AU-C Section 240 is the AICPA auditing standard that governs how an auditor considers fraud during a financial statement audit of a nonpublic entity. It requires the auditor to plan and perform the audit with the possibility of fraud in mind, identify and assess the risks of material misstatement caused by fraud, respond to those risks with targeted procedures, perform certain procedures on every engagement regardless of risk assessment, and communicate findings to management, governance, and in some cases regulators. Its counterpart for public company audits is PCAOB AS 2401, which is substantially similar.1AICPA & CIMA. Exposure Draft, Proposed SAS Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements
What the Standard Covers
The standard applies whenever an auditor performs a financial statement audit under generally accepted auditing standards. The objective is reasonable assurance that the statements are free of material misstatement, whether caused by error or by fraud.
The line between the two is deliberate. Error is unintentional: a transposed number, a misapplied accounting rule. Fraud is intentional. AU-C 240 focuses on two categories:
- Fraudulent financial reporting. Management or others intentionally misstate the financial statements by manipulating records, fabricating transactions, or misapplying accounting principles.
- Misappropriation of assets. Someone steals from the entity in a way that causes the statements to be materially wrong. Embezzlement, skimming receipts, and diverting assets for personal use all fit here.
The two categories call for different audit responses. Fraudulent reporting typically involves management and is harder to detect because those responsible often have the authority to override controls. Asset theft can happen at any level and leaves different footprints in the records.
Professional Skepticism
AU-C 240 requires the auditor to maintain professional skepticism throughout the engagement. Audit evidence has to be evaluated with a questioning mind. The auditor should not assume management is dishonest, and should not assume unquestioned honesty either.
In practice this means looking beyond management’s explanations and seeking corroborating evidence from independent sources. When responses to inquiries are inconsistent, vague, or implausible, the auditor digs deeper rather than accepting the explanation. Past experience with a client’s honesty does not justify a lower bar for the current engagement.
The standard also acknowledges that even a properly performed audit cannot guarantee every fraud will be caught. Collusion, forged documents, and coordinated cover stories can defeat controls that would otherwise catch a problem. Those limitations are a reason to be more rigorous, not less; they do not reduce the auditor’s obligation to perform the required procedures.
Required Risk Assessment Procedures
Before responding to fraud risks, the auditor has to identify them. AU-C 240 mandates a specific set of procedures during planning, and the results feed directly into decisions about what substantive testing to perform.
Engagement Team Discussion
Every audit must open with a discussion among the engagement team about how and where the entity’s financial statements could be materially misstated due to fraud. The standard treats this as brainstorming, not a checkbox. It has to cover both fraudulent financial reporting and asset misappropriation, and team members are expected to share what they know about the client, known risk factors, and areas where management has both the ability and the incentive to manipulate results.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit
Inquiries of Management and Others
The auditor must make direct inquiries of management about their own assessment of fraud risk, the process they use to identify and respond to fraud risks, any specific risks they have already flagged, and their knowledge of any actual, suspected, or alleged fraud.
If the entity has an internal audit function, the auditor asks about their fraud-detection procedures, findings, and whether management responded to those findings.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit Those charged with governance, typically the audit committee, get their own set of inquiries: their views on fraud risks, their oversight of management’s processes, and any fraud they know about.
These inquiries produce information the auditor needs and also create opportunities to compare accounts. When management, the board, and internal audit tell different stories about the same subject, that inconsistency is itself a red flag.
Analytical Procedures
The auditor performs analytical procedures during planning to spot unusual or unexpected relationships that could signal fraud.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit A sudden jump in receivables turnover, a spike in period-end sales without a clear business reason, or gross margins that diverge from industry norms can all point to revenue manipulation or other issues that warrant a closer look.
The Fraud Triangle
AU-C 240 structures the risk assessment around three conditions that are generally present when fraud occurs. The auditor has to identify risk factors related to each.
- Incentive or pressure. Someone has a reason to commit fraud. Management may face pressure to meet earnings forecasts or debt covenants. An employee may be dealing with personal financial problems. Compensation tied heavily to financial performance creates a direct motive to inflate results.
