American Tool and Mold Lawsuit: Chapter 11 and Benpac Judgment

American Tool and Mold, a Clearwater, Florida injection molder in business since the late 1970s, is in the middle of a contested Chapter 11 bankruptcy and a related lawsuit over who should run the company. The American Tool and Mold lawsuit landscape in 2026 breaks into three fronts: a receivership obtained by lender EverBank in January, a Chapter 11 petition the company filed in May listing $24.5 million in liabilities, and management’s own suit seeking to remove the court-appointed receiver. CEO Emilia Giannakopoulos and her team are fighting to keep control of a roughly 160-employee business against both the receiver and the bank.1MC Machinery. Breaking the Mold at American Tool and Mold2Tampa Bay Business Journal. American Tool Bankruptcy Lawsuit Receivership

How ATM Ended Up in Court

The company’s relationship with its primary lender, Jacksonville-based EverBank, broke down in late 2025. EverBank alleged that ATM had breached its loan agreement and defaulted on $17.2 million in outstanding loans.3WhatNow. Longstanding Florida Manufacturing Company Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy2Tampa Bay Business Journal. American Tool Bankruptcy Lawsuit Receivership

On January 22, 2026, a court granted the bank’s request and placed ATM into receivership. A court-appointed receiver took over management of the company’s business assets and property, setting up the fight that would carry into bankruptcy court four months later.4Plastics News. American Tool Clearwater Receivership

The Chapter 11 Filing

On May 15, 2026, ATM filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of Florida. The petition was signed by Giannakopoulos and filed first in Fort Myers as case 2:26-bk-01166, then transferred to the Tampa Division as case 8:26-bk-04159, assigned to Judge Luis Ernesto Rivera II. The case is being jointly administered with five related entities, including American Technical Molding, Inc. and American Tool & Mold, LLC.5PACER Monitor. American Tool and Mold, Inc., Case 2:26-bk-011666PACER Monitor. American Tool and Mold, Inc., Case 8:26-bk-04159

The petition listed estimated assets between $1 million and $10 million against total liabilities of $24.5 million.5PACER Monitor. American Tool and Mold, Inc., Case 2:26-bk-011662Tampa Bay Business Journal. American Tool Bankruptcy Lawsuit Receivership Later filings value the Clearwater manufacturing facility alone at nearly $20 million, suggesting the asset picture is more complex than that initial range implies.7Plastics News. American Tool Bankruptcy Financing Battle Appraisal ATM retained Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP as bankruptcy counsel, with the retention approved on June 17, 2026, and brought in Joseph Baum of BJC Advisors LLC as Chief Restructuring Officer.3WhatNow. Longstanding Florida Manufacturing Company Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy

The Three-Way Fight for Control

Plastics News described the bankruptcy as a “bitter courtroom battle” with three sides pulling in different directions.8Plastics News. American Tool Contentious Chapter 11 Bankruptcy

ATM’s management sued to remove the court-appointed receiver, accusing the receiver of misconduct and of violating the automatic bankruptcy stay that should have paused creditor actions once the Chapter 11 petition was filed.9Plastics News. American Tool Wins Emergency Financing2Tampa Bay Business Journal. American Tool Bankruptcy Lawsuit Receivership

EverBank took a different route. Rather than defending the receiver, the bank filed emergency motions seeking the appointment of a Chapter 11 trustee to take over operations, which would strip control from current management through the bankruptcy process itself. EverBank also moved to define the receiver’s powers and duties within the bankruptcy and to prohibit ATM from using cash collateral.7Plastics News. American Tool Bankruptcy Financing Battle Appraisal ATM’s debtors filed an omnibus response opposing all of EverBank’s emergency motions on June 17, 2026.6PACER Monitor. American Tool and Mold, Inc., Case 8:26-bk-04159

Emergency Financing and What’s Next

ATM did win one early round. The court granted interim approval of emergency financing, with funds designated to cover payroll, maintain employee health benefits, and perform repairs at the Clearwater facility. That approval kept the company running while the control fight continued.9Plastics News. American Tool Wins Emergency Financing

As of mid-June 2026, the case remained active. A preliminary hearing on EverBank’s motion to compel discovery compliance was scheduled for June 23, 2026, and a cash management hearing was set for July 8, 2026. The court set an August 14, 2026 deadline for ATM to file its Chapter 11 Plan and Disclosure Statement laying out the proposed path for restructuring and exiting bankruptcy.6PACER Monitor. American Tool and Mold, Inc., Case 8:26-bk-04159

The Benpac Judgment ATM Can’t Collect

Part of the financial backdrop is a large judgment ATM won but has struggled to enforce. In August 2023, a Florida judge ordered Benpac Holding Inc. to pay $22 million to ATM for breaching a settlement agreement tied to a failed 2019 acquisition. The judgment, as docketed in Delaware, totaled $22,128,398.25.10Plastics News. Benpac Ordered to Pay $22M to American Tool and Mold in Failed Acquisition Suit11Delaware Courts. Loulourgas Investments LLC et al. v. Benpac Holding Inc., Case N23J-02428

Collection has not followed. The Delaware docket shows plaintiffs filing motions to compel document production and, in March 2024, obtaining a court order for sanctions and contempt against Benpac for failing to cooperate with post-judgment discovery. Whether Benpac has the assets to satisfy the judgment is not clear from the available records.11Delaware Courts. Loulourgas Investments LLC et al. v. Benpac Holding Inc., Case N23J-02428

Earlier Lawsuits Against ATM

The company’s current troubles are not its first time in federal court. In December 2012, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued ATM in the Middle District of Florida, alleging that the company had unlawfully rescinded a job offer to Michael Matanic, a process engineer, after a pre-employment medical exam disclosed back surgery six years earlier. ATM had deemed Matanic “not fit for duty” because he could not produce documentation from his surgical team confirming no permanent restrictions, even though he had already been performing the job for two months.12EEOC. EEOC Wins Summary Judgment in American Tool and Mold Disability Case

On April 16, 2014, District Judge Mary S. Scriven granted summary judgment to the EEOC, holding that ATM had violated the Americans with Disabilities Act by relying on “myths and fears” about Matanic’s history instead of conducting an individualized assessment. The parties later agreed to $150,000 in damages.12EEOC. EEOC Wins Summary Judgment in American Tool and Mold Disability Case13EEOC. Significant Disability Discrimination Litigation Filed or Resolved, July 2013 – July 2014

A former employee named Zayas also sued ATM in 2017 under 42 U.S.C. § 1981, alleging race-based job discrimination. The case was transferred to the Tampa Division of the Middle District of Florida and is listed as closed, though the public record does not show the outcome or any damages.14PlainSite. Zayas v. American Tool and Mold, Inc.