Across the Buy Now, Pay Later industry, roughly 2% of loans end in default, based on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s review of loans originated between 2019 and 2022.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt That is the headline BNPL default rate, and on its own it looks modest. The fuller picture is less flattering: 41% of users paid late at least once in the past year, most of these loans never appear on a credit report, and the federal rule that would have extended credit card protections to BNPL borrowers was pulled back in 2025.
How a BNPL Default Is Counted
A BNPL loan is treated as a default once it has gone 120 days past due, at which point the lender writes it off as a loss. The CFPB uses that 120-day charge-off threshold in its January 2025 report.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt The timing matters. A standard pay-in-four loan runs only about six weeks from start to finish, so a loan can sit unpaid for months after its last scheduled installment before it officially counts as a default.
Lenders report a few related figures. Gross loss rate measures total write-offs before any recovery. Net loss rate takes out whatever is clawed back through collections or debt sales. Delinquency rates track loans that are late but have not yet hit the charge-off line, and those numbers typically move first when borrowers come under stress.
What the Major Providers Report
Individual lenders publish their own numbers, which fill in the industry average. Klarna reported realized credit losses of 0.45% of volume in the second quarter of 2025, down from 0.48% a year earlier, with a provision for credit losses of 0.56% of gross merchandise volume.2Klarna Investors. Klarna Grows Q2 Revenue to $823m, Reports Continued Operating Profitability and Highest Number of On-Time Payments
Affirm uses a composite metric, Revenue Less Transaction Costs as a share of gross merchandise volume, which bundles funding, processing, and net credit losses together. That figure sat at 3.93% for its fiscal second quarter of 2026, at the top of the company’s 3% to 4% target range.3Affirm Investor Relations. Affirm FQ2 2026 Shareholder Letter On a plainer measure, Affirm’s U.S. monthly installment loans were 2.7% delinquent at 30-plus days and 0.8% delinquent at 90-plus days as of December 2025.4Affirm Investor Relations. Affirm FY Q2 2026 Earnings Supplement
These numbers paint a healthy industry. They also capture only loans that have formally been written off, which is a narrower view of borrower trouble than it first appears.
Late Payments Tell a Different Story
While around 2% of BNPL loans end in default, the share of users who struggle to pay on time is far larger. A 2025 survey found that 41% of BNPL borrowers paid late at least once in the preceding year, up from 34% the year before.5Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Buy Now, Pay Later: Recent Developments and Implications The gap between 2% and 41% is not a contradiction. A borrower who misses a payment by a week or two and then catches up never becomes a default statistic, but the cash-flow strain was real.
Those late payments carry costs of their own. About 4.1% of pay-in-four loans were assessed a late fee, with an average fee of $9.70 assessed and $5.70 actually collected.6EveryCRSReport.com. Buy Now, Pay Later: Policy Issues and Options for Congress Policies vary widely across providers. Afterpay charges up to $8 per missed installment, capped at 25% of the order value.7Afterpay. Is There a Cost to Using Afterpay? Affirm charges no late fees on any of its products.
Why BNPL Default Rates Stay Where They Are
The borrower profile is the single clearest driver of BNPL losses. Users of these products tend to be more financially stretched than the general population. Their credit card utilization averages 60% to 66%, nearly double the 34% average among consumers who have never used BNPL.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt CFPB research shows those utilization rates climb in the months leading up to a borrower’s first BNPL purchase, which is consistent with people turning to pay-in-four when other credit has tightened.8Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Research Reveals Heavy Buy Now, Pay Later Use Among Borrowers with High Credit Balances and Multiple Pay-in-Four Loans
Loan stacking adds to the risk. About 63% of BNPL borrowers took out multiple simultaneous loans at some point during the year studied, and a third used more than one BNPL provider.8Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Research Reveals Heavy Buy Now, Pay Later Use Among Borrowers with High Credit Balances and Multiple Pay-in-Four Loans Because most providers don’t share data with credit bureaus, no single lender can see a borrower’s full BNPL exposure. Someone could be running four pay-in-four loans across different apps, and each lender would see only its own.
The underwriting itself is lightweight. Most providers rely on proprietary scoring and soft credit pulls rather than full credit reports. Speed and conversion are central to the business model since providers earn merchant fees on each transaction, but faster approvals mean shallower risk assessment.
