If the Department of Education denied your borrower defense to repayment claim, you can ask for a second look through borrower defense reconsideration, but only on narrow grounds set out in 34 C.F.R. § 685.407. A request that simply disagrees with the outcome will not succeed. One that points to a specific administrative error, a misapplied legal standard, or new evidence can.
The Three Grounds You Can Raise
The regulation limits reconsideration to three categories. Your request has to fit one of them.
Administrative or technical error. The Department made a procedural mistake: it overlooked evidence already in your file, applied the wrong regulation to your loan type, or miscalculated dates that affected eligibility. The denial letter is where you look for this. If the reasoning mischaracterizes what you submitted or ignores documents you attached, you have something to work with.
State law standard, for loans first disbursed before July 1, 2017. For older loans, the Department evaluates claims under the consumer protection laws of the state where the school operated. Applying the wrong state’s law, ignoring a relevant state statute, or misreading the standard for fraud or deception under that state’s rules is a reconsideration ground. This path is closed if your loans were disbursed on or after July 1, 2017; those claims are judged under a federal standard instead, and the state law argument will not get traction.
New evidence. Something you did not provide originally, and that the Department did not rely on in its decision. Internal school documents released through litigation, government enforcement actions filed after your original claim, and records from former school employees that surfaced later all count. Court records from cases involving the school, including settlements like Sweet v. McMahon (formerly Sweet v. Cardona), can document systemic patterns of deception that support your individual claim.
Read your denial letter closely before you write anything. The letter should explain what the Department considered and why it found your evidence insufficient. The specific sentences that mischaracterize your record, overlook a document, or apply the wrong standard are the threads to pull.
Filing Deadlines
For group reconsideration requests filed by a third-party requestor under § 685.402(c), the deadline is firm: 90 days from the date of the Department’s written decision, for decisions issued on or after the effective date of the current regulations.
For individual borrowers, the regulation does not set an explicit cutoff in the same way. Waiting still hurts you. Evidence gets harder to gather, memories fade, and the Department is not obligated to prioritize stale requests. Treat a denial as urgent even if no hard date applies to your situation.
Building the Request
Reconsideration is submitted on an approved form, signed under penalty of perjury. The individual form asks for identifying information about you, the school, and your enrollment: school name, campus location, program of study, and dates attended. If you have your original Borrower Defense application number from prior correspondence, include it so reviewers can pull your file.
The narrative does the real work. For each ground you raise, say what the Department got wrong or what new evidence you have. If you are arguing administrative error, point to the specific page or paragraph of the denial letter where the mistake appears. If you are submitting new evidence, explain why you did not have it before and why it changes the outcome.
Evidence That Carries Weight
Tie each document to a specific ground. Useful material includes enrollment agreements and course catalogs that contradict what recruiters promised, promotional materials showing inflated job placement or salary figures, government enforcement actions or state attorney general findings against the school, and communications from former employees describing institutional misconduct.
The form lets you include “any other new documentation that you believe supports your request.” Sworn statements from former classmates or school employees are not specifically required, but the certification section commits you to providing testimony or a sworn statement if the Department later asks. If you already have written statements from witnesses, include them now.
Reference your attachments by name in the narrative and direct reviewers to the relevant pages. A pile of unsorted PDFs with no explanation increases the chance that key evidence gets overlooked.
How to Submit
The Department accepts reconsideration requests through its online portal at StudentAid.gov/borrower-defense. Email submission is available when the portal is not. Keep your confirmation receipt or email acknowledgment as proof of the filing date, and update your contact information in the federal student aid system so the Department can reach you with a decision.
What Happens to Your Loans While You Wait
Once the Department receives a materially complete application, your loans get protective treatment. Loans not in default are placed in forbearance, so no payments are required. Defaulted loans move to stopped-collection status, which suspends wage garnishment and Treasury offset.
Interest is the piece most borrowers miss. Forbearance does not automatically stop interest from accruing. Under 34 C.F.R. § 685.403, interest keeps accumulating for the first 180 days of review. If the Department has not decided by day 180, interest stops accruing from that point until you are notified of the outcome. The same 180-day rule applies to defaulted loans in stopped-collection status. Any interest that accrues during those first 180 days can capitalize onto your principal if the reconsideration is ultimately denied.
The Department does not publish average timelines for reconsideration, and backlogs vary with claim volume. Plan on several months at a minimum.
If Your Reconsideration Is Approved
A successful reconsideration discharges the remaining balance on the federal loans tied to the school that engaged in misconduct. The Department may grant full or partial relief depending on the nature and extent of the conduct and the harm to you.
You may also receive a refund of payments you previously made on those specific loans, including voluntary payments and amounts collected through garnishment or Treasury offset. For borrowers who paid for years before filing, the refund can be substantial.
Credit reporting varies. In certain group discharge situations the Department has directed servicers to delete adverse credit history associated with discharged loans. For individual claims, servicers generally report discharged loans in a final status such as paid in full, but negative marks from delinquency periods before the discharge may remain for up to seven years from the original missed payment. Pull your credit reports after you receive the discharge notification and dispute anything that does not reflect the resolution accurately.
Taxes on a Discharge
The American Rescue Plan Act temporarily excluded all federal student loan forgiveness from taxable income, and that exclusion expired on December 31, 2025. For borrower defense discharges occurring in 2026 or later, the forgiven amount is generally treated as cancellation of debt income, taxed at your ordinary income tax rate. You will receive a Form 1099-C reporting the cancelled amount and must include it on your federal return for the year of the discharge.
Permanent exclusions in the tax code cover certain other kinds of loan forgiveness, including discharges for death or total and permanent disability and forgiveness through qualifying public service employment. Borrower defense discharges do not fall neatly into those permanent exclusions, so the general rule of taxability applies now that the ARPA window has closed.
There is a potential escape. Under 26 U.S.C. § 108(a)(1)(B), you can exclude cancelled debt from income to the extent you were insolvent immediately before the discharge, meaning your total liabilities exceeded the fair market value of your total assets. If your student loan balance was $40,000 and you had $15,000 in assets against $60,000 in total debts, you were insolvent by $45,000 and could exclude the full $40,000 discharge from income. You claim the exclusion by filing IRS Form 982 with your tax return.
State treatment is separate. Most states follow the federal code, but some tax forgiven debt independently. Talk to a tax professional before filing to pin down both your federal and state obligations.
If You’re Denied Again
The regulation states that the Secretary’s reconsideration decision “is final as to the merits of the borrower defense and any discharge that may be granted on the claim.” There is no further administrative appeal within the Department of Education.
Judicial review in federal court is theoretically available under the Administrative Procedure Act. Under 5 U.S.C. § 706, a court can set aside agency action that is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law. In practice, courts give substantial deference to the Secretary of Education on borrower defense determinations, and the Higher Education Act does not create an independent private right of action. Winning in court means showing that the Department’s process was fundamentally flawed or its conclusion unsupported by the record, not simply that you disagree.
Federal litigation is expensive and slow, and few individual borrowers pursue it. More borrowers look at other federal relief after a final denial: income-driven repayment plans that cap monthly payments based on income, Public Service Loan Forgiveness for qualifying employment, or closed school discharge if your institution shut down during or shortly after your enrollment. A final borrower defense denial does not disqualify you from any of these.