- Opportunity. The environment allows fraud to happen. Weak internal controls, poor segregation of duties, ineffective board oversight, and complex organizational structures all create openings. Management has more opportunity than other employees because it can override the controls meant to prevent this kind of manipulation.
- Rationalization or attitude. The person can justify the act internally. This shows up in a culture that pushes aggressive accounting interpretations, dismisses regulatory compliance, keeps a strained relationship with auditors, or fails to correct known control weaknesses.
These conditions rarely appear alone. An auditor who spots one should look harder for the other two.
Revenue Recognition Is Presumed a Fraud Risk
AU-C 240 goes further than the general framework by establishing a rebuttable presumption that fraud risk exists in revenue recognition. The auditor must evaluate which types of revenue, revenue transactions, or assertions give rise to fraud risk on that basis.3American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Supplement No. 2 to Fraud Exposure Draft – Mapping of Extant AU-C Section 240
The presumption can be rebutted only in limited circumstances. An entity with a single type of simple revenue transaction, such as leasehold income from one rental property, might justify a conclusion that no fraud risk exists in revenue. When the auditor rebuts the presumption, the reasons must be documented in the workpapers. In most engagements with any complexity, the presumption stands and the auditor designs specific procedures to address it.
Responding to Assessed Fraud Risks
Once risks are identified and assessed, AU-C 240 requires responses at two levels.
Overall Responses
At the financial statement level, the auditor adjusts the general design of the audit. That can mean assigning team members with specialized skills, such as forensic accountants or IT specialists, to high-risk areas. The auditor also evaluates whether the entity’s selection and application of accounting principles could itself indicate fraudulent reporting, paying particular attention to subjective measurements and complex transactions. Heightened professional skepticism across the engagement is a required overall response whenever fraud risks are assessed.
Assertion-Level Responses
At the assertion level, the auditor tailors procedures to the specific risks. If the risk involves fictitious sales, confirmations might be modified to verify not just balances but the actual terms of sale. Inventory counts might be unannounced or performed at unexpected locations. Computer-assisted audit techniques can scan the full population of journal entries for patterns that suggest manipulation, such as entries posted after hours, round-dollar adjustments, or entries made by people who don’t normally have access.
For risks involving complex valuations, financial instruments, or fair value measurements, the auditor may bring in an independent specialist to review the models and test the underlying assumptions.
Mandatory Procedures for Management Override
This is the hardest line the standard draws. The risk that management can override internal controls exists in every audit, regardless of the entity’s size, industry, or control environment. A favorable risk assessment does not remove it. Three procedures are required on every engagement.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit
Testing Journal Entries and Other Adjustments
The auditor tests the appropriateness of journal entries recorded in the general ledger and other adjustments made during the preparation of the financial statements. The focus is on entries posted at period-end, entries made by people who don’t typically post them, entries with no supporting documentation or vague descriptions, and entries to accounts that are rarely used. This requires enough understanding of the client’s reporting process to know which entries look normal and which don’t.
Reviewing Accounting Estimates for Bias
The auditor performs a retrospective review of prior-year accounting estimates by comparing what management estimated to what actually happened. When estimates consistently skew in the same direction, that pattern suggests bias rather than honest misjudgment. Estimates selected for review should come from significant accounts where fraud risk has been assessed.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit
Evaluating Unusual Significant Transactions
The auditor evaluates the business rationale for significant transactions that fall outside the entity’s normal course of business or otherwise look unusual. Related-party transactions, deals lacking a clear economic purpose, and arrangements with unusual terms all warrant scrutiny. The auditor reads the underlying documentation, verifies that the transaction was properly authorized, and assesses whether the financial capacity of the other parties supports the claimed terms.
When Fraud Is Identified
Finding fraud triggers obligations beyond the standard audit workflow.
