Barnum Financial Group Lawsuit: CFO Embezzlement and Varela Case

Barnum Financial Group, a Shelton, Connecticut, financial services firm operating as a general agency of MassMutual, has been connected to several notable legal matters: a federal embezzlement prosecution of its former chief financial officer, a civil lawsuit that reached the Second Circuit over life insurance conversion advice, regulatory actions against its affiliated broker-dealer MML Investors Services, a disciplinary case involving a former advisor, and a handful of consumer complaints. Taken together, these are the cases that show up when people search for a Barnum Financial Group lawsuit or regulatory history.

Former CFO Convicted of Embezzling $1.5 Million

The most serious case directly against the firm was internal. Carolina Guerreno, hired as Barnum’s CFO in 2018, stole $1,532,207.24 from the company between January 2019 and February 2021 by redirecting electronic payments into her own accounts, credit cards, and home equity line.

Prosecutors said she manipulated the company’s financial systems by altering contract-employee banking information to substitute her own details and by creating duplicate payees linked to her personal accounts, then deleting the entries after the money moved.1Hartford Business Journal. Ex-CFO Gets Two Years in Prison After Stealing $1.5M From Employer The funds went toward paying off her mortgage 21 years early, an $81,400 Audi Q7, home renovations, and international vacations.2New Haven Independent. Woman Who Stole From Shelton Company Sent to Federal Prison

Barnum discovered the scheme and fired Guerreno in February 2021.3U.S. Department of Justice. Fairfield Woman Sentenced to 2 Years in Federal Prison for Embezzling $1.5 Million4U.S. Secret Service. Fairfield Woman Admits Embezzling $1.5 Million5Connecticut Post. Ex-CFO of Shelton Firm Gets 2 Years in Prison for Stealing

Varela v. Barnum Financial Group

The reported civil lawsuit against the firm is Varela v. Barnum Financial Group, decided by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in 2016. It came out of a life insurance conversion that never happened.

Marta Barbeosch Varela sued on behalf of herself and the estate of her late husband, William Barbeosch, a former fiduciary officer at a SunTrust Banks subsidiary who participated in an employer-sponsored group life insurance plan administered by MetLife. After his employment status changed, Barbeosch had 31 days to convert the group policy to an individual policy. Varela alleged that Peter Greco, a Barnum financial services representative, met with her husband on April 18, 2011, and told him the 31 days ran from that meeting. The deadline actually ran from the earlier employment change, ending around May 2, 2011. Barbeosch died on May 13, 2011, without converting the policy.6CaseMine. Varela v. Barnum Financial Group, 15-2876-cv

Varela brought state-law claims for negligence, negligent misrepresentation, and breach of fiduciary duty. The case turned on a threshold point: Barnum Financial Group is not an independent legal entity but an office and trade name of MetLife, which was both the insurer and claims administrator for the ERISA-governed plan. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed the claims as preempted by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. On March 22, 2016, the Second Circuit affirmed, applying the test from Aetna Health Inc. v. Davila and finding that MetLife was a “core ERISA entity” and that the conversion process was a “central ERISA function.”6CaseMine. Varela v. Barnum Financial Group, 15-2876-cv7Rivkin Radler LLP. From the Courts The practical result was that Varela could not recover in state court for the alleged misadvice.

Regulatory Actions Against MML Investors Services

Barnum representatives offer securities through MML Investors Services, LLC, a MassMutual subsidiary that is a registered broker-dealer and investment adviser.8Barnum Financial Group. Barnum Relationships Barnum itself is a trade name, not a separately registered broker-dealer, so MML’s regulatory record is the one that governs Barnum-branded securities activity. MML Investors Services has 30 recorded disclosures on its FINRA BrokerCheck profile, a category that covers customer complaints, arbitrations, regulatory actions, and employment terminations.9FINRA. MML Investors Services Firm Summary

Recent regulatory actions include:

  • A $4 million fine from Massachusetts in September 2021 for alleged failures in supervising broker social media activity.
  • A December 2021 FINRA action requiring more than $617,000 in restitution for failures in supervising 529 college-savings plan share-class recommendations.
  • A $250,000 Massachusetts fine in August 2022, plus roughly $46,000 in disgorgement and restitution to six clients, over failures to supervise variable annuity recommendations and disclose broker commissions.
  • A $250,000 FINRA fine in May 2023 for failing to timely report disclosable events on regulatory filings.9FINRA. MML Investors Services Firm Summary

The Adam Belardino Advisor Case

Adam Belardino worked out of Barnum’s Elmsford, New York, office from 2007 to 2019. MML Investors Services terminated him in March 2019 after an internal investigation triggered by a customer complaint that alleged excessive trading, misrepresentation of account values, and failure to comply with liquidation requests. That single dispute settled for about $1.5 million.10Westfair Communications. FINRA Suspends New Rochelle Financial Adviser for Dodging Testimony

Three other customer disputes settled for smaller amounts: roughly $69,400 over allegations of unauthorized transactions and forged signatures, about $51,100 involving misrepresentation of a variable life insurance policy, and approximately $6,800 over unauthorized mutual fund trades with invalid signatures.10Westfair Communications. FINRA Suspends New Rochelle Financial Adviser for Dodging Testimony

FINRA later sought testimony from Belardino about his conduct. He failed to appear for on-the-record testimony in late 2020, and FINRA suspended him in February 2021. A formal disciplinary proceeding seeking monetary sanctions followed in May 2021.10Westfair Communications. FINRA Suspends New Rochelle Financial Adviser for Dodging Testimony

Consumer Complaints on File

Barnum’s Better Business Bureau profile shows four consumer complaints over the most recent three-year period. All four were categorized as answered by the business, but consumers either rejected the response or did not confirm satisfaction. The complaints centered on communication failures, including difficulty reaching representatives and lack of follow-up, along with concerns about access to funds after an advisor left the company and questions about data privacy during the life insurance solicitation process.11Better Business Bureau. Barnum Financial Group LLC Complaints