American Modern Insurance Lawsuit: Kickbacks, Fines, and Exit

American Modern Insurance has faced two intertwined waves of legal action: a 2016 federal class action in Miami alleging it paid kickbacks to mortgage servicers in exchange for force-placed insurance business, which settled for close to $15 million, and parallel regulatory enforcement from New York, Florida, Minnesota, and ultimately all 50 states that produced millions more in penalties and required rate cuts and refunds. The company exited the force-placed insurance business in February 2016. A handful of unrelated coverage disputes have also reached the federal appellate courts.

The Force-Placed Insurance Class Action

The core case was Strickland v. Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC, filed December 18, 2016, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida (Case No. 1:16-cv-25237). Five borrowers sued on behalf of classes whose loans were serviced by Carrington Mortgage Services, Fay Servicing, and Residential Credit Solutions. Named defendants included those three servicers, American Modern Home Insurance Company, American Western Home Insurance Company, and Southwest Business Corporation, which the complaint said acted as a conduit routing payments from American Modern to the servicers.1ClassAction.org. Strickland v. Carrington Class Action Complaint

Force-placed insurance is coverage a mortgage servicer buys on a borrower’s behalf when the borrower’s own homeowner policy lapses. Because the borrower chooses neither the insurer nor the price, premiums have long run far higher than open-market rates. The plaintiffs alleged American Modern paid the servicers undisclosed kickbacks for the exclusive right to write those policies, disguised as commissions, expense reimbursements, or payments for insurance-tracking services performed below cost.

The Settlement

The case did not go to trial. On August 10, 2017, U.S. Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman preliminarily approved settlements totaling close to $15 million. Affected borrowers were eligible for cash awards equal to between 6% and 10.5% of the net premiums they had been overcharged on force-placed policies dating back to 2008.2KTT Law. Settlement Reached for Mortgage Insurance Kickbacks in Florida, New Jersey The defendants denied the allegations and said they settled to avoid the cost and risk of trial.3Top Class Actions. Carrington Mortgage, Fay Servicing, Residential Credit Solutions Settlement Judge Goodman entered final judgments on January 26, 2018, and closed the case.4Plainsite. Strickland v. Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC Docket

Regulatory Penalties From the States

The class action rode on top of a wave of regulatory enforcement that began in late 2011, when the New York Department of Financial Services opened an industry-wide investigation into force-placed insurance.

New York

American Modern entered into a consent order with the New York Department of Financial Services carrying a $1 million penalty and restitution to affected homeowners. The order barred paying commissions to affiliated servicers, prohibited captive reinsurance arrangements, and stopped the practice of providing below-cost outsourced services to servicers.1ClassAction.org. Strickland v. Carrington Class Action Complaint

All 50 States

In April 2015, American Modern signed a Regulatory Settlement Agreement with all 50 states and the District of Columbia. The company agreed to an administrative penalty of at least $6 million, rising to as much as $24 million if it failed to implement the required corrective actions.1ClassAction.org. Strickland v. Carrington Class Action Complaint

Florida

In September 2015, the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation issued a consent order after a target market conduct examination of American Modern’s lender-placed practices from January 2008 through May 2014. The order prohibited the company from paying commissions to servicers or their affiliates, reinsuring force-placed policies with a servicer’s captive insurer, providing free or below-cost outsourced services, and making incentive payments to secure business. The company also had to refile its force-placed rates with Florida regulators annually. American Modern did not admit to any violations of the Florida Insurance Code.5Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. American Modern Insurance Group Consent Order

Minnesota

In June 2016, the Minnesota Commerce Department announced a $1 million penalty after concluding that American Modern charged excessive rates in a non-competitive market and submitted inaccurate information to support those rates. The settlement covered nearly 7,000 force-placed policies issued or active in Minnesota between January 2008 and March 2016 and required the company to cut its rates by 43%. Eligible homeowners could submit refund claims.6HousingWire. American Modern Insurance Group Fined $1M for Over-Charging on Force-Placed Insurance

Exit From the Force-Placed Business

On February 22, 2016, American Modern announced it was leaving the force-placed insurance business entirely, after nearly five years of investigations, penalties, and consent orders.1ClassAction.org. Strickland v. Carrington Class Action Complaint

Other Lawsuits Involving American Modern

Beyond the force-placed matters, American Modern has been a party to the kind of coverage disputes typical of a large property insurer. Three have produced reported decisions.

American Modern Home Insurance Co. v. Thomas (Eighth Circuit, 2021)

American Modern denied a personal property claim after a January 2014 fire destroyed the apartment of Aaron and Aimee Thomas, concluding the fire was intentionally set. The company filed a declaratory judgment action; the Thomases countersued for vexatious refusal to pay. A jury sided with the Thomases, but in April 2021 the Eighth Circuit reversed and ordered a new trial, finding that the trial judge improperly excluded evidence of Mr. Thomas’s 2017 felony convictions, which the appeals court said were highly relevant to credibility in a case that came down to “diametrically opposed” accounts.7FindLaw. American Modern Home Insurance Company v. Thomas

American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance Co. v. Pickett (S.D. Alabama, 2023)

American Modern sought a federal declaratory judgment to void a manufactured-home policy, alleging that Fracine Pickett misrepresented her insurance history on her application before a fire loss. Pickett sued in Alabama state court, adding breach of contract and bad faith claims against American Modern plus claims against her insurance agency and a prior insurer. In June 2023, the federal court dismissed American Modern’s preemptive action, ruling that the more comprehensive state case was the proper forum and that federal jurisdiction would amount to “gratuitous interference” with state proceedings.8FindLaw. American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance Company v. Pickett In February 2025, the Alabama Supreme Court reversed a lower court ruling and ordered Pickett’s claims into arbitration.9Justia. Pickett v. American Bankers Insurance Co. of Florida

Aqrawi v. American Modern (S.D. Texas, 2021)

A policyholder sought $134,225 to repair a 2019 Lamborghini Urus damaged during a test drive by a prospective buyer. The vehicle was insured under a “Collector Vehicle Policy” that covered only “occasional pleasure use.” The court granted summary judgment to American Modern, ruling that a test drive for a potential sale was not occasional pleasure use and fell outside coverage.10MDJW Law. Insurance Newsbrief: Aqrawi v. American Modern