The American Apparel controversy is really several overlapping scandals: a decade of sexual harassment lawsuits against founder Dov Charney, mandatory arbitration agreements that kept those claims out of public view, regulatory bans on the company’s sexualized advertising, discrimination findings over hiring and workplace conduct, the mass firing of roughly 1,500 to 1,800 factory workers after a 2009 federal immigration audit, and two bankruptcies that ended with Gildan Activewear buying the brand’s intellectual property in 2017. A 2025 Netflix documentary, Trainwreck: The Cult of American Apparel, pulled the allegations back into the public eye.
The Harassment Allegations Against Dov Charney
Charney faced sexual harassment lawsuits from employees throughout his tenure as CEO, with allegations that he used crude language in the office, hired women based on sexual interest, and conducted job interviews in his underwear.1The Fashion Law. The Rise and Fall of American Apparel The pattern was publicly documented as early as 2004, when journalist Claudine Ko profiled him for Jane magazine and reported that Charney masturbated in front of her during the interview. He was quoted saying, “Masturbation in front of women is underrated. It’s much easier on the woman.”2Longreads. Meet Your New Boss Charney later dismissed the lawsuits as “a testimony to my success, the fact that I’m a target for baseless lawsuits.”
The most serious individual case came in March 2011, when former teenage sales associate Irene Morales sued Charney and the company in New York State Supreme Court for $250 million. Morales alleged that shortly after her 18th birthday, Charney held her “prisoner” at his Manhattan apartment and forced her to perform sexual acts over several hours, and that the coercion continued for eight months under threat of losing her $10.25-an-hour job.3NBC News. American Apparel CEO Held Teen As Sex Slave4Reuters. American Apparel CEO Held Teen As Sex Slave The company moved to force the case into confidential arbitration under agreements Morales had signed as an employee.5Gothamist. Dov Charney Is Racking Up Those Harassment Lawsuits
A separate lawsuit was filed the same month by Kimbra Lo, a 19-year-old former sales associate who alleged Charney sexually harassed her at his Los Angeles home when she visited to discuss being rehired. Three additional women joined that suit but did not publicly disclose their claims due to confidentiality agreements they had signed while employed.6Los Angeles Business Journal. American Apparel CEO Faces Second Harassment Suit In total, at least five women filed lawsuits against Charney in 2011. Three were cleared by a judge and two went to arbitration.7The Guardian. American Apparel, Dov Charney, and Sexual Harassment
How Arbitration and NDAs Kept the Claims Quiet
A key reason the allegations took so long to reach critical mass was the company’s systematic use of mandatory arbitration and nondisclosure agreements. American Apparel required all employees to sign contracts forcing any disputes, including sexual harassment claims, into confidential arbitration. Employees were also barred from disparaging Charney or the company and prohibited from speaking to journalists without approval. One contract clause made employees liable for up to $1 million if they violated the disparagement provision.8The New York Times. Arbitration Clauses Let American Apparel Hide Misconduct
The practical effect was to keep disputes private and prevent the public and investors from recognizing a pattern. In 2013, a California court refused to compel one employee into arbitration after he alleged Charney had choked him and rubbed dirt in his face, basing the decision partly on the company’s practice of countersuing employees for disparagement.8The New York Times. Arbitration Clauses Let American Apparel Hide Misconduct Most American Apparel workers remained bound by those agreements.
Discrimination Findings and Appearance-Based Hiring
The Los Angeles office of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission found that American Apparel had discriminated against women as a class on the basis of gender through sexual harassment. Store managers were required to send photographs of job applicants to the Los Angeles headquarters for approval before hiring, and headquarters also demanded “class photos” of staff on duty. Employee tipsters alleged executives used those photos to pressure managers into firing workers deemed unattractive.9BuzzFeed News. My Unexpected Adventure With Dov Charney A leaked letter from a store manager, reported by Gawker in 2010, stated that Charney would not permit the hiring of “ugly people.”1The Fashion Law. The Rise and Fall of American Apparel Charney publicly said the policies were about judging fashion sense, not looks.
