The Academy at Penguin Hall lawsuits include a Chapter 11 bankruptcy case filed on June 11, 2025, a co-founder’s tort suit in Essex County Superior Court, a former teacher’s adversary proceeding in bankruptcy court that was dismissed without prejudice, a parent’s consumer complaint with the Massachusetts Attorney General, and a New York merchant cash advance judgment against the school. As of mid-2026, the bankruptcy case and the state tort case remain active, and the fate of the Wenham campus is being fought over through competing motions in bankruptcy court.
The Chapter 11 Case Driving Everything Else
The Academy at Penguin Hall filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the Massachusetts Bankruptcy Court on June 11, 2025, two days before telling families the school was closing. The filing listed estimated assets and liabilities each in the $10 million to $50 million range, and reporting put the total debt at roughly $26 million.1PACER Monitor. The Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc. – Case 1:25-bk-111912Boston.com. A Girls’ Catholic School in Wenham Filed a $26 Million Bankruptcy
The case sits before Judge Christopher J. Panos, with the U.S. Trustee’s office overseeing the proceedings. The automatic stay triggered by the filing is what has paused or redirected most other claims against the school, including the co-founder’s state court case and any effort by creditors to seize the Wenham estate outside the bankruptcy.
The schedules disclosed a long creditor list. The largest single claim was $5 million from Martins Construction Co., which is owned by board member Albert C. Martins — the husband of school president and board chair Mary B. “Molly” Martins. Other creditors included National Grid (more than $300,000), the IRS ($187,922 in unpaid federal payroll taxes already secured by a 2023 lien), and about two dozen outstanding loans. Faculty and staff were owed more than $250,000 in retirement contributions that had been deducted from paychecks but allegedly never deposited, plus unpaid wages for the final six weeks of the school year. Families collectively lost roughly $500,000 in prepaid tuition for the 2025–2026 year.2Boston.com. A Girls’ Catholic School in Wenham Filed a $26 Million Bankruptcy
Tsouvalas v. Academy at Penguin Hall
The first lawsuit against the school predated the closure. On September 25, 2024, co-founder Dean Tsouvalas filed a general torts complaint in Essex County Superior Court naming the Academy, Albert C. Martins, and Mary B. Martins. The civil action cover sheet described the claims as “tortious actions, unpaid wages and retirement” and “unjust enrichment,” with documented damages of $75,465.35.3Trellis Law. Tsouvalas, Dean vs. Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc. – Civil Action Cover Sheet
Tsouvalas sought a real estate attachment on school property, which the court denied in December 2024, citing “disputed questions of fact.” A related Chapter 93A consumer protection complaint was sent to the Attorney General in November 2024. Once the bankruptcy was filed, the Academy was marked “Inactive” as a defendant under a Suggestion of Bankruptcy. A May 2026 status report confirmed the bankruptcy was still ongoing, and the case remained on the docket as of June 2026.4Trellis Law. Tsouvalas, Dean vs. Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc. et al.
Al-Khalili v. Academy at Penguin Hall
Former teacher Reya Al-Khalili filed an adversary proceeding in the Massachusetts Bankruptcy Court on September 3, 2025, naming the Academy, Albert C. Martins, and Mary B. Martins. The complaint sought to prevent certain debts from being discharged, alleging false pretenses and actual fraud, fraud by a fiduciary, embezzlement, larceny, and willful and malicious injury. It also objected to the school’s bankruptcy discharge outright. In public comments to NBC Boston, Al-Khalili called the school’s conduct “embezzlement” and “criminal activity.”5NBC Boston. Mass. School’s Abrupt Closure Has Families, Staff in Limbo
Judge Panos dismissed the adversary proceeding without prejudice on October 23, 2025. Motions to dismiss filed separately by each of the Martinses were then declared moot, and the case was formally terminated on November 13, 2025.6PACER Monitor. Al-Khalili v. The Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc. et al. – Case 1:25-ap-01141 A dismissal without prejudice leaves the door open to refile.
Parent Claims and the Attorney General Complaint
Families whose tuition went unreturned have also pursued action. Reporting described lawsuits filed by parents over the lost tuition, though specific case numbers and plaintiffs beyond those identified above were not detailed in available records.2Boston.com. A Girls’ Catholic School in Wenham Filed a $26 Million Bankruptcy Parents also reported that monthly tuition payments were automatically debited from their accounts even after the closure was announced.
On July 11, 2025, parent Deena Flaherty filed a consumer complaint with the office of Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, alleging fraud tied to the $500,000 in collected tuition. As of September 2025, a spokesperson for the Attorney General’s office declined to confirm or deny an active investigation.
The AG’s office had already been involved with the school before the closure. Assistant Attorney General Hanne Rush confirmed to the Salem News in early 2024 that an “open investigation” existed regarding complaints filed against the school, though investigatory materials were withheld.7Salem News. AG’s Office Investigating Private All-Girls High School The Non-Profit Organizations/Public Charities Division had visited the school in December 2023 after it failed to file its annual financial audit; the school later provided the records and had its certificate of solicitation renewed.
In an email cited by the Boston Globe, Molly Martins said the board did not intend to “betray or defraud anyone,” and attributed the collapse in part to a bank selling the school’s mortgage to a development company and to the withdrawal of a pledged $2 million gift after negative publicity.
Fiji Funding v. Academy at Penguin Hall
A separate action predates the closure and is already past judgment. In April 2023, the school entered a merchant cash advance agreement with Fiji Funding, selling $721,645 in future receivables for $505,000 upfront. Fiji Funding alleged that in January 2024 the school blocked daily payment withdrawals, leaving $685,867.50 outstanding, and sued the Academy, Martins Construction, and Mary B. Martins as guarantor in New York state court.
In August 2024, Judge Leon Ruchelsman granted summary judgment to Fiji Funding, rejecting the defense that the arrangement was a usurious loan. The court ordered a further hearing to resolve the exact outstanding balance.8NY Courts. Fiji Funding v. The Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc.
The Campus Property Fight
Recovery for most claimants depends on what happens to the 48-acre estate at 36 Essex Street in Wenham, which the school bought in 2016 for about $10.3 million. A public auction originally scheduled for June 11, 2025, was postponed by the bankruptcy filing. A rescheduled auction in mid-September 2025 through Paul E. Saperstein Co. was likewise postponed.
As of June 2026, the property is the subject of competing motions in bankruptcy court. Creditor Origen Wenham LLC has moved for relief from the automatic stay, while the school has filed an expedited motion to sell the property free and clear of liens under Section 363(f) of the Bankruptcy Code. Both sides filed competing appraisal reports in June 2026, and the court has issued orders related to both motions. No final sale price or buyer has been publicly identified.1PACER Monitor. The Academy at Penguin Hall, Inc. – Case 1:25-bk-11191
Molly Martins and Al Martins had not responded to media requests for comment as of NBC Boston’s September 2025 reporting.5NBC Boston. Mass. School’s Abrupt Closure Has Families, Staff in Limbo