Former students of Brown Mackie College may qualify for federal student loan forgiveness through borrower defense to repayment, the Sweet v. McMahon class action settlement, or a closed school discharge, and a narrower group of private loan borrowers may qualify for cancellation under the Navient attorney general settlement. As of 2026, the U.S. Department of Education has not issued a blanket group discharge specifically for Brown Mackie borrowers, so most former students need to apply through one of these programs themselves.
Which route fits depends on when you attended, what kind of loan you have, and whether you were still enrolled when your campus closed. The options below are not mutually exclusive, and some borrowers qualify under more than one.
Borrower Defense to Repayment
Borrower defense is the main federal route for students who were defrauded by their school. If you have federal student loans and believe Brown Mackie misled you about job placement, accreditation, credit transferability, program quality, financial aid, or licensure, you can file an individual borrower defense claim with the Department of Education asking that your federal loans be discharged.
Brown Mackie borrowers have substantial documentary support for these claims. A coalition of 39 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia announced a settlement with parent company Education Management Corporation on November 16, 2015, cataloging misrepresentations about accreditation, graduation rates, job placement rates, credit transferability, financial aid terms, veterans’ benefits, and licensure requirements across EDMC schools including Brown Mackie. The states also found that EDMC enrolled students in programs that lacked the state accreditation needed for employment in the field being studied, and used third-party lead vendors who misrepresented student loans as “free money” or disguised recruitment contacts as employment offers.
Members of Congress have asked the Department of Education to use its authority under the Higher Education Act to issue a formal group discharge for Brown Mackie students, pointing to the $6.1 billion group discharge approved for students of EDMC’s Art Institutes brand. As of 2026, the Department has not done so, and advocacy groups such as Veterans Education Success are continuing to press for one. Until that changes, borrower defense is filed individually.
The Sweet v. McMahon Settlement
Brown Mackie College appears on the Exhibit C school list in the Sweet v. McMahon class action settlement (formerly Sweet v. Cardona), which provides relief to federal borrowers whose borrower defense applications sat unprocessed at the Department of Education. If this describes your situation, you may already be entitled to automatic relief without having to prove your fraud claim again.
The settlement covers two groups:
- Borrowers with borrower defense applications pending as of June 22, 2022 were entitled to automatic loan discharge under the settlement.
- “Post-class” applicants who filed between June 22, 2022 and November 16, 2022 were supposed to receive decisions by January 28, 2026.
The Department failed to adjudicate most post-class applications by that deadline, deciding fewer than 54,000 out of more than 251,000. Under the settlement, borrowers who did not get a decision are entitled to full relief: loan discharge, refunds of past payments, and correction of negative credit reporting. The Department asked to delay those obligations, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals denied the request in March 2026. The Department was ordered to send eligibility notices by March 30, 2026, with relief to follow within one year.
If you filed a borrower defense application for Brown Mackie in or before that November 2022 window, watch for a notice from the Department of Education and keep your contact information current with your loan servicer.
Closed School Discharge
Every Brown Mackie campus is now permanently closed. The Michigan City, Indiana campus closed in May 2016, and the Merrillville, Fort Wayne, Indianapolis, and South Bend campuses closed in September 2017, after EDMC announced in mid-2016 that it would shut down 22 of the chain’s 26 locations.
You may qualify for a closed school discharge of your federal loans if you were enrolled when your Brown Mackie campus closed, or if you withdrew within 180 days of the closure date. Because every Brown Mackie campus closed before July 1, 2023, former students are not eligible for automatic discharge. You will need to submit a paper application to your federal loan servicer.
If you previously applied for a closed school discharge and were denied under older, more restrictive rules, you can reapply under the current eligibility criteria.
One caution: consumer advocates flagged that during the Dream Center transition period, students at closing EDMC-related campuses were sometimes steered into transfer agreements designed to prevent them from qualifying for closed school discharges. Completing a program by transferring your Brown Mackie credits elsewhere can disqualify you from this specific form of relief, even if those credits ultimately did not transfer well. If this happened to you, borrower defense may still be available.