Separately, former employee Christopher Renfro won a $343,000 arbitration award in a racial discrimination case after alleging a supervisor repeatedly used a racial slur against him during a 2007 business trip. Testimony showed American Apparel did not discipline the supervisor until threatened with litigation, issued a written warning, and then gave the supervisor a pay raise two days later.10East Bay Express. Former American Apparel Employee Wins $343K in Race Discrimination Suit
Advertising Bans and the Woody Allen Settlement
American Apparel’s advertising drew repeated action from the British Advertising Standards Authority. In April 2013, the ASA pulled a series of images from the company’s website, ruling they “demeaned women by emphasising the model’s groin, buttocks and breasts and by not including her face” and carried a “voyeuristic quality” that made the women appear “vulnerable.”11The Guardian. American Apparel Ad Banned That ruling followed three bans in just over four months. Other ASA actions targeted ads the regulator said appeared to sexualize children; one featured a model the company said was 23, but the ASA found the imagery could reasonably be construed as sexualizing someone under 16. A “Back to School” campaign showing a young woman in a tartan miniskirt bending over a car to expose her underwear was the first American Apparel ad the ASA banned.12Retail Dive. Second American Apparel Ad Banned in UK A company representative said it would “not be altering our classic advertising aesthetic which is internationally recognized for its artistic and social values.”13The Cut. American Apparel Explains That Banned Sexy Ad Critics also challenged the company’s claim that ads featured “real girls” who were employees or friends; former models alleged many were professional models or adult film performers.1The Fashion Law. The Rise and Fall of American Apparel
In March 2008, filmmaker Woody Allen sued American Apparel for $10 million after it used a still from his 1977 film Annie Hall, showing him dressed as a Hasidic rabbi, on billboards in New York and Los Angeles without his permission. Allen said the ads violated his longstanding refusal to make commercial endorsements; the company argued the use was protected satire. The case settled on the day jury selection was set to begin in federal court in Manhattan, with American Apparel paying Allen $5 million. Charney said the payment came from the company’s insurance carrier.14CNN. American Apparel Settles Lawsuit With Woody Allen15Reuters. Woody Allen Wins $5 Million in Lawsuit Over His Image
The 2009 Immigration Audit and Mass Firings
In 2009, a federal investigation into employee immigration documentation at American Apparel’s Los Angeles factory led to the termination of approximately 1,500 to 1,800 workers, more than a quarter of the company’s workforce. Following audits by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the company identified about 1,600 employees who could not verify their authorization to work. Workers were given 30 to 60 days to produce documentation, and those who could not were fired. The company said it was not found to have willingly hired unauthorized workers, and Charney said terminated employees who resolved their status would be given priority for rehiring.16ABC News. 1,600 American Apparel Workers’ Legal Status
Charney’s Firing and the Lawsuits That Followed
On June 18, 2014, the board suspended Charney as president and CEO, citing an investigation into alleged misconduct and misuse of company funds. He served as a special consultant during the investigation and was formally terminated for cause on December 16, 2014.17Los Angeles Times. Dov Charney Fired From American Apparel Former board co-chairman Allan Mayer later said a forensic investigation of company servers had uncovered “videos and emails from him… to call them inappropriate would be an understatement.”7The Guardian. American Apparel, Dov Charney, and Sexual Harassment The company disclosed it had incurred $8.2 million in insured litigation costs and $1.2 million in uninsured costs related to Charney’s conduct through September 2014.18CNBC. American Apparel Details Allegations of Sexual Misconduct by Ousted CEO Its employment practices liability insurance costs had more than doubled because of his behavior.9BuzzFeed News. My Unexpected Adventure With Dov Charney
Charney sued back. In May 2015, he filed a $30 million defamation suit against Standard General, the hedge fund that had become American Apparel’s controlling shareholder, alleging it orchestrated a “coup d’etat” and conducted a “sham investigation” to justify his removal.19Forbes. Fired American Apparel CEO Dov Charney Files $30 Million Defamation Suit The following month, he filed a $100 million conspiracy and fraud suit against American Apparel, Standard General, and several former board members, alleging they tricked him into diluting his ownership stake from 43% to 27%.20Los Angeles Times. Dov Charney Sues American Apparel, Standard General Standard General countersued in Delaware to recover a $20 million loan it had made to him.
