Aetna’s payment policies run on four moving parts: coding and medical-necessity reviews that can reduce or deny what a provider billed, site-of-care rules that dictate where many procedures and infusions must be performed, plan-by-plan formulas for out-of-network reimbursement, and federal and state rules that cap what members pay in certain situations. Together they shape the dollar amount Aetna will recognize on any given claim and how much of a bill lands on the patient.
Claims and Coding Reviews
Aetna runs a Claim and Code Review Program (CCRP) that measures submitted claims against coding guidance from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the American Medical Association’s CPT standards, and evidence-based guidelines from recognized health care organizations.1Aetna. Officelink Updates, September 2025 The target is claims where Aetna judges that the service level billed is not supported by the documentation.
The most visible piece is the evaluation and management review. Certified coders look at Level 4 and Level 5 office visit codes for new and established patients and weigh the complexity of medical decision-making, the number and severity of problems addressed, and the total time spent with the patient. Aetna’s position is that billing a higher-level E&M code when a lower level is documented is not medically necessary or appropriate. Providers who disagree with an edit can appeal by submitting medical records through the Availity provider portal or to the address on the Explanation of Benefits.2Aetna. E&M Code Claim Review
The program grew significantly in late 2025. Beginning September 1, 2025, Aetna expanded the CCRP to commercial, Medicare, and student health members, with new triggers for medical record requests on high-dollar claims, implant procedures, anesthesia services, and bundled claims.3Becker’s Payer Issues. Aetna Expanding Claims Reviews in September Additional claim edits followed on December 1, 2025.1Aetna. Officelink Updates, September 2025 Washington and Texas implementation was made subject to regulatory approval, and Maine and Vermont received unique effective dates for commercial plans.
The Inpatient Severity Downgrade Policy
In August 2025, Aetna announced a level of severity inpatient payment policy with a November 15, 2025 effective date. Most other major insurers that question an inpatient stay either deny it as medically unnecessary or downgrade it to outpatient observation. Aetna’s new policy took a different route: pay hospitals at a lower severity level for inpatient admissions the insurer judged less complex than billed.4American Hospital Association. AHA Urges Aetna To Rescind Level of Severity Inpatient Payment Policy
Hospitals pushed back. In September 2025, the American Hospital Association wrote to Aetna arguing the policy “appears to circumvent established regulatory standards regarding coverage for Medicare Advantage beneficiaries” and asking the insurer to rescind it.4American Hospital Association. AHA Urges Aetna To Rescind Level of Severity Inpatient Payment Policy In April 2026, Jefferson Health and the Lehigh Valley Physician Hospital Organization filed a federal lawsuit seeking to block its implementation.5Healthcare Dive. Jefferson Health Sues Aetna Over Medicare Advantage Downcoding Policy
Where Aetna Requires Care To Be Delivered
Aetna’s site-of-care rules steer certain procedures and treatments toward lower-cost settings when it considers them clinically appropriate.
Outpatient Surgery
Under the site-of-service precertification program, several elective procedures must be performed in an ambulatory surgical center or office setting rather than a hospital outpatient department unless the patient meets specific medical necessity criteria. The list includes breast tissue excision, complex wound repair, cystourethroscopy, septoplasty, tenodesis of the long tendon of the biceps, turbinate resection, and certain skin tissue transfers. A broader group of procedures, including arthroscopic hip surgery, blepharoplasty, shoulder arthroplasty, and varicose vein surgery, is subject to additional site-of-care review. Hospital outpatient settings may be authorized when a patient has an ASA physical status classification of III or higher, a BMI above 40 (or above 35 with comorbidities), obstructive sleep apnea, poorly controlled diabetes, end-stage renal disease, recent cardiac events, or other elevated-risk conditions.6Aetna. Outpatient Surgical Procedures
Infusions and Injections
Site-of-care rules also apply to drug infusion and injection services. After an initial dose, which may be given at the provider’s preferred location, follow-up doses generally must avoid hospital outpatient settings unless medical necessity is documented.7Aetna. Drug Infusion Site of Care Policy Exceptions include patients with a history of serious adverse reactions such as anaphylaxis, those with vein access issues requiring special procedures, patients under 14 receiving certain biologic therapies, and those receiving combination chemotherapy regimens in a single visit.
