Whether REITs are redeemable depends on which kind you own. Shares of a publicly traded REIT aren’t redeemed by the REIT itself at all — you sell them to another investor on a stock exchange. Non-traded REITs are partially redeemable through a share repurchase program the sponsor can cap, pause, or shut down. Private REITs are generally not redeemable in any practical sense; your money stays in until the sponsor runs a liquidity event.
Redemption and Market Sale Are Not the Same Thing
Two different mechanisms let you exit a REIT, and mixing them up produces bad expectations. Redemption means the REIT itself buys your shares back, usually at a price it sets based on its estimated net asset value. A market sale means you find another investor to buy your shares on an exchange, at whatever price supply and demand produce that day. Publicly traded REITs give you the second. Non-traded REITs give you a limited version of the first. Private REITs give you almost neither.
Publicly Traded REITs: Sell Through Your Broker
Publicly traded REITs list on major stock exchanges and sit in your brokerage account like any other stock.1Investor.gov. Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) You place a sell order, a buyer on the exchange takes the other side, and settlement typically completes within one business day. The REIT itself has no obligation to buy your shares back. These are not redeemable securities in the technical sense, but they’re highly liquid because the market absorbs them.
Your exit price is whatever the market pays at that moment, not the appraised value of the buildings the REIT owns. A publicly traded REIT can trade at a premium or discount to its underlying real estate for months at a time, and share prices can swing with broader market sentiment even when rental income is steady. Most major brokerages charge no commission on the trade.
Non-Traded REITs: The Share Repurchase Program
Non-traded REITs don’t list on an exchange, so there’s no open market where you can find a buyer. To offer some liquidity, most sponsors run a Share Repurchase Program that lets you sell shares back to the REIT at a price tied to its most recently estimated net asset value per share. Treat this as a discretionary program, not a right. The board can restrict, suspend, or terminate it at any time without notice.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin – Non-traded REITs
Every repurchase program caps how many shares it will buy back in a given period. A common structure limits repurchases to around 2% of net asset value per month or 5% per quarter. When requests exceed the cap, each investor’s request is filled pro rata, and the unfilled portion has to be resubmitted later. During 2022 and 2023, several high-profile non-traded REITs hit their quarterly caps and gated redemptions for months at a stretch. Investors who wanted out had no mechanism to get out.
If the program is suspended outright, your realistic options narrow to two. You wait for repurchases to resume, or you wait for a full liquidity event such as an exchange listing or a portfolio sale. Secondary market platforms sometimes facilitate investor-to-investor trades of non-traded REIT shares, but prices there run at steep discounts to NAV. Buyers on those platforms demand a significant cut for absorbing the illiquidity you’re trying to escape.
What the Exit Actually Costs
Even when the repurchase program is open, the math on getting out early is harsh. Non-traded REITs charge upfront fees — selling commissions, dealer manager fees, and organizational costs — that can consume up to 15% of your initial investment.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin – Non-traded REITs On a $100,000 investment, as little as $85,000 ever reaches real estate. Those fees are gone whether you hold for one year or ten.
On top of the upfront load, many non-traded REITs apply a short-term trading discount to early redemptions. Shares held less than a year are commonly repurchased at only 95% of estimated NAV per share, and some programs discount by as much as 10% for shares redeemed before a specified holding period. Most non-traded REITs also impose a minimum holding period, often one year, before you’re eligible for the repurchase program at all.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin – Non-traded REITs An investor who buys and redeems inside the first year or two can lose 20% or more of the original investment.
Private REITs: Wait for the Sponsor
Private REITs are sold under Regulation D and are limited to accredited investors — generally individuals with net worth above $1 million excluding a primary residence, or annual income above $200,000 for the past two years ($300,000 jointly with a spouse).3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accredited Investors Because the offerings aren’t registered with the SEC, they carry fewer disclosure obligations and even fewer liquidity options than non-traded REITs.
Most private REITs don’t run a formal repurchase program at all. The expected holding period is often projected somewhere in the range of five to ten years, and during that stretch your capital is largely inaccessible. Selling before a liquidity event usually means finding another accredited investor willing to buy your interest in an off-market transaction, typically at a meaningful discount to net asset value.
The real exit for a private REIT investor is a planned liquidity event controlled by the sponsor: a sale of the entire property portfolio, a merger into a larger vehicle, or an IPO. You realize your gain or loss when the sponsor decides it’s time. If real estate markets soften, the sponsor may push the exit years past the original projection, and you have no mechanism to force the timing.
Tax Consequences of Selling or Redeeming
Selling REIT shares on an exchange, redeeming them through a repurchase program, or receiving proceeds from a sponsor-driven liquidity event all count as taxable events. Your gain or loss is sale proceeds minus adjusted cost basis, reported on Form 8949 and carried to Schedule D of your Form 1040.4Internal Revenue Service. About Form 8949, Sales and Other Dispositions of Capital Assets Shares held one year or less produce a short-term gain taxed at ordinary rates; shares held longer qualify for the lower long-term capital gains rates.5Internal Revenue Service. Topic no. 409 Capital Gains and Losses
The piece investors most often miss is cost basis. REITs must distribute at least 90% of their taxable income to keep their tax status,6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 857 – Taxation of Real Estate Investment Trusts and Their Beneficiaries and a portion of what they distribute is often classified as return of capital. ROC isn’t taxed in the year received, but it reduces your basis in the shares, which increases your taxable gain when you sell.
A simple example: you buy at $10 and receive $2 in ROC distributions over several years. Your adjusted basis is $8. Sell for $12 and the taxable gain is $4, not $2. Once ROC distributions reduce your basis to zero, any further ROC becomes immediately taxable as a capital gain even though you haven’t sold anything.7Internal Revenue Service. Publication 550 (2025), Investment Income and Expenses Your broker’s Form 1099-B may not reflect every ROC adjustment, so you’re responsible for tracking basis and reporting the correct figure on Form 8949.8Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8949