Advance refunding of municipal bonds is a refinancing technique in which a local government issues new bonds and uses the proceeds to buy a portfolio of government securities, held in escrow, that pays off the old bonds when their call date arrives. The old debt is treated as legally paid from the moment the escrow is funded, even though the actual redemption may be years away. Since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, any advance refunding bond issued after December 31, 2017 carries taxable interest, which has reshaped when the strategy is worth doing and pushed issuers toward newer structures that preserve tax-exempt status.
How the Mechanism Works
The legal concept at the heart of advance refunding is defeasance. Once the municipality deposits enough money into an irrevocable escrow account to cover every remaining interest and principal payment on the old bonds, those bondholders stop looking to the municipality’s revenues. They are paid out of the escrow. The old bonds remain technically outstanding until the call date, but the issuer has no further obligation tied to them.
A third-party escrow agent, usually a commercial bank with trust powers, holds the account and invests the proceeds in high-quality securities timed to match the debt service schedule of the refunded bonds. Issuers generally choose between two sources for those investments: State and Local Government Series securities (SLGS) purchased directly from the U.S. Treasury, and open-market Treasury bills, notes, and bonds bought on the secondary market.
SLGS are built for this role. Issuers subscribe through the Treasury’s SLGSafe electronic system, specifying the exact principal amounts, maturities, and rates needed to fund the escrow.1TreasuryDirect. SLGS Forms The catch is that SLGS sales depend on the federal debt ceiling. The Treasury suspended sales in May 2023 and resumed them in June 2023.2TreasuryDirect. Treasury to Resume Sales of State and Local Government Series Securities When the SLGS window closes, escrows have to be built from open-market Treasuries instead, which complicates pricing.
The trust agreement governing the escrow prevents the municipality from using the money for any other purpose. That legal separation is what protects bondholders and holds the refunding together until the call date arrives.
The 2017 Tax Change
Before 2018, municipalities could advance refund older debt with tax-exempt bonds, passing lower borrowing costs along to investors who paid no federal income tax on the interest. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act ended that. Under 26 U.S.C. § 149(d), interest on any bond issued to advance refund another bond is not exempt from federal income tax.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 149 – Bonds Must Be Registered To Be Tax Exempt; Other Requirements The prohibition applies to advance refunding bonds issued after December 31, 2017.
The statute uses 90 days as the dividing line. A refunding bond issued more than 90 days before the redemption of the original bond is an advance refunding, and its interest is taxable. A refunding bond issued inside that 90-day window is a current refunding, and the interest can still qualify for tax-exempt status if the other requirements of Internal Revenue Code sections 141 through 150 are met.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 149 – Bonds Must Be Registered To Be Tax Exempt; Other Requirements
Because taxable bonds have to offer higher coupons to attract investors, the potential savings from an advance refunding are smaller than they were before 2018. The financial hurdle is higher, and some refundings that would have cleared it as tax-exempt deals do not pencil out as taxable ones.
Arbitrage Limits and Negative Arbitrage
Federal tax law restricts how much the escrow can earn. Under 26 U.S.C. § 148, a bond becomes an “arbitrage bond” if any portion of its proceeds is used to acquire investments yielding materially more than the bond itself yields, which strips the tax-exempt status entirely.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 148 – Arbitrage Treasury regulations define “materially higher” for refunding escrow investments as more than one-thousandth of one percentage point above the bond yield.5eCFR. 26 CFR 1.148-2 – General Arbitrage Yield Restriction Rules That is a very tight tolerance.
When escrow investments do earn above the permitted yield, the issuer owes the excess back to the federal government as an arbitrage rebate, with installments due at least every five years.6eCFR. 26 CFR 1.148-3 – General Arbitrage Rebate Rules Missed rebates can retroactively cost the bonds their tax-exempt status.7Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8038-T
In practice, the opposite problem shows up more often. Short-term Treasuries used in the escrow usually yield less than the long-term coupon on the refunding bonds, so the issuer pays more on the new debt than the escrow earns during the period before the call date. That gap is negative arbitrage, and it is real lost money. The longer the time between issuance and the call date, the more it eats into savings. For taxable advance refundings the problem is often worse, because the spread between short-term escrow yields and long-term taxable coupons can be wide.
