Attestation Engagements: Types, Standards, and SOC Reports

Attestation engagements are independent services performed by CPAs to evaluate and report on subject matter that falls outside a traditional financial statement audit. They come in three types — examinations, reviews, and agreed-upon procedures — and each provides a different level of assurance about whatever is being evaluated. The professional rules for these engagements sit in the Statements on Standards for Attestation Engagements (SSAEs) issued by the AICPA and codified as the AT-C sections.1AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSAEs – Currently Effective

What Every Attestation Engagement Requires

Five elements have to be present before a CPA can perform this kind of work: three distinct parties, identifiable subject matter, suitable criteria, sufficient appropriate evidence, and a written report. Miss one and the engagement cannot proceed under attestation standards.

The three parties are the practitioner (the CPA), the responsible party (usually management, which makes the assertion about the subject matter), and the intended users (whoever will rely on the report). A technology company’s management might assert that its data security controls meet certain standards, and the company’s clients would be the intended users relying on that conclusion.

The subject matter is whatever is being evaluated, and this is where attestation stands apart from auditing. It can be internal control effectiveness, regulatory compliance, call center response times, sustainability metrics, or cybersecurity practices. It only needs to be capable of consistent evaluation against identifiable benchmarks.

Those benchmarks are the suitable criteria — the standards the practitioner measures the subject matter against. Criteria must be objective, measurable, complete, and relevant. Internal control work often uses the COSO Internal Control Integrated Framework.2Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. Internal Control Cybersecurity attestation typically uses the Trust Services Criteria published by the AICPA.

The practitioner then gathers evidence at a level scaled to the type of engagement, and issues a written report identifying the subject matter, the criteria, the work performed, and the conclusion or findings.

Examination Engagements

An examination provides the highest level of assurance available in attestation work: reasonable assurance, which is high but not absolute. The practitioner performs extensive procedures — inspection, confirmation, recalculation, and detailed testing — to support a positive opinion on whether the subject matter conforms to the criteria.3AICPA. AT-C Section 205 – Assertion-Based Examination Engagements

The rigor parallels a financial statement audit. Transactions and controls get tested, external parties corroborate information, and everything is documented. The report expresses a positive opinion, typically phrased as “the subject matter is in accordance with the criteria, in all material respects” or “the responsible party’s assertion is fairly stated, in all material respects.”3AICPA. AT-C Section 205 – Assertion-Based Examination Engagements

Assertion-Based and Direct Examinations

Examinations come in two forms. In an assertion-based examination under AT-C Section 205, the responsible party provides a written assertion about the subject matter, and the practitioner opines on whether that assertion is fairly stated. Management says “our controls are effective,” and the CPA evaluates that claim.

A direct examination under AT-C Section 206, introduced by SSAE 21, works differently. The practitioner measures the subject matter directly against the criteria without needing a written assertion from the responsible party. Both forms produce reasonable assurance, but the direct examination gives practitioners flexibility when a formal written assertion isn’t practical.

When the Opinion Isn’t Clean

Not every examination ends with an unqualified opinion. When the practitioner finds a material misstatement, the opinion becomes qualified: the subject matter conforms to the criteria “except for” the identified issue. If the problems are pervasive, the practitioner issues an adverse opinion. When the practitioner cannot gather enough evidence to form a conclusion, the report contains a disclaimer of opinion explaining why.3AICPA. AT-C Section 205 – Assertion-Based Examination Engagements

Review Engagements

A review provides limited assurance. That’s substantially lower than an examination but still meaningful. Procedures consist primarily of inquiry and analytical procedures rather than the detailed testing and external confirmation an examination requires.4American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 22 – Review Engagements

The conclusion is sometimes called “negative assurance” in practice. Rather than a positive opinion, the practitioner states whether they became aware of any material modifications that should be made. In effect: “nothing came to our attention that indicates the subject matter needs to be changed.” That’s a fundamentally different statement than “we tested this thoroughly and it passes.”4American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 22 – Review Engagements

The reduced scope makes reviews less expensive than examinations, which is the point. When intended users want more than zero independent verification but don’t need the rigor of a full examination, a review fits. The report must explicitly note that procedures are substantially less in extent than an examination and that the assurance level is correspondingly lower.4American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 22 – Review Engagements

Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements

An agreed-upon procedures (AUP) engagement is the most flexible attestation service. The practitioner performs only the specific procedures the engaging party requests and reports the factual findings. No opinion, no assurance. Just “here is what we did and here is what we found.”

An engaging party might ask the practitioner to recalculate payment terms on a set of invoices and compare contract provisions against internal records. The report would state something like “the average payment term across the sampled invoices was 45 days” without any conclusion about whether that figure is good, bad, or compliant. Users draw their own conclusions.

SSAE 19 changed these engagements significantly by updating AT-C Section 215. Under previous standards, AUP reports were restricted to the specific parties who agreed to the procedures, on the reasoning that outside parties wouldn’t understand whether the limited procedures were adequate for their purposes. SSAE 19 removed that restriction and allows general-use AUP reports. The updated standard report language alerts readers that the procedures and findings may not be suitable for their specific purposes, shifting responsibility to the reader rather than limiting distribution.5AICPA & CIMA. AICPA Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 19

Common uses include grant compliance, royalty calculations, and contractual performance metrics — narrow data points that need verification without the cost of a full examination or review.