Gene-based, cellular, and other innovative therapies sit in a separate category. Drugs such as Zolgensma, Casgevy, and Luxturna, along with others on Aetna’s designated list, must be administered at facilities in the insurer’s Gene-Based, Cellular and Other Innovative Therapy (GCIT) network for every dose, including the first.7Aetna. Drug Infusion Site of Care Policy
Out-of-Network Payments
What Aetna pays for out-of-network care depends on the individual plan. The insurer’s public materials do not describe a single universal formula and point members to plan documents for how each plan sets the “recognized charge” or “allowed amount.” The final reimbursement turns on two variables: the method the plan uses to set the allowed amount and the percentage of that amount the plan covers.8Aetna. Network and Out-of-Network Care
The practical consequence is balance billing exposure. Members may owe the difference between what the provider charged and what Aetna recognized. Some plans use a Medicare-based benchmark, others a database of usual and customary charges, and the plan documents are the governing source.
No Surprises Act Protections
The federal No Surprises Act, effective January 1, 2022, shields insured patients from surprise bills for emergency services and certain out-of-network care at in-network facilities. Member cost-sharing for covered services is based on the Qualifying Payment Amount (QPA), generally the median contracted rate the insurer has negotiated with in-network providers for similar services in the same geographic area.
Aetna includes No Surprises Act disclosures and QPA determinations on Explanation of Benefits statements. When a provider does not accept the QPA, the process starts with a 30-business-day open negotiation period, followed by a four-business-day window to initiate federal independent dispute resolution.9Aetna. Federal No Surprises Act
CMS Audit Findings
In May 2024, CMS published its first-ever audit of insurer compliance with the No Surprises Act. The subject was Aetna Health Inc. of Texas, and the audit examined air ambulance service claims processed between January and June 2022. CMS found that Aetna had calculated the QPA using an incorrect methodology, basing figures on amounts actually paid on claims rather than the required median contracted rate with other providers for similar services in the area. The errors affected QPAs across four air ambulance service codes. CMS also found Aetna had failed to notify providers of their right to initiate independent dispute resolution within the required timeframe, had provided inaccurate disclosure statements about arbitration deadlines on Explanation of Benefits forms, and had omitted the QPA from remittance advices sent with initial payments or denial notices.10Becker’s Payer Issues. CMS Cites Aetna in First No Surprises Act Audit
CMS directed Aetna to perform a self-audit of all QPA calculations for air ambulance services in Texas during the audit period and to issue refunds to members whose cost-sharing would have been lower under a correctly calculated payment amount. Aetna updated its systems to include required disclosure language, added a QPA field to remittance advices, and reprocessed the identified claims.9Aetna. Federal No Surprises Act An Aetna spokesperson said the audit “took place during the first six months of 2022, following the initial implementation of the requirements” and the company addressed all findings to CMS’s satisfaction.10Becker’s Payer Issues. CMS Cites Aetna in First No Surprises Act Audit CMS noted Aetna may be subject to future audits.
Medicaid Managed Care
Aetna operates Medicaid plans through its Aetna Better Health brand, and payment rules follow each state’s provider manual.
In Illinois, Aetna Better Health’s clinical policies drive benefit administration and prior authorization, while separate payment policies govern claims adjudication based on correct coding principles from CMS, the National Correct Coding Initiative, and AMA CPT guidance, along with state-specific reimbursement rules.11Aetna Better Health. Clinical and Payment Policies The Illinois provider manual also addresses pay-for-performance incentives, overpayment recovery, and timely filing requirements.12Aetna Better Health. Aetna Better Health of Illinois Provider Manual
In Maryland, state law requires Aetna Better Health to transmit payment for clean claims within 30 days of receipt, with interest owed on claims that remain unpaid past that window. Hospital reimbursement in Maryland follows rates set by the Health Services Cost Review Commission. When members self-refer to out-of-plan providers for state-authorized services such as emergency care or family planning, the plan pays at the state Medicaid rate. Providers are strictly prohibited from balance billing Medicaid beneficiaries and cannot charge members, Medicaid, or the managed care organization for missed appointments.13Maryland Department of Health. Aetna Better Health of Maryland Provider Manual