ACAT Form: Registration Match, Rejections, and Residual Balances

An ACAT form, formally the Transfer Initiation Form (TIF), is the document you fill out at your new brokerage to move investments from your old brokerage without selling them first. The form feeds the Automated Customer Account Transfer Service (ACATS), an electronic system that lets brokerages pass securities to each other through a single protocol.1FINRA. Customer Account Transfers Once the form enters the system, a straightforward transfer takes up to five business days.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account Your new broker supplies the form, either through its website or on paper by request.

What to Gather Before You Fill It Out

Most rejections come from information that doesn’t match between the two firms, so pull everything together before you start typing. The SEC specifically warns investors to provide information exactly as it appears on the old account, down to the spelling of your name.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account A middle initial on one account and not the other is enough to stall a transfer.

  • Full account numbers at both the delivering (old) firm and the receiving (new) firm.
  • DTC participant numbers for each brokerage. These are four-digit codes assigned by the Depository Trust Company and typically appear on a monthly statement or in your account settings; the new broker can also tell you both.3Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC). DTC Participant Report
  • The legal names of both firms, exactly as registered, not marketing names.
  • Your Social Security number or Tax Identification Number.
  • The account type: individual, joint, traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and so on.
  • Your most recent statement from the old account, to confirm share counts and cash balances.

Account Registration Has to Match

The account at the receiving firm must have the same registration as the account at the delivering firm. Individual goes to individual. A joint account moves to a joint account with the same owners. If names or legal structure don’t line up, the delivering firm will reject the request to prevent unauthorized movement of assets. Open the new account first and verify the registration before you submit anything.

For retirement accounts, the transfer has to go into the same type of account. Moving a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA is a conversion, not a transfer, and it has tax consequences. Confirm with the new firm that the right account type is open before initiating.

Full Transfer or Partial, In-Kind or Cash

The form asks you to choose between moving the whole account or specific holdings. A full transfer moves all assets and cash. A partial transfer requires you to list individual securities by ticker symbol and share quantity, so use your latest statement to verify counts. Listing more shares than you actually hold will stall the transfer until the numbers are fixed.

In-kind transfers move securities as they are, without selling. Your cost basis carries over, and because nothing was sold, there is no taxable event. The alternative is to liquidate first and transfer cash, which can trigger capital gains or losses depending on your positions and account type.

One practical note on partial transfers: ask your new firm to process them through ACATS rather than manually. The SEC flags manual transfers outside ACATS as a source of delay, taking up to thirty days.4U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Transferring your Brokerage Account: Tips on Avoiding Delays Both firms may charge the same outgoing fee whether you move one position or the entire portfolio.

Assets That Won’t Transfer

Not everything in your account can make the trip. FINRA Rule 11870 identifies categories of nontransferable assets that ACATS cannot move:5FINRA. FINRA Rule 11870 – Customer Account Transfer Contracts

  • Proprietary products created by the old broker that the new broker has no agreement to hold.
  • Third-party mutual funds or money market funds the new broker doesn’t carry.
  • Limited partnership interests in retail accounts.
  • Foreign securities or baby bonds where proper denominations can’t be obtained.
  • Bankrupt issues where no transfer agent exists to re-register shares.

When your account includes nontransferable holdings, the delivering firm must list them and ask what you want done. The usual choices are to liquidate (watch for redemption fees), leave them at the old firm, or have them physically transferred into your name.5FINRA. FINRA Rule 11870 – Customer Account Transfer Contracts A short conversation with the new firm beforehand, asking which of your holdings they accept, prevents the most frustrating delays.

Margin Accounts and Pledged Assets

A margin account adds complications on the form. If you carry a margin debit balance, the delivering firm must note any outstanding initial margin calls on the transfer instruction at the time of validation.5FINRA. FINRA Rule 11870 – Customer Account Transfer Contracts Signing the standard form authorizes the receiving firm to pay the debit balance to the delivering firm and accept the credit balance, moving the margin loan along with the securities.

The receiving firm doesn’t have to accept the margin transfer. If your balance is large relative to your account value, or the new firm has tighter margin requirements, the transfer can be rejected. Pay down what you can before initiating and confirm with the new broker that they’ll accept the remaining debit. If assets are pledged as collateral for a loan, the delivering firm can refuse to release them until the loan is satisfied.

What Happens After You Submit the Form

Once you sign, the new broker submits the instruction electronically through ACATS. This is a “pull” mechanism: the receiving firm asks the delivering firm to release the specified assets, and the delivering firm has one business day to validate the transfer or file a formal objection.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account From there, validation, settlement preparation, and settlement run through the clearing locations, with the whole sequence taking up to five business days.6Federal Register. Self-Regulatory Organizations; National Securities Clearing Corporation; Order Approving a Proposed Rule Change

During the transfer window, the old account is effectively frozen. You can’t buy or sell, and any open limit orders or pending trades can complicate things. The SEC advises against trading during a transfer for this reason.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account Cancel any open orders before submitting the form, and if possible, time the transfer to avoid dividend payment dates or pending interest credits that would land mid-transfer.

If the delivering firm takes no action, or a problem isn’t resolved within two business days, the request gets purged from ACATS and you start over.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account

Why Transfers Get Rejected

Legitimate reasons the delivering firm can object include:

  • Social Security or Tax ID number doesn’t match.
  • Account title or type doesn’t match between firms.
  • A required signature or other authorization is missing.
  • The account number is invalid.
  • The transfer would violate the firm’s credit policy, common with margin accounts.
  • Assets are pledged as collateral for a loan.
  • Additional legal documents are needed, such as a death certificate or marriage certificate.

If your transfer is rejected, call the new broker right away. They can usually tell you exactly what to fix and resubmit within a day.

Fees, Cost Basis, and Residual Balances

Most brokerages charge an outgoing ACAT fee, typically $50 to $100. The fee is usually taken from the account being transferred; if there isn’t enough cash, it can show up as a debit balance forwarded to the new account. Some receiving brokers will reimburse the outgoing fee for a large enough balance, so ask before paying out of pocket. Confirm the fees on both sides before you initiate.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account

When securities move in-kind, cost basis data is transmitted from the old firm to the new one through the DTCC’s Cost Basis Reporting Service.7DTCC. Cost Basis Reporting Service (CBRS) In practice the data often lags. Securities may appear within a week while the basis takes a month or longer, and sometimes it arrives as “unknown.” Download or print your cost basis reports from the old firm before transferring so you can enter missing figures manually at the new broker. Incorrect basis leads to wrong tax reporting on your 1099-B.

Residual balances trickle in after the main transfer settles. Dividends declared before the transfer but paid after, late interest, and the proceeds of fractional shares sold at the old firm all get swept to the new account in later waves, usually on the old firm’s weekly processing schedule.

If Something Goes Wrong

If a transfer stalls, call the compliance departments at both firms. The new broker has the stronger incentive to help, but the old firm is holding the assets. If neither resolves the issue, you can file a complaint with the SEC, FINRA, or your state securities regulator.2Investor.gov. Investor Bulletin: Transferring Your Investment Account FINRA Rule 11870 requires both firms to expedite and coordinate the transfer.5FINRA. FINRA Rule 11870 – Customer Account Transfer Contracts

Once your assets appear at the new firm, verify every position, check that cost basis arrived, and confirm the old account is closed or zeroed out. Some firms leave empty accounts open and continue to charge maintenance fees, so a quick call to confirm closure can save you from a surprise bill later.