Under AICPA Technical Practice Aid 5290.05, the accrual of audit fees at year-end should reflect only the portion of audit work actually performed before the balance sheet date, not the full estimated fee for auditing that year’s financial statements. In practice, that means the Year 1 accrual usually covers planning, risk assessment, control walkthroughs, and any confirmations sent before year-end, while the bulk of the fee (substantive testing, fieldwork, report drafting) is expensed in Year 2 as the auditor performs it.
What TPA 5290.05 Requires
The guidance is more conservative than many accountants expect. TPA 5290.05 recommends against accruing the full audit fee as an expense of the year under audit. The Year 1 accrual should cover only the fees connected to planning and preliminary procedures actually performed before year-end.1Securities and Exchange Commission. Form X-17A-5 Annual Audited Report Everything else is expensed in Year 2 as the auditor performs the remaining work.
This is an effort-based allocation, not a time-based one. A 50/50 split between years is incorrect unless the auditor genuinely performs half the work in each period. In most engagements the split is nowhere near even. Planning represents a modest share of total effort; substantive testing, inventory observation, and report drafting dominate the Year 2 workload.
The dollar impact is significant. If a company pays $100,000 for its annual audit and the auditor completed only planning-stage work before December 31, the Year 1 accrual might be $20,000 to $35,000 depending on engagement complexity. The remaining $65,000 to $80,000 is recognized as expense in Year 2. Accruing the full $100,000 in Year 1 would overstate that year’s expenses and understate Year 2’s.
One point worth understanding: Technical Practice Aids are non-authoritative and don’t carry the same weight as the FASB Accounting Standards Codification. But TPA 5290.05 has been referenced in SEC filing reviews and adopted by regulatory bodies like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners as the expected framework for audit fee accruals.2National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Accruing Audit Fees Under AICPA Technical Practice Aid 5290.05 Auditors and regulators treat it as the standard approach, and deviating from it invites scrutiny.
Which Activities Belong in the Year 1 Accrual
Building an accurate Year 1 number requires coordination with the external audit team. The engagement partner or manager can typically provide a breakdown of planned hours by phase, giving management a basis for allocating fees between periods. The categories of work that usually fall within Year 1 include:
- Engagement planning: establishing materiality thresholds, identifying significant accounts, and developing the overall audit strategy.
- Risk assessment: evaluating the risk of material misstatement at both the financial statement and assertion levels.
- Internal control walkthroughs: documenting and testing key controls, which typically happens during the third or fourth quarter.
- Preliminary analytical procedures: comparing interim financial data against expectations to focus the audit scope.
- Confirmation work: sending confirmations to banks, customers, or vendors that require responses before year-end.
The proportion these activities represent varies. A company undergoing a major acquisition or implementing a new accounting standard will see a heavier concentration of planning work in Year 1, potentially pushing the allocation to 35% or higher. A stable company with clean prior audits and no structural changes might see planning consume only 15% to 20% of total fees. The percentage is not a fixed number and must be reassessed each year based on the specific audit plan.
Recording the Journal Entries
Once the allocation is determined, the mechanics are straightforward. At Year 1 close, the company records an accrual for the estimated planning-stage fees. In Year 2, the accrued liability is drawn down as the auditor invoices for completed work.
Year 1 Accrual
Assume a total estimated audit fee of $100,000 and a determination that 25% of the work was completed before year-end. The Year 1 adjusting entry would be:
- Debit: Audit Expense $25,000
- Credit: Accrued Audit Fees (liability) $25,000
Year 1’s income statement now reflects the cost of audit services received during that period, and the balance sheet carries the corresponding obligation.
Year 2 Settlement
As the auditor completes fieldwork in Year 2, the company recognizes additional audit expense. When the final invoice arrives, the accrued liability clears and any remaining balance is recorded. If the final invoice is $100,000 and $70,000 of additional expense has already been recognized during Year 2 fieldwork:
- Debit: Accrued Audit Fees $25,000 (clearing the Year 1 accrual)
- Debit: Audit Expense $5,000 (remaining unrecognized portion)
- Credit: Accounts Payable $30,000 (amount due on final invoice net of prior payments)
Specific entries depend on whether the company makes progress payments or pays the full amount upon invoice. The principle stays constant: total expense across both periods equals the total fee, and the balance sheet reflects the actual amount owed at each reporting date.
True-Ups When the Estimate Misses
Because the Year 1 accrual is always an estimate, some variance from the final invoiced amount is virtually guaranteed. The true-up happens in Year 2 when the final bill arrives and cumulative expense can be reconciled against total fees.
The difference flows through Year 2’s income statement as an adjustment to audit expense. If the estimate was too low, Year 2 picks up the additional cost. If it was too high, Year 2 gets a favorable adjustment. Under GAAP this is a change in accounting estimate, recognized prospectively in the current period rather than by restating Year 1.1Securities and Exchange Commission. Form X-17A-5 Annual Audited Report
Retroactive restatement of Year 1 would only be appropriate if the original accrual was made in bad faith, was based on information the company knew to be wrong at the time, or produced a material error. A good-faith estimate that turns out to be off by a reasonable margin is the normal course of business for accrued professional fees.