He lost on both fronts. In March 2017, the California Court of Appeal upheld the dismissal of his defamation claims against Standard General under an anti-SLAPP motion, finding he failed to show a minimal chance of success on the merits.21FindLaw. Dov Charney v. Standard General, L.P., B268928 In December 2017, a Delaware Chancery Court judge ordered Charney to repay Standard General’s $20 million loan plus interest, calling him a “sophisticated businessperson” who was represented by counsel when he signed the agreements.22Courthouse News. Ex-American Apparel CEO Loses Court Battle With Hedge Fund After Ouster
Two Bankruptcies and the Gildan Sale
American Apparel filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on October 5, 2015, in Delaware, listing $199.3 million in assets against $397.6 million in debt.23ASI Central. American Apparel: A Timeline CEO Paula Schneider, who had replaced Charney in January 2015, cited competition from fast-fashion rivals and the burden of legal costs tied to the founder.24ABC News. American Apparel, Once Worth a Billion, Now Bankrupt The company’s stock was delisted from the New York Stock Exchange.25Time. American Apparel CEO Fired
It filed again on November 14, 2016, in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.26Kroll. APP Winddown, LLC – Bankruptcy Case Information Gildan Activewear won the auction in January 2017 with an $88 million bid and completed its purchase of the brand’s intellectual property, select merchandise, and manufacturing equipment the following month.23ASI Central. American Apparel: A Timeline The deal did not include retail store assets, and nearly 200 American Apparel stores closed.
What Changed About “Made in USA” After the Sale
If you remember American Apparel for its “Made in USA, Sweatshop-Free” labels, the brand you can buy today is not that company. After the 2017 acquisition, Gildan replaced the “Made in USA” label with “Globally-Sourced” and moved production to its own factories, primarily in Central America. Gildan maintained no textile or sewing facilities in the United States. The website continued using the language “Ethically-Made, and Sweatshop Free,” but the Workers Rights Consortium and the Honduran Women’s Collective documented allegations of mandatory overtime, suppression of unionization, and chronic health conditions among workers at Gildan’s Central American facilities. WRC executive director Scott Nova said: “Using terms like ethically-made and sweatshop free — there is no way that that doesn’t make a misleading impression on consumers.”27The Guardian. The New American Apparel: Claims of Ethically Made Abroad Clash With Reality
Charney Today and the Netflix Documentary
After his ouster, Charney founded Los Angeles Apparel, a garment manufacturer with a similar emphasis on domestic production. In July 2020, the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health ordered the factory shut down following a COVID-19 outbreak. More than 300 employees tested positive and four workers died between June and early July. Health officials cited “flagrant violations” of infection control orders, including the use of cardboard as barriers between workers and the company’s alleged failure to cooperate with the investigation. Charney called the closure “media theatrics.”28CBS News. Los Angeles Apparel Coronavirus Cases, Deaths – Plant Closed29WWD. Dov Charney’s Los Angeles Apparel Ordered to Suspend Operations He continues to operate Los Angeles Apparel and continues to deny wrongdoing regarding the American Apparel allegations.30Yahoo Entertainment. Dov Charney Net Worth 2025
In 2025, Netflix released Trainwreck: The Cult of American Apparel, featuring testimony from former employees describing what they called a “toxic” and “cult-like” workplace. Because many accusers remained bound by confidentiality agreements, the documentary used actors to voice some witness testimonies.31Entertainment Weekly. Where Is Former American Apparel CEO Dov Charney Now The film reported that new hires received a welcome gift box containing a vibrator, a copy of The 48 Laws of Power, a Leica camera, and a BlackBerry for around-the-clock contact from Charney, and described how he housed certain young female employees at his Silver Lake mansion, where they allegedly served as “surrogates and enforcers.”32Los Angeles Times. Trainwreck: The Cult of American Apparel Archival footage showed Charney berating employees, calling them the “fool of the week” and issuing ultimatums to “quit or submit.” A spokesperson for Charney denied the allegations, stating he has never been found liable for misconduct by any judge, jury, arbitrator, or independent investigation, and called the film a gross misrepresentation that relied on “paid actors to emotionally restate long-disproven allegations.”