Alternative Reference Rates: SOFR, LIBOR Transition, and Spread Adjustments

SOFR and the LIBOR transition refer to the replacement of the London Interbank Offered Rate with the Secured Overnight Financing Rate as the primary U.S. dollar interest rate benchmark. SOFR is a transaction-based overnight rate published each business day by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, built from more than $2 trillion in daily Treasury repo trades. All 35 LIBOR settings have now permanently ceased, with the final three synthetic USD LIBOR settings published for the last time on September 30, 2024.1Bank of England. The End of LIBOR If you have an adjustable-rate mortgage, a floating-rate business loan, or an interest rate swap, the rate you pay is now almost certainly tied to SOFR.

Why LIBOR Was Retired

LIBOR was built on a daily survey. A panel of banks submitted estimates of what it would cost them to borrow from each other, and nothing required those submissions to reflect actual trades. Traders at several global banks took advantage of that design to push the rate in directions that helped their own positions, and enforcement actions in the United States, United Kingdom, and European Union produced billions of dollars in fines through the early-to-mid 2010s.

The underlying interbank lending market had also shrunk for years. Fewer real transactions meant the rate reflected guesswork more than market reality, and regulators concluded the framework was unsustainable. Most LIBOR panels (including several USD tenors) stopped after June 30, 2023, the deadline U.S. banking regulators set for institutions to have replacement rates in place.2Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Joint Statement on Completing the LIBOR Transition Synthetic settings kept a few legacy contracts running for a limited time, and those have now ended as well.

What SOFR Is and How It Is Calculated

The Alternative Reference Rates Committee, convened by the Federal Reserve, selected SOFR as the recommended replacement for USD LIBOR in 2017.3Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Transition from LIBOR SOFR measures the cost of borrowing cash overnight against U.S. Treasury securities as collateral in the repurchase agreement (repo) market. Because every underlying transaction is backed by government debt, SOFR is treated as a nearly risk-free rate. LIBOR, by contrast, embedded bank credit risk in its number.

The New York Fed publishes SOFR each business day at approximately 8:00 a.m. Eastern Time.4Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Secured Overnight Financing Rate Data It is calculated as a volume-weighted median of eligible overnight Treasury repo transactions drawn from three segments of the market: tri-party repo data, general collateral finance repo, and bilateral Treasury repo cleared through the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation. Specials (repos on specific Treasury securities trading at unusually low rates) are filtered out before the median is taken. Daily volumes behind the rate regularly exceed $2 trillion.5Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Secured Overnight Financing Volume (SOFRVOL) No single institution can meaningfully move a number anchored to that much trading activity.

Term SOFR Versus Daily SOFR

SOFR on its own is an overnight rate, but most loans and bonds have interest periods measured in months. The market handles that mismatch two different ways, and borrowers run into both.

Daily SOFR Compounded in Arrears

Under this method, each day’s published SOFR is applied to the outstanding balance for that day, and the daily rates are compounded over the full interest period. The rate for the whole period is not known until the period is nearly over, since each day’s number is only set after the overnight market closes.6Federal Reserve Bank of New York. SOFR In Arrears Conventions for Syndicated Business Loans Loan agreements build in a lookback of several business days so the borrower has time to arrange payment. A five-business-day lookback, for example, lets the lender calculate the final interest about a week before the payment date. This approach is common in syndicated business loans and in derivatives.

Term SOFR

Term SOFR solves the uncertainty problem by setting a single rate at the start of the interest period, the way LIBOR did. CME Group publishes Term SOFR in one-month, three-month, six-month, and twelve-month tenors, derived from SOFR futures prices.7CME Group. Term SOFR Because it is forward-looking, Term SOFR moves in anticipation of Fed rate changes rather than lagging them. That makes it the preferred index for business loans quoted in standard tenors and for borrowers who want to know their interest cost up front.

The practical difference shows up during rate-change cycles. When the Fed is raising rates, Term SOFR tends to move higher before Daily SOFR catches up; when rates are falling, Term SOFR drops first. Neither is inherently better. Certainty of payment favors Term SOFR; the most accurate reflection of current overnight rates favors daily compounding.

How SOFR Shows Up in Your Loan

SOFR now underpins a wide range of financial products, from consumer mortgages to corporate credit facilities and interest rate swaps.