When It Still Saves Money
Whether an advance refunding is worth doing comes down to net present value savings after transaction costs and negative arbitrage. The financial advisor models the cash flows of the existing debt against the proposed debt, factoring in underwriting fees, legal costs, escrow agent fees, and verification costs. A common industry benchmark is net present value savings of at least 3 to 5 percent of the refunded bonds’ par amount.
That benchmark is a starting point, not a rule. A refunding that barely clears 3 percent may not be worth doing if rates could move further before the call date. A more complete analysis looks at how much of the call option’s economic value the refunding actually captures, not just whether savings cross a line. Taxable advance refundings face a particularly steep version of this question, because the higher coupons and wider negative arbitrage can consume several percentage points of par over a multi-year escrow period.
What the Transaction Requires
The starting document is the original bond transcript, which contains the call provisions and redemption prices for the old bonds. Those terms dictate how much money the escrow needs and when it has to pay out. Redemption prices are typically par or a small premium above par.
An independent verification report is required. A certified public accountant, working separately from the financial advisor who structured the escrow, confirms two things: that the escrow investments will throw off enough cash to cover every debt service payment on the refunded bonds through the redemption date, and, for tax-exempt refundings, that the yield on those investments does not exceed the yield on the refunding bonds. The math has to be exact.
For issuers using SLGS, principal amounts, maturity dates, and interest rates are entered through SLGSafe and must align with the verification report.1TreasuryDirect. SLGS Forms If the SLGS window is closed, the escrow is built from open-market Treasuries and the verification is recalculated. The escrow agreement itself defines the escrow agent’s duties and what happens if a scheduled investment fails or matures early. Agent fees typically run in the low thousands of dollars annually.
For tax-exempt current refundings, the issuer files IRS Form 8038-G to report the issuance. The form is required for tax-exempt governmental bond issues with an issue price of $100,000 or more.8Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8038-G – Information Return for Tax-Exempt Governmental Bonds Taxable advance refunding bonds have separate reporting obligations, since Form 8038-G is specific to tax-exempt issues.
Alternatives That Preserve Tax-Exempt Status
The 2017 law did not eliminate the need to refinance callable debt early. It eliminated one way of doing it. Three structures have taken hold since 2018.
Taxable Advance Refunding
The simplest option is to go ahead and issue taxable advance refunding bonds. Nothing in the TCJA prohibits advance refunding itself; only the tax exemption disappeared. Taxable municipal issuance surged after 2018, driven largely by this strategy. The trade-off is the higher coupon rate, which means the deal needs a larger drop in interest rates to produce meaningful savings.
Forward Delivery Bonds
A forward delivery bond lets an issuer lock in today’s rates for bonds that will not actually be delivered until a future date, usually within 90 days of the old bonds’ call date. Because delivery falls inside the 90-day window, the deal is a current refunding and the interest can be tax-exempt. The issuer gets the economic benefit of acting early without crossing the advance refunding line. Forward periods can run from a few months to roughly two years. Bond counsel issues a preliminary letter at pricing stating that a tax opinion is expected at final settlement, contingent on no change in law or material facts, and that contingency is the main risk. Underwriters also charge a premium for the forward commitment.
Cinderella Bonds
A Cinderella bond is issued as taxable and converts to tax-exempt at a specified date, typically within 90 days of the refunded bonds’ call date. At conversion, the bond is treated as a new tax-exempt issue that qualifies as a current refunding. The structure is newer and less tested than forward delivery bonds, and practitioners are still working through the technical requirements for the IRS to treat the conversion as a true retirement and reissuance rather than a continuation of the original taxable bond.
Pending Legislation
There has been consistent bipartisan interest in Congress to reverse the TCJA’s elimination of tax-exempt advance refunding. In February 2025, a bipartisan group of lawmakers introduced the Investing in Our Communities Act, which would restore the ability of municipalities to issue tax-exempt advance refunding bonds. Municipal finance organizations have argued that the current prohibition costs state and local governments billions in forgone interest savings. As of early 2026, no restoration bill has been enacted. If one passes, the newer alternative structures would likely give way to the simpler pre-2018 approach for most issuers.