Evaluating the Impact
If the auditor concludes that the statements are, or may be, materially misstated as a result of fraud, the auditor must evaluate the implications for the audit. This connects to opinion formation under AU-C Section 700. A material misstatement management refuses to correct leads to a modified opinion; the nature of the modification depends on whether the misstatement is pervasive or isolated and whether the auditor can quantify its effects.
Considering Withdrawal
Some situations force the auditor to consider withdrawing from the engagement entirely. AU-C 240 identifies three circumstances that typically raise the question: the entity refuses to take appropriate action even when the fraud is not material, audit procedures indicate a significant risk of material and pervasive fraud, or the auditor has serious concerns about the competence or integrity of management or those charged with governance.
An auditor who withdraws must discuss the decision and its reasons with the appropriate level of management and those charged with governance. The auditor must also determine whether any professional or legal obligation requires reporting the withdrawal to the party that engaged the auditor or to regulatory authorities.
Communication and Reporting
The standard sets a layered communication structure that escalates based on who is involved and how serious the matter is.
To Management
Whenever the auditor identifies fraud or obtains information indicating fraud may exist, the matter must be communicated promptly to the appropriate level of management, meaning at least one level above the people who appear to be involved. There is no materiality threshold for this initial notification. Even minor theft by a low-level employee is reported to management.
To Those Charged With Governance
The auditor communicates directly to those charged with governance, typically the audit committee, when the fraud involves management, employees with significant roles in internal control, or anyone else if the fraud results in a material misstatement. When management is suspected, the communication must include a discussion of the nature, timing, and extent of the additional audit procedures needed to complete the engagement. Other fraud-related matters relevant to the governance body’s oversight also get communicated when professional judgment calls for it.
To Regulators
For nonpublic entities, the auditor’s duty of client confidentiality generally prevents disclosure to outside parties unless a specific legal or regulatory requirement demands it. AU-C 240 does not impose a blanket duty to report fraud to law enforcement.
For public companies, the rules are more demanding. Section 10A of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 creates a specific escalation path when an auditor detects a likely illegal act during a financial statement audit. The auditor first determines whether the act likely occurred and whether it could materially affect the statements. If so, the auditor informs management and ensures the audit committee or board is adequately notified. If senior management fails to take timely and appropriate remedial action, the auditor must report its conclusions directly to the board.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 U.S. Code 78j-1 – Audit Requirements
Once the board receives that report, the company must notify the SEC within one business day and send the auditor a copy of the notice. If the auditor does not receive that copy within the one-business-day window, the auditor faces a choice: resign from the engagement, or furnish its own report directly to the SEC.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 U.S. Code 78j-1 – Audit Requirements
Documentation
AU-C 240 requires thorough workpaper documentation at every stage. The auditor must document:
- The significant decisions reached during the engagement team discussion, including who participated and when and how it occurred.
- The identified and assessed risks of material misstatement due to fraud at both the financial statement level and the assertion level.
- The overall responses to fraud risks at the financial statement level and the nature, timing, and extent of specific procedures performed, with a clear link back to the assessed risks.
- The results of the three mandatory procedures addressing management override of controls.
- All fraud-related communications made to management, those charged with governance, regulators, or others.
- If the auditor concluded that the presumption of fraud risk in revenue recognition does not apply, the reasons supporting that conclusion.
The standard is designed so that an experienced auditor who was not part of the engagement could review the workpapers and understand what fraud risks were identified, what was done about them, and why the auditor reached the conclusions in the report.
Proposed Revisions
The AICPA’s Auditing Standards Board has issued an exposure draft that would supersede AU-C 240 with a new Statement on Auditing Standards.5AICPA & CIMA. AICPA Seeks Comment on Proposed Update to Auditors’ Responsibilities Related to Fraud The proposal would broaden the definition of fraud to explicitly include acts by third parties, treat the risk of management override as a fraud risk at the financial statement level, and expand the auditor’s obligations around fraud-related risks tied to revenue transactions. It also introduces a “stand-back” provision requiring the auditor to reconsider, near the end of the audit, whether accumulated evidence changes the fraud risk assessment. The effective date has not been finalized, but a final version could change several of the procedures above and is worth tracking.