AICPA Code: When Audit Firms May Accept Contingent Fees

Under AICPA rules, a CPA firm can never charge a contingent fee for an audit, and it cannot charge a contingent fee for any other service performed for an audit client during the covered engagement and financial-statement periods. Two narrow situations fall outside the definition of a contingent fee: amounts fixed by a court or public authority, and fees in tax matters that depend on a governmental agency’s findings or a judicial proceeding. A separate part of the same rule prohibits contingent fees for preparing any original tax return, amended return, or refund claim, and that ban applies to every client the firm serves, audit or not.

Which Services Trigger the Prohibition

AICPA Rule 1.510.001 bars a member in public practice from performing any professional service for a contingent fee, or receiving one, from a client for whom the firm performs certain listed services.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct Those services are:

  • An audit or review of a financial statement.
  • A compilation of a financial statement when the firm expects a third party to use the statement and the compilation report does not disclose a lack of independence.
  • An examination of prospective financial information, such as forecasts or projections.

The compilation piece is where firms get caught off guard. A compilation whose report openly discloses that the firm lacks independence does not trigger the prohibition. Only compilations that an outside party might rely on without knowing the firm is not independent fall within the rule.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct

Once a firm performs one of those listed services for a client, the contingent fee prohibition reaches every service the firm provides to that same client. Consulting work, valuation projects, and advisory engagements for the audit client all have to be billed on a non-contingent basis. The strictest standard governs the entire relationship.

How Long the Ban Applies

The prohibition covers two overlapping windows: the period the firm is engaged to perform the attest service, and the period covered by the historical financial statements involved.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct If your firm audits a client’s 2025 statements during early 2026, the ban reaches back through all of 2025. A contingent fee arrangement that started and ended before the engagement letter was signed can still violate the rule if it overlapped the fiscal year under audit.

Fees That Are Not Considered Contingent

Rule 1.510.001 does not so much create exceptions as narrow what counts as a contingent fee in the first place. Two categories sit outside the definition entirely.

Fees Fixed by Courts or Public Authorities

A fee set by a court or other public authority is not treated as contingent, even if the dollar amount depends on the outcome of a proceeding.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct Bankruptcy court approval of fees for accounting services to an estate is a common example. The external authority has to genuinely control the amount rather than sign off on whatever the firm proposes.

Tax Matters Where the Government Decides the Result

In tax matters, a fee based on the results of judicial proceedings or the findings of a governmental agency is not treated as contingent.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct Representing a client during an IRS examination fits here: the IRS makes the determination, so the fee outcome rests with the government rather than the CPA’s own work product. A tax protest against a state property assessment works the same way.

The carve-out is narrower than it looks. The fee has to genuinely depend on what the government decides. Charging more simply because a client’s refund turned out to be large, with no government proceeding driving the result, is still a contingent fee under the rule.

The Separate Ban on Contingent-Fee Tax Returns

Rule 1.510.001(b) contains a second prohibition that catches people because it does not depend on any attest relationship. A CPA firm cannot prepare an original tax return, an amended return, or a claim for a refund on a contingent-fee basis for any client at all.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct The client can have no audit or review relationship with the firm whatsoever, and the ban still applies.

The tax-matter carve-out described above does not override this second prohibition. That carve-out covers representation before governmental agencies and in judicial proceedings, which happen after a return has been filed and the government has begun its review. Preparing the return itself remains off-limits for contingent billing.

Circular 230 for CPAs Practicing Before the IRS

A CPA who practices before the IRS also has to satisfy Treasury Department Circular 230. Section 10.27 restricts contingent fees for IRS-related work and allows them only in four situations.2eCFR. 31 CFR 10.27 – Fees

  • IRS examination or challenge of an original return.
  • An amended return or refund claim, but only when filed within 120 days after the taxpayer receives written notice of the IRS examination of the original return.
  • A refund claim filed solely to recover statutory interest or penalties the IRS assessed.
  • Any judicial proceeding arising under the Internal Revenue Code.

The 120-day window is where Circular 230 is stricter than the AICPA rules. An amended return filed months after an examination notice will not support a contingent fee under Circular 230 no matter how solid the underlying position is. When both regimes apply, the stricter one controls.2eCFR. 31 CFR 10.27 – Fees Circular 230 also defines contingent fees broadly, catching arrangements based on a percentage of the refund, a percentage of taxes saved, or any promise to reimburse the client if a position is later challenged.

Public Company Audits Under PCAOB Rule 3521

Auditors of publicly traded companies work under tighter rules. PCAOB Rule 3521 states that a registered public accounting firm is not independent of its audit client if the firm provides any service or product to that client for a contingent fee during the audit and professional engagement period.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. Section 3. Auditing and Related Professional Practice Standards The rule covers commissions as well, and it reaches any affiliate of the firm.

PCAOB Rule 3521 has no tax-matter carve-out. Its only definitional exclusion is for fees fixed by courts or public authorities that do not depend on a finding or result.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. Section 3. Auditing and Related Professional Practice Standards A public company auditor cannot charge a contingent fee for representing the audit client in an IRS examination, even though a private-company auditor might be able to under the AICPA definition. Firms with mixed portfolios need to know which regime governs each client.

Non-Attest Clients and the Risk of Switching Roles

If a CPA firm provides only consulting, valuation, or advisory work to a client, with no audit, review, or covered compilation, contingent fees for those services are generally available. The separate ban on contingent-fee tax return preparation still applies, but other advisory arrangements remain on the table.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct

The problem arises when a non-attest client later becomes an attest client. The moment the firm agrees to perform an audit or review, existing contingent arrangements can become a violation, because the prohibition reaches back to cover the period of the financial statements involved. A contingent fee that was acceptable last quarter can create a retroactive conflict once the engagement letter is signed. Before accepting a new attest engagement, a firm should inventory every existing fee arrangement with that client.

One narrow contingent-fee investment advisory arrangement is available even alongside an attest relationship. A firm may provide contingent-fee investment advisory services to individual owners, officers, or employees of an attest client, or to a nonattest-client employee benefit plan sponsored by an attest client.1American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct The service runs to the individual or the plan, not to the attest client entity, which is what keeps it within the rule.