thousands of dollars in carrying costs the base policy will not touch. Typical categories include:

  • Construction loan interest, which the lender continues to charge regardless of a fire on the third floor
  • Property taxes, which continue regardless of project status
  • Architect and engineering fees for redesign and additional inspections after a loss
  • Advertising and promotional expenses for relaunching marketing campaigns on delayed lease-up or sales
  • Permit and license fees for renewals when the original permits expire
  • Legal and accounting fees tied to the delay
  • Additional premiums to extend the builders risk policy itself

The endorsement typically includes a waiting period (30 days is standard on large projects) before recovery begins, and an agreed maximum indemnity period capping how long the insurer pays. The trigger is specific: a covered physical loss must push completion beyond the originally scheduled date. Losses that happen but don’t delay the project do not activate soft cost coverage.

When Coverage Ends

Builders risk policies are not permanent, and this is where policyholders get caught. Coverage terminates on the first of several triggers:

  • The building is occupied, in whole or in part, or put to its intended use
  • The property is accepted by the owner or purchaser
  • The policy expires or is cancelled
  • The insured’s interest in the property ceases
  • Construction is abandoned with no intention to complete
  • A set number of days (commonly 60 to 90) pass after construction is complete

Occupancy catches the most people. Moving a security guard into a completed wing, storing inventory in a finished warehouse bay, or letting a tenant start fitting out their space can terminate the entire policy, not just coverage for the occupied portion. Some forms give a 60-day grace period after partial occupancy; others terminate immediately. Anyone planning phased occupancy needs to read this provision carefully and consider endorsements that permit partial use without killing the policy.

If construction runs past the original policy expiration date, which happens on more projects than anyone likes to admit, the policy has to be extended before it expires. Letting it lapse mid-construction leaves the project uninsured, and retroactively binding new coverage over the gap is not possible.

Renovation Projects and Existing Structures

Renovation coverage is more complex than new construction because the policy has to account for the value of an existing building in addition to the new construction costs. The existing structure may be insured at replacement cost, actual cash value, or under a separate sub-limit, and that choice meaningfully affects claim recovery.

Actual cash value on an older building can create a significant gap. A 50-year-old structure with a $3 million replacement cost might have an actual cash value of only $800,000 after depreciation. If the building is destroyed during renovation, the insured recovers far less than the cost to rebuild. The better approach on most renovation projects is a specific sub-limit or agreed amount for the existing structure based on its replacement cost or its contribution to the project’s completed value.

Time element coverages need extra attention here too. If the original structure was generating income before renovation began, the policy should address lost income during the construction period, not just delay beyond the scheduled completion date. Failing to coordinate the builders risk policy with any existing property insurance on the building can leave gaps that only show up after a loss.

Premiums and Deductibles

Premiums for new construction generally fall between 1% and 4% of total project value, with the actual cost driven by location, construction type, project size, and scope of coverage. A wood-frame project in a hurricane zone costs substantially more to insure than a fire-resistive building in the Midwest. Adding soft cost coverage, broader defect provisions, or earthquake and flood endorsements pushes the premium higher.

Deductibles split between standard and catastrophic perils. For fire, theft, vandalism, and other standard causes of loss, deductibles are typically a flat dollar amount. For wind, hail, and named storm coverage, they are often expressed as a percentage of the insured value, commonly 2% to 5%. On a $10 million project with a 3% named storm deductible, the insured absorbs the first $300,000 of any hurricane-related loss before the policy responds. Earthquake deductibles work the same way. These percentage-based deductibles can represent a substantial uninsured layer on large projects and need to be budgeted for before the storm shows up.