Bona Fide Loan: IRS Requirements and Tax Treatment

A bona fide loan is a transfer of money that creates a real debtor-creditor relationship: the borrower has an enforceable obligation to repay, the lender behaves like a lender, and because a genuine debt exists, the principal is not taxable income to the borrower and not a deduction for the lender. The label on the transaction is not what controls. If the IRS decides your “loan” was actually a gift, a dividend, or disguised wages, the tax consequences hit both sides, often with penalties and interest layered on top.

Who the IRS Scrutinizes

When a commercial bank writes a loan, no one questions whether it is real. The bank pulled credit, charged a market rate, took a lien, and will sue on default. Trouble starts when money moves between people who have reasons to be generous with each other.

Three relationships draw the most attention. A parent who hands a child a large sum and calls it a loan may actually be making a gift and skipping the gift tax return. A closely held corporation that advances cash to its sole shareholder with no repayment schedule may be distributing profits without paying dividend tax. An employer who “lends” money to a key employee and never asks for it back is likely paying compensation without withholding. In each case the label does not match the economics, and the IRS applies a multi-factor test to figure out which label is correct.

What Makes a Loan Bona Fide

Courts weigh several factors, and no single one decides the question. The core inquiry is whether the transaction looks and functions like something an arm’s-length lender would recognize as a loan.

A Written, Enforceable Promissory Note

A signed promissory note is the starting point. It should identify the principal, the interest rate, a fixed maturity date, and a repayment schedule, and it must be legally enforceable so the lender has the right to sue on default. Both parties should carry the debt on their own books. Without written documentation, the IRS has an easy argument that no real debt existed.

Interest at or Above the Applicable Federal Rate

The loan must carry a reasonable rate. For transactions between related parties, the floor is the Applicable Federal Rate, which the IRS publishes monthly.1Internal Revenue Service. Applicable Federal Rates The correct AFR depends on the loan’s term: the short-term rate applies to loans of three years or less, the mid-term rate covers loans over three years through nine years, and the long-term rate applies to anything beyond nine years.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1274 Charging less than the AFR triggers imputed interest rules discussed below.

A Real Repayment Schedule, Followed

Fixed, regular payments of principal and interest are among the strongest evidence that a loan is genuine. Vague terms like “pay it back when you can,” or repayment contingent entirely on the borrower’s future ability to pay, suggest no real expectation of repayment. The most compelling proof is a documented history of on-time payments, backed by bank records or canceled checks.

What the lender does when a payment is missed matters just as much. A lender who shrugs off missed payments, keeps extending the maturity date, or never sends a demand letter is behaving like someone who gave a gift. The IRS routinely uses the absence of collection efforts between related parties to reclassify transactions.

Collateral

An arm’s-length lender usually requires collateral proportional to the risk. Pledging collateral and then perfecting the security interest strongly supports bona fide status. For personal property, perfection means filing a UCC-1 financing statement identifying the debtor, the secured party, and the collateral.3Legal Information Institute. UCC Financing Statement For real estate, recording a mortgage or deed of trust does the same job. The absence of collateral does not automatically doom a loan, but it makes an IRS challenge easier, especially where the borrower’s creditworthiness is weak.

Borrower’s Ability to Repay

A prudent lender checks whether the borrower can actually service the debt before writing a check. The IRS looks at the borrower’s income, existing debts, and assets when the loan was made. Lending a large sum to someone clearly insolvent, or to an undercapitalized entity, suggests the lender never expected the money back. Even an informal evaluation, memorialized in writing, helps show the parties acted like a real creditor and debtor.

Tax Treatment When the Loan Holds Up

Once a transaction qualifies as genuine debt, standard rules for interest income, interest expense, and bad debts apply. The principal itself is not income to the borrower when received and not a deduction for the lender when advanced.

Interest Income and Expense

The lender reports interest received as ordinary income and must file Form 1099-INT if interest paid reaches at least $10 for the year.4Internal Revenue Service. About Form 1099-INT, Interest Income Whether the borrower can deduct the interest depends on how the funds were used: acquiring or improving a qualified residence can generate mortgage interest, buying investments can generate investment interest, and most personal interest remains nondeductible.5Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 505 – Interest Expense

Below-Market Loans and Imputed Interest

When a loan charges less than the AFR, the tax code treats it as if full interest were charged anyway. Under IRC Section 7872, the IRS imputes interest on three categories of below-market loans: gift loans, compensation-related loans, and corporation-shareholder loans.6GovInfo. 26 USC 7872 The difference between AFR interest and whatever the borrower actually pays is treated as if the lender transferred that amount to the borrower and the borrower paid it back as interest. The lender owes tax on the imputed interest, and depending on the relationship, the deemed transfer to the borrower is treated as a gift, added compensation, or a corporate distribution.

