Bond Parity: Liens, Covenants, and the Additional Bonds Test

Bond parity is a structural feature of municipal revenue bonds in which two or more series share an equal claim on the same pledged revenue stream, with no series holding priority over another. When an issuer like a water authority or toll road operator borrows against the same source of income multiple times over decades, parity keeps every series on equal footing regardless of when it was sold. The mechanics are set out in the bond resolution or trust indenture, enforced through specific financial tests, and reflected in the yield investors demand.

What Parity Actually Means for Bondholders

If a bond series is issued on a parity basis, it has the same priority of claim or lien against the pledged revenues as every other parity series. If the issuer runs into trouble and cannot pay all its obligations in full, no series jumps the line. Each receives its share pro rata. The Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board defines parity bonds as two or more issues or series that have the same priority of claim or lien against pledged revenues or other security.

That equal footing is the entire point. Most revenue-generating public projects need capital infusions over many years. A regional water system might issue bonds in 2020 to build a treatment plant, again in 2028 to expand distribution lines, and again in 2035 to upgrade aging infrastructure. Parity lets all three series share the same security at comparable borrowing costs, instead of each successive issue being pushed to the back of the line.

Parity vs. Subordinated Debt

The alternative to parity is subordination. A subordinated or junior lien bond explicitly accepts a lower-priority claim. Senior lien holders must be paid in full before junior lien holders receive anything. Subordination protects the earlier bondholders, but it makes later borrowing expensive, because investors buying the junior debt know they are last in line. That dynamic is exactly what parity is designed to avoid.

Where Parity Bonds Sit in the Revenue Waterfall

Pledged revenue moves through a defined order of allocation, often called the waterfall. The order depends on whether the bonds carry a gross revenue pledge or a net revenue pledge.

Under a gross revenue pledge, bondholders get paid first. Revenue flows to debt service before anything is spent on operating and maintenance, and then into reserve and renewal funds. This gives bondholders the strongest possible position, because the system’s operating expenses cannot eat into debt service payments.

Under a net revenue pledge, operating and maintenance costs come off the top. Only after those expenses are covered does the remaining revenue flow to debt service and then to reserves. Net pledges are more common, because most issuers need operational flexibility to keep the system running, and lenders accept that a functioning system is in everyone’s interest.

When multiple series share parity status, they all sit at the same level in this waterfall. A 2020 series and a 2035 series receive their debt service from the same pool at the same step, split proportionally. No series can divert revenue to itself ahead of another.

The Additional Bonds Test

The legal mechanism that establishes parity lives in the bond resolution or trust indenture. Within that document, the additional bonds covenant spells out the conditions the issuer must satisfy before selling new bonds on a parity basis with existing debt. The centerpiece of that covenant is the Additional Bonds Test, often called the ABT or parity test.

The ABT requires the issuer to demonstrate that its revenue can comfortably cover debt service on both the existing bonds and the proposed new bonds. The measure is a Debt Service Coverage Ratio: net revenue divided by total debt service. A typical ABT might require net revenue for the most recent fiscal year to equal at least 1.25 times the maximum annual debt service on all outstanding and proposed parity bonds combined. If the math doesn’t work, the issuer cannot sell additional parity debt.

Two versions of the test are common:

  • A historical earnings test uses audited financial data, typically requiring that revenue over one or two of the last three fiscal years met the coverage ratio. It relies on actual, verified numbers.
  • A projected earnings test uses an independent consultant’s forecast of future revenue. This becomes necessary when the new bonds will fund a facility that does not yet exist and has no operating history.

The projected test carries more uncertainty, and investors tend to price that in. A system with a long record of passing its historical ABT with comfortable margins inspires far more confidence than one leaning on an optimistic forecast of toll revenue from a highway that has not been built.

Rate Covenants and Reserve Funds

The ABT does not work alone. Two supporting mechanisms reinforce parity protection on an ongoing basis.

Rate Covenants

A rate covenant is the issuer’s binding promise to set user fees high enough to generate the required revenue. For a water utility, that means setting water rates at a level that covers operating expenses plus a specified margin above total debt service. Common thresholds run from 110% to 125% of annual debt service. If coverage starts slipping, the issuer is legally obligated to raise rates rather than let bondholders absorb the shortfall.

Rate increases are politically unpopular, and elected officials sometimes resist raising water or sewer rates even when the covenant demands it. That tension between covenant compliance and political reality is something credit analysts watch closely.

