Accounting Research Bulletin No. 43 was the first major codification of U.S. accounting standards, issued in June 1953 by the Committee on Accounting Procedure (CAP), a body within the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins It pulled the 42 separate bulletins CAP had issued since 1939 into a single organized document covering how to classify current assets, value inventory, account for intangibles, and depreciate long-lived property. Most of its chapters have since been superseded, but the concepts it introduced remain embedded in the FASB Accounting Standards Codification that governs U.S. GAAP today.
Why ARB No. 43 Was Issued
Between 1939 and 1953, CAP responded to accounting questions as they came up, issuing 42 individual bulletins on scattered topics. The guidance was hard to navigate and occasionally inconsistent. ARB No. 43 canceled and replaced all of them, restating earlier positions where they still held and revising them where practice had moved on.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins
The consolidated bulletin ran to 15 chapters, each addressing a distinct area of financial reporting. Four of those chapters shaped decades of practice: Chapter 3 on working capital, Chapter 4 on inventory pricing, Chapter 5 on intangible assets, and Chapter 9 on depreciation.
Working Capital: Defining Current Assets and Current Liabilities
Chapter 3 established the definitions that still govern how companies organize the top portion of a balance sheet. Before it, there was no uniform standard for deciding which items counted as “current,” which made comparisons between companies unreliable.
ARB No. 43 defined current assets as cash and other resources reasonably expected to be turned into cash, sold, or used up within one year or the company’s normal operating cycle, whichever is longer.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins Cash and accounts receivable qualify, as do inventory and short-term investments. The operating-cycle qualifier matters in industries like construction or distilling, where production routinely runs past 12 months.
Current liabilities were defined as obligations expected to be settled using current assets or by creating other current liabilities within that same window.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins Accounts payable, wages owed, and the portion of long-term debt coming due within a year all fit. The chapter carved out a practical exception: a debt maturing soon but expected to be refinanced should not be classified as current, so a company would not look artificially illiquid because of a loan-schedule technicality.
The gap between current assets and current liabilities is working capital, and lenders have relied on that figure ever since as a quick read on whether a business can cover its near-term bills. The current ratio depends entirely on companies classifying items the same way, and that consistency traces back to Chapter 3.
Inventory Valuation: Lower of Cost or Market
Chapter 4 addressed one of the harder problems in financial reporting: how to value inventory sitting on the balance sheet when conditions have changed since the company acquired or produced it. ARB No. 43 gave a conservative answer. Inventory should be carried at original cost unless its value has dropped, in which case the company must write it down and recognize the loss immediately.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins
This became known as the “lower of cost or market” rule. If goods have lost value through damage, obsolescence, or falling prices, carrying them at the original purchase price overstates the company’s assets. The loss belongs in the current period, not deferred until the goods are eventually sold.
How “Cost” Was Determined
Cost meant the total expenditure to bring an item to its existing condition and location. Because companies buy and produce inventory continuously, they need a systematic way to decide which costs attach to which units. ARB No. 43 accepted several cost-flow methods, including first-in, first-out (FIFO), last-in, first-out (LIFO), and weighted-average cost. Each company chose the method that most clearly reflected its periodic income and was expected to apply it consistently.
How “Market” Was Defined
The more technically significant piece of Chapter 4 was its precise definition of “market.” The starting point is replacement cost: what the company would pay today to acquire or reproduce the inventory. Replacement cost alone could produce misleading results at either extreme, so the bulletin bracketed it with an upper and lower bound.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins
The upper limit (the ceiling) is net realizable value: estimated selling price minus the costs still needed to complete and sell the goods. Market can never exceed that, because a company would not carry inventory above what it actually expects to collect. The lower limit (the floor) is net realizable value minus a normal profit margin. That prevents a company from writing inventory down so aggressively that the eventual sale produces an inflated profit.
In practice, you start with replacement cost and test it against the two boundaries. If replacement cost falls between the ceiling and the floor, you use replacement cost. If it exceeds the ceiling, you use the ceiling. If it falls below the floor, you use the floor. You then compare that market figure against original cost and carry inventory at whichever is lower.
What Changed in 2015
For most companies, that ceiling-and-floor test is history. In 2015, FASB issued ASU 2015-11, which simplified inventory measurement for companies using FIFO, weighted-average, and similar methods. Those companies now compare cost directly against net realizable value and carry inventory at the lower of the two.2Financial Accounting Standards Board. ASU 2015-11 Inventory Topic 330 Replacement cost and the floor calculation were eliminated for those methods. Companies using LIFO or the retail inventory method were excluded from the update and still apply the original ARB No. 43 framework, which is one reason the old rules still matter.
