When a broker-dealer executes an agency trade for you, the firm acts as a middleman: it finds a counterparty in the open market to take the other side of your order instead of filling the order from its own inventory. Because the firm never owns the security, your cost is a disclosed commission rather than a markup buried in the price, and the firm owes you a duty to seek the best execution reasonably available. Federal law defines a “broker” as a person in the business of effecting securities transactions for the account of others, which is the legal shorthand for exactly this role.
Agency vs. Principal: Which Hat Is the Firm Wearing
The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 draws a clean line between two roles a firm can play. A broker effects transactions in securities for the account of others. A dealer buys and sells securities for its own account as a regular business.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 78c – Definitions and Application Most large firms register as both, which is why the industry uses the combined label “broker-dealer.” On any single trade, though, the firm has to pick one hat.
Acting as agent, the firm never takes ownership of the security. It locates a willing buyer or seller and connects the two sides, and it earns a commission disclosed on the confirmation. Acting as principal, the firm sells you a security out of its own holdings or buys yours into inventory, and its profit comes from the spread between what it paid and what you paid. For certain principal trades in debt securities, FINRA Rule 2232 requires the firm to disclose that markup as both a dollar amount and a percentage of the prevailing market price.2FINRA. FINRA Rule 2232 – Customer Confirmations
The distinction changes the incentive structure. When the firm trades as principal, it sits on the other side of your order and has a direct interest in the price you accept. When it trades as agent, its only financial interest in the transaction is the commission, so its incentive lines up more naturally with filling your order at a good price. Every trade confirmation has to say which role the firm played, so you can tell after the fact which was which.
What You Actually Pay on an Agency Trade
Your broker-dealer earns its fee through a commission disclosed upfront, usually structured as a flat fee per trade or a per-share charge. That transparency is one of the practical advantages of agency execution. You can look at the confirmation and see exactly what the firm earned.
SEC Rule 10b-10 requires the broker-dealer to send a written confirmation showing the amount of any commission received, along with whether the firm acted as agent or principal, the execution price, and other trade terms.3eCFR. 17 CFR 240.10b-10 – Confirmation of Transactions Reviewing the confirmation is the simplest way to verify what you paid and in what capacity the firm executed.
The Section 31 Fee
On sell orders you may see a small extra line labeled as a regulatory or transaction fee. This comes from Section 31 of the Securities Exchange Act, which funds SEC oversight by assessing a fee on securities sales. Exchanges remit the fee to the SEC, and most brokers pass it through to customers. As of April 4, 2026, the rate is $20.60 per million dollars in sales.4U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Section 31 Transaction Fee Rate Advisory for Fiscal Year 2026 On a $10,000 sale, that works out to about two cents. The fee applies to sell transactions only.
Commissions and Your Tax Basis
Commissions do not just reduce your returns; they change your tax math. The IRS treats the commission on a purchase as part of your cost basis in the security. The basis of stocks or bonds is generally the purchase price plus costs of purchase, including commissions and transfer fees. When you sell, the commission paid on the sale reduces your amount realized. The net effect is that commissions on both ends reduce a taxable gain or increase a deductible loss.5Internal Revenue Service. Publication 550 – Investment Income and Expenses
Best Execution and the Limits of Reg BI
The core protection you get in an agency trade is the duty of best execution. FINRA Rule 5310 requires broker-dealers to use reasonable diligence to find the best market for a security and to execute the trade so that the resulting price is as favorable as possible under current market conditions.6FINRA. FINRA Rule 5310 – Best Execution and Interpositioning Reasonable diligence means the firm has to weigh several factors, including the price, volatility, and relative liquidity of the security along with the availability of competing markets. A firm that routinely routes every order to a single venue without comparing prices elsewhere is on thin ice, and most agency-trading enforcement actions start here.
What Reg BI Does and Does Not Cover
If your broker also recommends specific securities to you, Regulation Best Interest applies on top of best execution. Reg BI requires the firm to act in your best interest at the time it makes a recommendation and to avoid placing its financial interest ahead of yours. The standard is intentionally narrower than the fiduciary duty that applies to registered investment advisers. An investment adviser’s duty is ongoing and covers the whole relationship; a broker-dealer’s obligation under Reg BI attaches at the moment of each recommendation and does not include a continuing duty to monitor your account afterward.7U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Regulation Best Interest – The Broker-Dealer Standard of Conduct If your broker recommended a stock that later fell, Reg BI did not require the firm to call you later and tell you to sell.
Payment for Order Flow: The Conflict Behind “Free” Trades
Even in a pure agency trade, routing decisions are not always neutral. Payment for order flow is the practice where a trading venue pays your broker in exchange for routing your orders there. Retail brokers typically receive these payments from wholesale market makers that then fill the orders from their own inventory.8U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. How Does Payment for Order Flow Influence Markets? The conflict is direct: the broker has a financial incentive to send your order to whichever venue pays the most, which may not be the venue offering you the best price.
SEC Rule 606 addresses this through disclosure. Every broker-dealer must publish quarterly reports on its website showing where it routes non-directed orders in NMS stocks and options. For each top venue, the report has to disclose the net payment for order flow received, broken down by order type, along with any profit-sharing or volume-based incentive arrangements. You can also request a customer-specific report showing exactly where your own orders were routed over the previous six months, and brokers must notify you at least once a year that this information is available.9eCFR. 17 CFR 242.606 – Disclosure of Order Routing Information
If you trade with a commission-free broker, payment for order flow is almost certainly how the firm makes money on your equity orders. That by itself does not mean you are getting a bad deal. But a firm that routes overwhelmingly to a single venue paying the highest rate while competitors offer better price improvement is worth a harder look at the Rule 606 numbers.
How Long Your Trade Records Stick Around
Your broker cannot throw out trade records once the confirmation goes out. SEC Rule 17a-4 requires firms to preserve copies of all trade confirmations for at least three years, with the first two years in an easily accessible location.10eCFR. 17 CFR 240.17a-4 – Records to Be Preserved by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers If you need to reconstruct cost basis for taxes years later or dispute the terms of an old trade, the firm is legally required to still have those records.