Adjustable-Rate Mortgages

Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae require newly originated adjustable-rate mortgages to use the 30-day Average SOFR as their index. These ARMs come in familiar structures such as 5/6-month and 7/6-month products, where the first number is the initial fixed-rate period in years and the second is how often the rate adjusts afterward. The lender adds a margin on top of the index, and that margin must fall between 1.00% and 3.00%.8Freddie Mac. SOFR ARMs Fact Sheet If the 30-day Average SOFR is 4.50% and your margin is 2.75%, your rate at the next adjustment would be 7.25%, subject to any caps in your loan agreement.

Business Loans and Derivatives

Corporate borrowers typically see either Term SOFR or Daily Simple SOFR in their credit agreements. Term SOFR dominates broadly syndicated loans because operational systems built around LIBOR’s forward-looking structure transferred to it more easily. Interest rate swaps and other derivatives more commonly reference daily compounded SOFR, which lines up with conventions set by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association.

Legacy LIBOR Contracts and the Mandatory Spread Adjustment

A floating-rate bond or loan from, say, 2005 might have said “three-month LIBOR plus 2%” with no contingency for LIBOR disappearing. Renegotiating millions of these “tough legacy” contracts one by one was not realistic.

Congress addressed this with the Adjustable Interest Rate (LIBOR) Act, enacted in 2022 as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act. For any LIBOR contract that lacks a clear fallback or a designated person to pick a replacement, a Board-selected benchmark replacement takes effect automatically by operation of law.9Congress.gov. 117th Congress: Adjustable Interest Rate (LIBOR) Act The statute also shields parties from litigation over the switch, blocking claims that the rate change breached the contract.

Because SOFR is nearly risk-free and LIBOR carried bank credit risk, a straight substitution would change the economics of every affected contract. The LIBOR Act fixes this by mandating a tenor-specific spread adjustment that is added to SOFR. Each value is the five-year historical median difference between that LIBOR tenor and SOFR:10Bloomberg Index Services. IBOR Fallback Rate Adjustments Rule Book

  • Overnight LIBOR: 0.00644%
  • One-month LIBOR: 0.11448%
  • Three-month LIBOR: 0.26161%
  • Six-month LIBOR: 0.42826%
  • Twelve-month LIBOR: 0.71513%

These values are codified in the Federal Reserve’s implementing regulation at 12 CFR Part 253.11eCFR. 12 CFR Part 253 – Regulations Implementing the Adjustable Interest Rate (LIBOR) Act The longer the tenor, the larger the adjustment, because credit risk premiums increase with the length of the borrowing period. A legacy contract that referenced three-month LIBOR, for example, transitions to three-month SOFR plus 0.26161%, keeping the contract’s intended economics intact as closely as possible.

Tax Treatment of the Switch

Changing a contract’s reference rate could in theory be treated as a taxable event if the IRS saw it as creating a materially different instrument. The IRS headed that off with Revenue Procedure 2020-44, which provides a safe harbor: modifying a contract to replace an interbank offered rate with an alternative reference rate is not treated as an exchange of property differing materially in kind or extent.12Internal Revenue Service. Rev. Proc. 2020-44 The guidance also confirms that these modifications do not create adverse consequences for integrated hedging transactions and do not terminate a qualified hedge. For borrowers and lenders, the transition from LIBOR to SOFR does not, by itself, generate a tax bill.

Where SOFR Falls Short

SOFR solved the manipulation and thin-market problems, but it introduced trade-offs. The most significant is the absence of a credit component. LIBOR rose when banks perceived higher lending risk, so borrowers paid more during stress periods and lenders were compensated for that stress. SOFR, anchored to Treasury-collateralized borrowing, can actually fall during a credit crisis as investors flee to government securities, moving in the opposite direction from bank funding costs.

Some regional and mid-sized banks argued the mismatch made SOFR a poor fit for lending, since their own borrowing costs rise during stress even as their SOFR-linked loan rates decline. That concern drove interest in credit-sensitive alternatives such as the Bloomberg Short-Term Bank Yield Index (BSBY) and the American Interbank Offered Rate (Ameribor). Neither was formally recommended by the ARRC. BSBY ceased publication, and Ameribor continues to serve a niche among smaller institutions, but the bulk of the market has standardized on SOFR.

The overnight nature of SOFR also means that borrowers using daily compounded rates face payment uncertainty until near the end of each interest period. Term SOFR eases that for many products, but the ARRC has recommended keeping Term SOFR’s use limited to situations where operational needs genuinely require a forward-looking rate, so that the market does not recreate the concentration risks that undid LIBOR.