Allowable Costs: Five Tests, Examples, and Documentation

Allowable costs are expenses a contractor or grant recipient can legally charge to a federal award. To qualify, every dollar must pass five tests set out in Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) Part 31 for contracts or 2 CFR Part 200 for grants: the cost has to be reasonable, allocable to the award, treated consistently with how similar costs are handled elsewhere, measured according to proper accounting standards, and permitted under both the contract terms and the specific rules in FAR Subpart 31.2. Fail any one of those, and the cost is unallowable, no matter how legitimate the underlying expense looks.

The Five Tests

FAR 31.201-2 is the gate every charge has to clear.1Acquisition.GOV. 31.201-2 Determining Allowability The five criteria work together, not in sequence; a cost that satisfies four and fails the fifth is still unallowable.

Reasonableness

A cost is reasonable if it doesn’t exceed what a careful businessperson would pay in a competitive market. FAR 31.201-3 looks at whether the expense is ordinary and necessary, whether it reflects sound business practices and arm’s-length bargaining, and whether it departs from the contractor’s own established patterns.2Acquisition.GOV. 31.201-3 Determining Reasonableness There is no presumption of reasonableness. If a contracting officer challenges an expense, the contractor has to prove it was reasonable.

Allocability

A cost is allocable if it meets one of three conditions: it was incurred specifically for that contract, it benefits the contract along with other work and can be split proportionally, or it’s necessary to the overall operation of the business even without a direct link to any single contract.3Acquisition.GOV. 31.201-4 Determining Allocability The first bucket is direct costs like project materials. The third is where indirect costs live, such as rent and executive salaries, and those must be distributed across contracts through a fair allocation method.

Consistency

You cannot classify a cost as direct on one contract and indirect on another when the circumstances are the same. FAR 31.202 is explicit: no final cost objective can receive a direct charge for any cost if the same type of cost, incurred for the same purpose, has been pooled as an indirect cost elsewhere.4Acquisition.GOV. 31.202 Direct Costs An administrative assistant’s time charged directly to a cost-reimbursement contract but swept into overhead on a fixed-price contract is the classic violation, and auditors look for exactly that pattern.

Accounting Standards

The cost must be measured and recorded according to Cost Accounting Standards (CAS) if those apply, or otherwise follow generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). CAS imposes prescriptive rules on how costs are accumulated and allocated; GAAP gives more flexibility, but the methods still need to produce consistent, defensible numbers.

Contract Terms and Regulatory Limits

Even a cost that clears the first four tests can be unallowable if the contract itself restricts it or if FAR Subpart 31.2 flags that category. Subpart 31.2 contains dozens of specific cost provisions, and if a regulation says a cost is unallowable, the analysis stops there.

Costs That Are Generally Allowable

Most expenses that are ordinary, necessary, and tied to performing the work make it through. The common categories:

  • Employee salaries, wages, and fringe benefits for time actually spent on the contract, subject to the annual compensation benchmark set by the Office of Federal Procurement Policy for contracts awarded on or after June 24, 2014.5Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-6 Compensation for Personal Services
  • Materials, supplies, components, and subcontractor costs acquired for contract performance.
  • Travel costs up to federal per diem rates.6Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-46 Travel Costs
  • Indirect costs such as facility rent, utilities, insurance, and general administrative expenses, allocated through an approved indirect cost rate.
  • Professional service fees for outside consultants, auditors, and contract-related legal counsel (excluding legal costs tied to fraud proceedings or regulatory violations).

The qualifier running through all of these is “for the work performed.” An employee’s salary is allowable only to the extent they actually worked on the federal contract, and a trip that mixes government business with personal time requires splitting, with the personal portion coming out of your own pocket.

Costs That Are Always Unallowable

Certain categories cannot be charged to a federal contract regardless of context. Knowing this list cold is where compliance programs start.

One rule multiplies the risk here. When a cost is unallowable, its “directly associated costs” are also unallowable.14Acquisition.GOV. 31.201-6 Accounting for Unallowable Costs Host an unallowable entertainment event and the catering, venue rental, and transportation for that event all become unallowable, even though those categories would normally be fine.

Costs That Depend on Context

Some categories sit between the two lists above. Whether the charge survives depends on specific circumstances and documentation.

Travel

Travel is allowable only up to the federal per diem rate in effect at the time of travel. The General Services Administration sets rates for the contiguous United States, the Department of Defense sets rates for Alaska, Hawaii, and outlying areas, and the Department of State sets foreign rates.6Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-46 Travel Costs Exceeding per diem is possible in special situations, but it needs written justification approved by a company officer, and ongoing exceptions need advance approval from the contracting officer. Partial travel days and days with no lodging require downward adjustments.