SOC Reports: The Most Common Attestation in Practice

The most widely recognized attestation engagements are Service Organization Control (SOC) reports. If your company uses a cloud vendor, payment processor, or any third-party service provider handling sensitive data, you’ve probably seen one or been asked to produce one.

SOC 1 reports focus on a service organization’s controls that could affect a client’s financial reporting. Payroll processors, claims administrators, and payment processing companies typically undergo SOC 1 examinations so their clients can rely on the financial data flowing through those systems.

SOC 2 reports cover a broader set of controls based on the AICPA’s Trust Services Criteria: security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. These are the reports SaaS vendors, data centers, and cloud providers produce to demonstrate their security posture. SOC 2 reports are typically shared under nondisclosure agreements rather than posted publicly.

SOC 3 reports contain the same subject matter as SOC 2 but are designed for general distribution. They omit the detailed control descriptions and test results, which makes them suitable for posting on a company’s website. A SOC 3 is essentially the public-facing summary of a SOC 2.

Type I and Type II Reports

SOC reports also come in two versions based on timing. A Type I report evaluates the design of controls at a single point in time: the controls exist and are appropriately designed as of a specific date. A Type II report tests the operating effectiveness of those controls over a period of at least six months. Type II reports carry more weight because they demonstrate the controls actually worked consistently, not just that they existed on paper on one day.

How Attestation Differs from Audits and Compilations

It’s easy to lump attestation engagements together with audits and compilations, but they serve different purposes under different professional standards.

An audit, governed by Statements on Auditing Standards (SAS), expresses an opinion on historical financial statements prepared under GAAP.6Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AU Section 150 – Generally Accepted Auditing Standards The scope is fixed to financial reporting. An examination engagement provides a similar level of assurance but applies to a much broader range of subject matter: internal controls, regulatory compliance, cybersecurity, sustainability, or anything measurable against suitable criteria. Both produce positive opinions, but the governing standards and the universe of subject matter are different.

Compilations sit at the other end. In a compilation, the practitioner presents management’s information in financial statement form without performing any procedures to verify it. The compilation report explicitly states that no assurance is provided and that the practitioner has not audited or reviewed the statements. Compilations are governed by Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services (SSARS), not the attestation standards.7Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. PCAOB AT Section 101 – Attest Engagements

Even an AUP engagement, the lowest-assurance attestation service, involves more work than a compilation. The AUP practitioner applies specific procedures and reports verifiable findings. The compilation practitioner does neither.

Independence and Which Standards Apply

Independence is a non-negotiable requirement for any CPA performing attestation work. The practitioner must maintain intellectual honesty and impartiality throughout the engagement and reach unbiased conclusions.7Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. PCAOB AT Section 101 – Attest Engagements A financial interest in the client, certain prohibited services provided to the same client, or any other threat that can’t be adequately addressed will disqualify the engagement before it starts.

When a CPA firm also provides non-attestation services to an attestation client, such as bookkeeping, tax preparation, or consulting, those services must be structured so that client management retains all decision-making responsibility. Management must oversee the non-attest work, evaluate its results, and accept responsibility for the output. Without that, independence is compromised and the attestation engagement is off the table.

Which set of standards applies depends on the entity. The AICPA’s SSAEs govern attestation engagements for nonissuers — private companies and other entities not subject to SEC oversight. Public companies and broker-dealers fall under the PCAOB’s attestation standards.1AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSAEs – Currently Effective The concepts overlap significantly, but specific requirements and report formats can differ.

How an Attestation Engagement Runs

Whatever the type, every attestation engagement follows the same basic arc: acceptance, planning, procedures, and reporting.

At acceptance, the practitioner confirms that the preconditions exist. The subject matter must be identifiable and evaluable, suitable criteria must be available, and the responsible party must acknowledge its responsibilities. If management won’t provide necessary representations or no suitable criteria exist, the practitioner declines. Once preconditions are confirmed, an engagement letter spells out the subject matter, the criteria, the type of service, and the level of assurance.

Planning is scaled to the engagement type. For examinations, that means a detailed risk assessment, materiality thresholds, and decisions on the nature, timing, and extent of procedures. For reviews, planning is less intensive and focused on designing effective inquiries and analytical procedures. For AUP work, planning is largely about confirming the specific procedures the engaging party wants performed.

Performing procedures is where the types diverge most. Examinations involve inspection, confirmation with external parties, recalculation, and testing of controls. Reviews rely on targeted inquiries and analytical procedures designed to identify unusual patterns. AUP engagements involve executing the agreed procedures and documenting factual findings. All evidence must be documented thoroughly enough to support the final report.

The practitioner then evaluates the accumulated evidence against the criteria and issues the report. For an examination, the evidence must provide a reasonable basis for a positive opinion. For a review, it must support the practitioner’s statement about whether they became aware of needed modifications. If the practitioner cannot gather sufficient evidence, the result is a qualified opinion, a disclaimer, or a scope limitation. Gaps do not get filled with assumptions. All attestation reports must include the word “independent” in the title and clearly describe the scope of work performed.4American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 22 – Review Engagements