For demand loans, the imputed interest is recalculated each year at that year’s AFR. For term loans, the calculation is done upfront using the AFR in effect when the loan was made.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7872

Not every interest-free family loan triggers the rules. Section 7872 includes a $10,000 de minimis exception: if total outstanding loans between two individuals stay at or below $10,000, the imputed interest rules do not apply. A separate $10,000 de minimis rule covers compensation-related and corporation-shareholder loans. For gift loans where the outstanding balance stays at or below $100,000, imputed interest income is capped at the borrower’s actual net investment income for the year, and if the borrower had none, none is imputed. That $100,000 cushion disappears if one of the principal purposes of the arrangement is tax avoidance, or the moment the balance climbs past $100,000.

Bad Debt Deduction

If a bona fide loan becomes genuinely uncollectible, the lender can claim a bad debt deduction under IRC Section 166, and the treatment depends on whether the debt arose in the lender’s trade or business.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 166 – Bad Debts

  • A business bad debt is fully deductible as an ordinary loss, and partial write-offs are allowed if the lender can show the debt is only partially recoverable.
  • A non-business bad debt (personal and family loans) is treated as a short-term capital loss regardless of how long the loan was outstanding. It offsets capital gains first, then up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year ($1,500 if married filing separately), with any excess carried forward.9Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 409, Capital Gains and Losses

To claim the deduction the lender must show the loan was bona fide in the first place and that reasonable collection efforts were made before the write-off. A lender who never sent a demand letter or explored legal remedies will struggle to convince the IRS that the debt was real and that collection was truly hopeless.

What Happens If the IRS Says It Wasn’t a Loan

When the IRS concludes a purported loan was not genuine debt, it reclassifies the transfer based on the relationship between the parties. What was a tax-neutral exchange of debt becomes a taxable event, often with back taxes, interest, and penalties.

Reclassified as a Gift

Between family members, a failed loan is most often recast as a gift. The transferor is treated as having made a donative transfer and reports it on Form 709.10Internal Revenue Service. About Form 709 Because of the annual exclusion and the large lifetime basic exclusion amount, most people never write a gift tax check.11Internal Revenue Service. What’s New – Estate and Gift Tax Failing to file the return when required, however, keeps the statute of limitations from starting to run on that gift, which can create problems later during estate administration.

Reclassified as a Constructive Dividend

When a corporation advances money to a shareholder without the hallmarks of real debt, the IRS treats the transfer as a constructive dividend. The corporation gets no deduction. The shareholder reports the amount as income to the extent of the corporation’s accumulated earnings and profits, with any excess treated first as a tax-free return of stock basis and then as capital gain. Qualified dividend rates may soften the blow, but the shareholder loses the ability to treat the funds as tax-free loan proceeds.

Reclassified as Wages

An employer-to-employee “loan” with no meaningful repayment terms gets treated as compensation. The full amount becomes taxable wages subject to income tax withholding and FICA (Social Security at 6.2% and Medicare at 1.45% on both sides), and the employer must issue a corrected W-2.12Internal Revenue Service. About Form W-2 C, Corrected Wage and Tax Statements The reclassified compensation is deductible as a business expense, but the payroll tax liability and penalties usually swamp that benefit.

Accuracy-Related Penalties

On top of the tax itself, recharacterization often triggers the 20% accuracy-related penalty on the resulting underpayment. It applies when the underpayment is attributable to negligence, disregard of rules, or a substantial understatement of income tax.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6662 Calling a transfer a loan without any of the documentation or formalities described above is exactly the conduct that invites the penalty. Interest also runs from the original due date, compounding the cost when a reclassification reaches back several years.

How to Protect Bona Fide Status Up Front

The factors are well established, so the roadmap is straightforward. Build the record before the money moves, not during an audit.

  • Draft a promissory note with the principal, a stated interest rate at or above the current AFR for the term, a fixed maturity date, and a monthly or quarterly payment schedule. Both parties sign and date it.
  • Check the IRS’s monthly AFR publication and charge at least the applicable rate. Make interest payments by check or electronic transfer so there is a paper trail.
  • Keep to the schedule. The borrower should pay on time. If a payment is late, the lender should send a written reminder. Forgiving payments or repeatedly extending deadlines undermines the whole arrangement.
  • Secure the loan when it is practical. For larger loans, file a UCC-1 financing statement or record a mortgage. The filing fees are small compared with the protection.
  • Document the borrower’s ability to repay. Even an informal review of income and debts, saved as a note or email, shows the lender acted like a real creditor.
  • File the right forms. The lender should issue Form 1099-INT if interest received hits $10 or more and report interest income on their own return. Skipping these filings hands the IRS evidence that neither party treated the transaction as real debt.

None of this requires a lawyer, though consulting one is worthwhile for six-figure loans or complex corporate-shareholder arrangements. The recurring theme in Tax Court is that related parties who act like strangers in their lending arrangements almost always win, and those who rely on trust and informality almost always lose.