Airfare is allowable only at the lowest fare available during normal business hours. A higher fare clears only if the cheaper option would require unreasonable routing, excessive travel time, or would not accommodate documented medical needs.

Advertising and Public Relations

Most advertising is unallowable. Any advertising whose primary purpose is promoting products or burnishing the company’s image cannot be charged to the contract, and that excludes trade shows, corporate celebrations, promotional brochures, branded merchandise, and convention sponsorships.15Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-1 Public Relations and Advertising Costs The narrow exceptions cover advertising required by the contract, advertising to acquire scarce items needed for performance, advertising to dispose of scrap, and advertising that promotes U.S. exports. On the public relations side, responding to press inquiries, community activities like blood drives, and communications about matters of legitimate public concern (plant closings, layoffs, contract awards) are allowable.

Compensation

Salaries and benefits are generally allowable, but two limits catch contractors routinely. Total compensation must be reasonable for the work performed, with the burden of proof on the contractor. And for contracts awarded on or after June 24, 2014, any employee compensation above the annual benchmark set by the Office of Federal Procurement Policy is unallowable. Owners of closely held companies face an added restriction: compensation exceeding what is deductible under the Internal Revenue Code cannot be charged.5Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-6 Compensation for Personal Services

Contracts and Grants Use Different Rulebooks

The allowable cost concept lives in two regulatory environments. Which one applies determines which rules you follow and who audits you.

Federal contractors follow FAR Part 31.16Acquisition.GOV. FAR Part 31 – Contract Cost Principles and Procedures These rules govern cost-reimbursement contracts, contract modifications, termination settlements, and any negotiated contract requiring cost analysis. For most contractors outside educational institutions and nonprofits, the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) handles the audits, reviewing cost proposals, indirect cost rate submissions, and incurred cost claims.17Acquisition.GOV. 48 CFR 42.101 – Contract Audit Responsibilities

Nonprofits, universities, state and local governments, and tribal organizations receiving federal grants instead follow the Uniform Guidance at 2 CFR Part 200.18eCFR. 2 CFR Part 200 – Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards Under 2 CFR 200.403, a cost charged to a grant must be necessary and reasonable, allocable, consistent with policies applied to both federally funded and non-federally funded activities, in accordance with GAAP, adequately documented, and not already used to meet cost-sharing requirements on another federal award.19eCFR. 2 CFR 200.403 – Factors Affecting Allowability of Costs The language is slightly different from the FAR’s, but the ideas overlap heavily.

Documentation Is Half the Battle

A cost that meets every allowability criterion will still get disallowed if the records don’t back it up. Three documentation obligations do most of the work.

Segregating unallowable costs. The accounting system has to identify and exclude unallowable costs from any billing, claim, or proposal. That means separate accounts or cost codes for categories like entertainment, lobbying, and alcohol so those charges never flow into an indirect cost pool, and the same treatment for every directly associated cost.14Acquisition.GOV. 31.201-6 Accounting for Unallowable Costs

Source documentation. Every expense needs contemporaneous records tying it to a specific contract or grant. For travel, that means date, location, purpose, and traveler name at a minimum, with receipts required for any single expense of $75 or more.6Acquisition.GOV. 31.205-46 Travel Costs Labor needs the most rigorous controls: daily time entry, clear charge codes separating direct labor from indirect time and leave, a complete audit trail for any timesheet changes, no estimated entries, supervisor review, and no routine supervisor-entered time on behalf of employees. Sloppy timekeeping is one of DCAA’s most common findings, and it can call every labor dollar into question.

Record retention. Contractors must retain financial records for three years after final payment on the contract. A late final indirect cost rate proposal extends that period by one day for each day of delay.20Acquisition.GOV. Subpart 4.7 – Contractor Records Retention On multi-year contracts with unsettled indirect rates, final payment can arrive years after the work is done, which is why many contractors end up holding records for five to seven years or more.

What Happens If You Bill an Unallowable Cost

Including unallowable costs in a billing or indirect rate proposal is not just an accounting mistake. FAR 42.709 sets up a formal penalty structure for contractors who include expressly unallowable costs, or costs previously determined to be unallowable, in a final indirect cost rate proposal.21Acquisition.GOV. 42.709 Penalties for Unallowable Costs

At minimum, the contractor repays the disallowed amount with interest. The contracting officer can also assess a penalty equal to the disallowed cost if the inclusion was due to inadequate policies or procedures. If the contractor knew the cost was unallowable and included it anyway, the penalty can be substantially higher. Repeated or egregious violations can lead to suspension or debarment from all federal contracting.

This is where the directly-associated-cost rule bites hardest. A $5,000 entertainment expense that slipped through can look trivial on its own, but if the accounting system failed to catch it, auditors will question whether the whole system is adequate, and a single sloppy cost pool can unravel confidence in millions of dollars of indirect rate claims.