Debt Service Reserve Funds

The resolution typically requires the issuer to maintain a reserve fund that acts as a cushion if revenue dips temporarily. On parity debt, the reserve can be structured in two ways: as a common reserve securing all parity bonds, or as separate reserves for each series.

A common reserve recalculates its required balance whenever new parity bonds are issued, growing proportionally with total debt service. Separate reserves give the issuer more flexibility to size each fund independently, but they also mean one series might have a thicker cushion than another. The reserve fund requirement is generally sized as the lesser of 10% of par, maximum annual debt service, or 125% of average annual debt service.

Open Lien vs. Closed Lien

The additional bonds covenant also determines whether the structure is an open lien or a closed lien. That distinction shapes the issuer’s future borrowing capacity.

Open Lien

An open lien permits the issuer to sell additional parity bonds in the future, provided it passes the ABT each time. This is the dominant structure in public finance, because it accommodates the ongoing capital needs of large utility systems, transportation networks, and similar enterprises that require periodic reinvestment over decades.

The protection for existing bondholders under an open lien comes entirely from the strength of the ABT. A rigorous test with a high coverage requirement, say 1.50 times maximum annual debt service, gives current holders meaningful protection against dilution. A weak test at 1.10 times coverage leaves much less margin for error and signals that the issuer could pile on debt until everyone’s security is strained.

Closed Lien

A closed lien prohibits the issuer from ever selling additional bonds with an equal claim on the pledged revenue. Any future borrowing against the same revenue stream must be subordinated. That provides the strongest possible protection for original bondholders, because their claim can never be diluted.

The tradeoff is severe for the issuer. Every future borrowing carries a higher interest rate, because junior lien debt is inherently riskier. Closed liens show up most often in single-project financings or situations where the issuer does not expect significant future capital needs. They are rare for large, ongoing systems precisely because the long-term financing costs become prohibitive.

What Parity Means for Pricing and Credit Ratings

Parity structure drives both the credit rating an issuer receives and the interest rate it pays. Rating agencies treat the ABT as the primary mechanism protecting bondholders from excessive leverage. An issuer with a strong ABT requirement, solid historical coverage, and a clean record of covenant compliance earns a higher rating, which translates to lower borrowing costs across all parity series.

For investors, the key variables are the lien structure and the ABT threshold. A closed lien bond carries less credit risk and commands a lower yield than an open lien bond from the same issuer, because the closed lien investor knows their claim can never be diluted. Within open lien structures, the spread between a 1.50x ABT and a 1.10x ABT can be meaningful. The weaker the test, the more room the issuer has to layer on additional debt, and the more yield investors demand to compensate for that dilution risk.

For issuers, the choice is a long-term strategic decision. A closed lien minimizes the initial borrowing cost but locks in higher rates for all future subordinated debt. An open lien with a well-calibrated ABT provides decades of financing flexibility at competitive rates, provided the underlying system generates reliable, growing revenue. Most large public utility and transportation issuers land on the open lien approach for exactly that reason.

When Covenants Are Breached or the Issuer Fails

Covenant violations and payment defaults are not the same thing. Failing the ABT typically blocks the issuer from selling additional parity debt until revenue recovers. Failing the rate covenant triggers an obligation to raise fees, and persistent noncompliance can escalate to a formal event of default.

When a default does occur, remedies are generally exercised by the bond trustee on behalf of all bondholders. The trustee may sue for payment, seek court-ordered performance of the covenant obligations, or in some cases accelerate the debt, declaring all principal immediately due and payable. Because parity bonds share equal standing, acceleration of one series typically gives all parity holders the right to accelerate as well. Holders of a majority or supermajority of outstanding principal can usually direct the trustee’s actions.

In the rare event an issuer enters Chapter 9 bankruptcy, the treatment of parity bonds depends on whether they are special revenue bonds or general obligation bonds. Special revenue bonds, which include most parity debt backed by utility or toll revenue, receive favorable treatment. The Bankruptcy Code allows pledged special revenues to continue flowing to bondholders even after the filing, and the automatic stay that normally freezes creditor payments does not apply to special revenue bond debt service. General obligation bonds, by contrast, are treated as general unsecured debt in Chapter 9 and are subject to negotiation and potential restructuring under the plan of adjustment. For investors holding parity revenue bonds, that distinction is a meaningful source of comfort during periods of financial stress.