Institutional Loan Forgiveness From the 2015 State Settlement
The 2015 multistate attorney general settlement already forgave $102.8 million in institutional loan debt that more than 80,000 former EDMC students, including Brown Mackie students, owed directly to the school. State examples included more than $10.6 million for over 7,100 Ohio students, $5.7 million for 5,530 Indiana students, and $632,000 for roughly 553 New Mexico students.
To qualify, a student generally had to have enrolled with fewer than 24 transfer credits, withdrawn within 45 days of their first term, and last attended between 2006 and 2014. If you fit that profile and were never contacted, it is worth asking your state attorney general’s office about the status of relief under the settlement.
Important boundary: this settlement only covered loans owed to the school itself. It did not forgive federal student loans or private loans from outside lenders.
Private Loan Relief Through the Navient Settlement
Options for private student loans are narrower. Brown Mackie is listed under the EDMC/Education Management Corporation entry on the Navient attorney general settlement’s for-profit school list. Under that settlement, certain private student loans originated by Sallie Mae between 2003 and 2014 for students attending schools on the list are eligible for cancellation.
To qualify, the borrower needed:
- More than seven consecutive months of delinquent payments before June 30, 2021, and
- A mailing address in one of the participating states.
Outside of this specific settlement, there is no dedicated forgiveness program for private student loans. If your private loan is held by another lender, your options are generally limited to individual legal claims or direct negotiation with the loan holder.
Why Brown Mackie Borrowers Often Have Strong Fraud Claims
If you are deciding whether to file a borrower defense claim, the public record is unusually detailed. Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine, announcing his state’s portion of the 2015 settlement, said many students “didn’t understand what they were getting into and accrued a significant amount of debt without ever getting a degree.”
A U.S. Senate investigation documented aggressive internal quotas requiring EDMC recruiters to sign up an average of three new students per week, with recruiters who missed targets facing termination. A 2021 report by Veterans Education Success documented 202 complaints from student veterans about EDMC schools, with more than half coming specifically from Brown Mackie students. Veterans reported being misled about employment prospects, salaries, career services, credit transferability, and accreditation, which led them to exhaust GI Bill benefits or take on heavy additional debt.
Program quality findings add to the record. The Arizona Board of Nursing investigated the Tucson Brown Mackie practical nursing program for the 2014–2015 academic year and found the school failed to provide proper textbooks, qualified faculty, and clinical placements; students were required to use veterinary technician supplies because the college lacked appropriate medical equipment, and a paralegal program attorney was assigned to teach anatomy and physiology. None of the students were recommended to the state nursing board, and none were permitted to sit for the national licensing exam. The Arizona board placed the program on probation in May 2015 and barred new enrollment, and the program ultimately surrendered its approval.
Brown Mackie’s accreditor, the Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools, also lost federal recognition in 2016 when the Department of Education concluded its track record “does not inspire confidence that it can address all of the problems effectively.” Former Brown Mackie students have reported being unable to transfer any of their credits to other institutions, including a veteran profiled by the Hechinger Report who found that a California community college would not accept a single credit, forcing him to start over after exhausting his federal loan eligibility.
What To Do Next
Start by identifying which loans you have. Federal loans appear in your account at studentaid.gov; anything not listed there is private. For federal loans, file a borrower defense application through the Department of Education and, if your campus closure dates fit, a closed school discharge application with your loan servicer. If you filed a borrower defense claim on or before November 16, 2022 and never received a decision, watch for a Sweet v. McMahon eligibility notice.
EDMC filed for bankruptcy in June 2018 with reported assets of less than $50,000 against liabilities of $500 million to $1 billion, so direct recovery from the company is not realistic. Relief, if it comes, will come through the federal and state programs above.