When Scope Changes Blow Up the Estimate
The harder case arises when the final fee substantially exceeds the original estimate because of a mid-engagement scope change, such as a restatement, a newly discovered fraud, or an unanticipated acquisition. The variance may be large enough to raise materiality questions, and the company should consider whether the original accrual was reasonable given the information available at the time.
If the scope change couldn’t have been anticipated, the excess is a change in estimate and runs through Year 2. If the company knew about circumstances that would increase fees but failed to adjust the accrual, that starts looking more like an error than an estimate change, and the analysis under materiality guidance becomes important.
When the Variance Becomes a Materiality Question
Audit fees are rarely large enough to affect materiality on quantitative grounds alone. But the SEC has made clear that materiality is not purely a numbers game. Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 identifies qualitative factors that can make even a small misstatement material, including whether the misstatement arises from an estimate, whether it masks an earnings trend, whether it affects loan covenant compliance, or whether it increases management compensation.3U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 – Materiality
A company sitting on the edge of a debt covenant or an earnings target needs to scrutinize even modest audit fee accruals more carefully. Misclassification of $50,000 between periods might be quantitatively immaterial for a large filer, but if that $50,000 is the difference between meeting and missing an earnings benchmark, it can draw regulatory attention.
SAB 99 also notes that the degree of precision attainable in the estimate matters. Audit fees are typically based on engagement letters with defined fee ranges, making them more precisely estimable than many other accrued liabilities. A material variance from an amount that should have been readily estimable gets less benefit of the doubt than a variance in a genuinely uncertain contingency.3U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 – Materiality
Tax Treatment Differs From the Book Accrual
The book accrual under TPA 5290.05 and the tax deduction for audit fees follow different rules, which can create a timing difference. For accrual-method taxpayers, the IRS requires three conditions before a deduction is allowed: the fact of the liability must be established, the amount must be determinable with reasonable accuracy, and economic performance must have occurred.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 461 – General Rule for Taxable Year of Deduction
For professional services like auditing, economic performance occurs as the services are provided.5eCFR. Title 26 Part 1 – Income Taxes Taxable Year for Which Deductions Taken The Year 1 planning work accrued on the books is also deductible in Year 1 for tax purposes, so book and tax align for that portion. Year 2 fieldwork expense is deductible in Year 2 when performed, again matching the book treatment.
The Recurring Item Exception
A company that wants to deduct the full fee in Year 1 for tax purposes, beyond what the economic performance test would allow, may be able to use the recurring item exception under IRC 461(h)(3). This provision lets an accrual-method taxpayer deduct a liability in the year the all-events test is met even if economic performance hasn’t occurred yet, provided four conditions are satisfied:4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 461 – General Rule for Taxable Year of Deduction
- All-events test met: the liability is fixed and the amount determinable with reasonable accuracy by year-end.
- Timely economic performance: services are provided by the earlier of the tax return filing date (including extensions) or 8½ months after the close of the tax year.
- Recurring nature: the liability can be expected to arise year after year. Annual audit fees easily meet this test.
- Materiality or better matching: either the amount is not material, or accruing it in Year 1 produces a better match with income than waiting.
Since most audit fieldwork is completed well within 8½ months of Year 1’s close, the recurring item exception can allow the full audit fee to be deducted in Year 1 for tax purposes, even though the book expense is spread across both years.6eCFR. 26 CFR 1.461-5 – Recurring Item Exception That creates a temporary book-tax difference that should be tracked if the company accounts for income taxes under ASC 740. Once elected, the recurring item exception must be applied consistently.
Proxy Disclosure for SEC Registrants
Public companies face an additional layer of accountability. SEC rules require registrants to disclose fees paid to their principal auditor in four categories within the annual proxy statement: Audit Fees (annual audit, quarterly reviews, and work connected to statutory or regulatory filings); Audit-Related Fees (assurance services reasonably connected to the audit, such as due diligence on acquisitions or benefit plan audits); Tax Fees (compliance, planning, and advisory); and All Other Fees (anything not captured in the other three).
These disclosures must cover the two most recent fiscal years and include a description of the services in each category.7eCFR. 17 CFR 240.14a-101 – Schedule 14A Information Required in Proxy Statement An inaccurate audit fee accrual can ripple into these required disclosures if reported estimates later require significant correction. The TPA 5290.05 allocation feeds directly into the numbers reported here, which is one reason regulators take it seriously.
For SEC registrants, any current liability that individually exceeds 5% of total current liabilities must be separately stated on the balance sheet or in the notes. A material accrued audit fee balance lumped into a generic “other accrued liabilities” line without disclosure can draw an SEC comment letter.