How BNPL Defaults Compare to Credit Cards
On a simple side-by-side, BNPL default rates look favorable. Credit card charge-offs across all banks hit 4.11% in the fourth quarter of 2025, according to the Federal Reserve.9Federal Reserve. Charge-Off and Delinquency Rates on Loans and Leases at Commercial Banks The New York Fed reported 4.8% of all outstanding consumer debt in some stage of delinquency by the end of 2025.10Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Household Debt Balances Grow Modestly; Early Delinquencies
The comparison is structurally misleading. A pay-in-four loan lives about six weeks and typically covers a modest purchase. A credit card balance can revolve for years. The short life of a BNPL loan simply gives it less time to deteriorate, which pulls the charge-off rate down.
A sharper comparison sits inside the CFPB’s own data. The same borrowers who defaulted on 2% of their BNPL loans during the 2019 to 2022 period defaulted on 10% of the credit cards they held.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt That five-to-one ratio suggests the BNPL model is not so much eliminating credit risk as moving it. Borrowers prioritize the short, fixed installments and let revolving debt slip.
What Happens If You Default
Miss a BNPL payment and most providers will freeze the account to new purchases and start sending reminders. After roughly 60 to 90 days of nonpayment, the debt may be declared in default and either handed to an in-house collections team or sold to a third-party collector.11Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. What Happens If I Can’t Pay Back a Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) Loan? Once a collector is involved, the debt can be reported to credit bureaus even if the original BNPL provider never did. A loan that was invisible to your credit file while you were paying can suddenly appear as a collection account after you stop.
There is a tax wrinkle too. If a lender cancels $600 or more of your debt, it must report the forgiven amount to the IRS on Form 1099-C, and the IRS generally treats cancelled debt as taxable income.12Internal Revenue Service. About Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt Most individual pay-in-four loans fall well below that threshold, but a borrower who defaults on several loans with the same provider could cross it if balances are aggregated.
Why the True Default Picture Is Hard to See
Credit bureau reporting is the biggest gap in understanding BNPL risk. As of mid-2025, Affirm was the only major provider consistently reporting its pay-in-four performance, and only to Experian. Other large providers were not consistently furnishing pay-in-four data to any of the three national bureaus.6EveryCRSReport.com. Buy Now, Pay Later: Policy Issues and Options for Congress Equifax built a framework to include BNPL installment loans on credit reports starting in February 2022, but lender participation is voluntary and the data is suppressed from existing FICO and VantageScore calculations.13Equifax. Buy Now, Pay Later Credit Reporting
The practical result: BNPL loans remain largely invisible to traditional credit scoring. A borrower juggling five overdue pay-in-four loans can still show a clean credit report, and a lender pulling that report would have no way to see the exposure. The Richmond Fed has flagged this directly, noting that because pay-in-four loans involve no hard inquiries and little performance reporting, “BNPL usage and its associated risks are difficult to measure at both individual and aggregate levels.”5Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Buy Now, Pay Later: Recent Developments and Implications Longer-term point-of-sale installment loans marketed under the BNPL label are typically reported and scored, creating an odd split where the shorter, riskier product escapes attention while the more conventional installment loan does not.
What the 2025 Regulatory Rollback Changed
In May 2024, the CFPB issued an interpretive rule classifying BNPL lenders as credit card providers under the Truth in Lending Act, which would have required them to investigate disputes, pause payments during investigations, process refunds on returned merchandise, and provide periodic billing statements.14Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Takes Action to Ensure Consumers Can Dispute Charges and Obtain Refunds on Buy Now, Pay Later Loans That rule was withdrawn on May 12, 2025. The CFPB said it would not prioritize enforcement based on the rule and signaled it was considering rescinding it entirely.15Federal Register. Interpretive Rules, Policy Statements, and Advisory Opinions Withdrawal
For borrowers, this means BNPL does not carry the same federal dispute and refund protections as a credit card. If you have a billing error or want to dispute a charge on a credit card, federal law requires the issuer to investigate and pause collection during the process. With BNPL, those protections depend on each provider’s own policies. The CFPB’s earlier inquiry had flagged concerns about regulatory arbitrage, data harvesting, and hidden debt accumulation, but the enforcement mechanism intended to address them is no longer active.16Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Opens Inquiry Into Buy Now, Pay Later Credit Read a provider’s dispute and refund terms before you buy, and treat each installment as a firm obligation, because the safety nets that apply to traditional credit products largely do not apply here.