Intangible Assets and Goodwill
Chapter 5 created the first standardized framework for recording patents, copyrights, franchises, and goodwill on the balance sheet. The bulletin split intangibles into two groups. The first covered intangibles with a clearly limited life, like a patent that expires after a set number of years. Those had to be amortized over their legal or economic life, whichever was shorter.
The second covered intangibles with no obvious expiration date, most importantly purchased goodwill, which represents the premium a buyer pays over the fair value of a company’s identifiable net assets in an acquisition. Under ARB No. 43, goodwill could sit on the balance sheet indefinitely without mandatory amortization as long as there was no evidence it had lost value. The capitalization rules only applied to externally acquired intangibles. Internally developed items like brand recognition or a trained workforce were expensed as costs were incurred, a distinction that persists in GAAP today.
Chapter 5 has since been deleted from ARB No. 43 because later standards replaced it entirely.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins APB Opinion No. 17 in 1970 reversed the indefinite-life approach and required all purchased intangibles, including goodwill, to be amortized over no more than 40 years.3Financial Accounting Standards Board. Summary of Statement No. 142 That mandatory 40-year rule held until 2001, when SFAS No. 142 eliminated it and moved to annual impairment testing.
Depreciation of Fixed Assets
Chapter 9 laid out the principles for accounting for property, plant, and equipment. A long-lived asset’s cost should be spread across the periods it helps generate revenue. ARB No. 43 described depreciation as “a process of allocation, not of valuation,” drawing a sharp line between systematic cost spreading and any attempt to track what the asset might sell for on the open market.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins
Several methods were accepted. Straight-line, which allocates an equal amount to each year, was the simplest. Accelerated methods like declining balance, which front-load expense into earlier years, were also permitted as long as they were systematic and rational. Whatever method a company chose, it was expected to apply it consistently, and any switch was treated as a change in accounting principle requiring disclosure.
Chapter 9 also took a firm stance against writing up asset values. Companies were told not to record property, plant, and equipment above cost, even if appraisals or market conditions suggested higher values.1Financial Accounting Standards Board. ARB 43 Restatement and Revision of Accounting Research Bulletins If a company had previously recorded appreciation on its books, depreciation had to be calculated on the written-up amount. The bulletin similarly rejected one-time write-downs of plant costs to reflect high wartime or postwar prices, preferring that any shortened useful life be reflected through adjusted systematic depreciation. Those positions reinforced the historical-cost foundation that still underpins U.S. GAAP for fixed assets.
What Still Applies Today
ARB No. 43 was the highest accounting authority in the U.S. for the better part of a decade after its release, but the institutions around it kept shifting. In 1959, the AICPA replaced CAP with the Accounting Principles Board (APB), which took over new standard-setting.4SEC Historical Society. The Richard C. Adkerson Gallery on the SEC Role in Accounting APB opinions gradually modified or superseded individual chapters, with Opinion No. 17 in 1970 being the most prominent example when it overhauled goodwill accounting.
In 1973, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) replaced the APB as the designated private-sector standard-setter, a role the SEC formally recognized as authoritative.5U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Reaffirming the Status of the FASB as a Designated Private-Sector Standard Setter FASB continued refining and replacing the remaining pieces. SFAS No. 142 in 2001 eliminated the 40-year goodwill amortization rule and moved to annual impairment testing.3Financial Accounting Standards Board. Summary of Statement No. 142 ASU 2015-11 in 2015 simplified the inventory rules Chapter 4 had established.2Financial Accounting Standards Board. ASU 2015-11 Inventory Topic 330
Goodwill accounting has since shifted again for private companies. In 2014, FASB gave them the option to amortize goodwill on a straight-line basis over ten years instead of running costly annual impairment tests.6Financial Accounting Standards Board. ASU 2014-02 Intangibles Goodwill and Other Topic 350 FASB has considered extending a similar amortization approach to public companies, though that project has not been finalized.
The final structural change came in 2009, when FASB launched the Accounting Standards Codification, reorganizing thousands of pronouncements, including the surviving portions of ARB No. 43, into roughly 90 topics under a single searchable system.7Financial Accounting Standards Board. FASB Accounting Standards Codification Launches July 1 2009 The Codification became the sole authoritative source of U.S. GAAP for periods ending after September 15, 2009. You will not find ARB No. 43 cited in a modern financial statement, but its working capital classifications in Chapter 3 and its inventory rules still applicable to LIFO companies under Chapter 4 remain embedded in the Codification that governs financial reporting today.