403(b) Investment Options: Annuity Contracts and Mutual Funds

A 403(b) plan routes your retirement savings into one of three federally authorized investment vehicles: annuity contracts purchased through insurance companies, custodial accounts that hold mutual funds, or retirement income accounts maintained by churches. These are the only 403(b) investment options the Internal Revenue Code recognizes, and the vehicle your plan uses shapes what you can actually hold, what you pay in fees, and how easily you can move your money later.1Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Plans FAQs Regarding 403(b) Tax-Sheltered Annuity Plans Employees of public schools, Section 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organizations, and churches are eligible to participate.

Many plans offer only one vehicle; some offer a choice. Knowing what each one is, and what it costs, is the point of this article.

Annuity Contracts Under 403(b)(1)

The oldest 403(b) vehicle is the annuity contract. An insurance company accepts your contributions and promises future payments. Federal law requires these contracts to be non-transferable, so you cannot sell or assign the contract to someone else.2eCFR. 26 CFR 1.401-9 – Nontransferable Annuity Contracts You can hold the annuity through an individual contract issued directly to you or through a group contract where your employer holds the master agreement. Your rights to the contract’s value are nonforfeitable once contributions are made, aside from the obligation to pay future premiums.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 403 – Taxation of Employee Annuities

Fixed and Variable Annuities

Fixed annuities pay a guaranteed interest rate for a set period. Your account grows on a predictable path with no exposure to market swings. Variable annuities work differently: you allocate your premiums among sub-accounts that invest in underlying securities, so the account value moves with the markets. Fixed means stability at the cost of lower long-term growth potential. Variable means market participation at the cost of investment risk.

Variable annuities carry mortality and expense risk charges that typically run about 1.25% of account value per year. These charges cover the insurer’s guarantee obligations and administrative costs, and they stack on top of the fees charged by the underlying sub-accounts. You’ll find them laid out in the contract prospectus. Over decades, this compounds. A 403(b) annuity with total annual costs of 2% or more will meaningfully lag a lower-cost custodial account holding the same investments.

Surrender Charges

Most annuity contracts impose a surrender charge if you withdraw funds or move to a different provider during the first several years. These charges typically start at 5% to 7% in year one and decline by roughly one percentage point each year, usually disappearing after six to eight years. Many contracts include a free withdrawal provision allowing you to take out about 10% of your account value each year without triggering the charge. Surrender charges are generally waived for required minimum distributions and death benefits.

This penalty structure is one of the sharpest differences between annuity contracts and custodial accounts. If your employer later switches plan providers, you may find your existing annuity locked up unless you accept the charge.

Custodial Accounts and Mutual Funds Under 403(b)(7)

A 403(b)(7) custodial account skips the insurance company entirely. A qualified custodian holds mutual fund shares directly on your behalf. The custodian must be a bank or an entity that has received specific IRS approval to serve in that role.4Internal Revenue Service. 403(b) Investment Options: Annuity Contracts, Custodial Accounts, and Mutual Funds Assets in the custodial account must remain segregated from your employer’s own assets, which protects your savings if the employer faces bankruptcy or legal claims.

Federal law restricts 403(b)(7) custodial accounts to investing exclusively in regulated investment company stock, which is the legal term for open-end mutual funds.4Internal Revenue Service. 403(b) Investment Options: Annuity Contracts, Custodial Accounts, and Mutual Funds Individual stocks, bonds, ETFs, and real estate investment trusts are off the table. In practice this is less limiting than it sounds, because the mutual fund menu inside a 403(b) typically covers equity funds, bond funds, money market funds, and target-date funds.

Types of Mutual Funds Available

Equity funds hold diversified portfolios of domestic and international stocks and aim at long-term growth through price appreciation and reinvested dividends. Bond funds invest in corporate or government debt and generate income through interest payments; they’re commonly grouped by average maturity, with short-term funds carrying less interest-rate risk than long-term ones. Money market funds hold very short-term, high-quality debt and prioritize preserving principal over generating returns.

Expense ratios vary widely. Broad-market index funds can charge as little as 0.03% to 0.05% annually. Actively managed funds often charge 0.50% to 1.00% or more. Every purchase of fund shares happens at the price calculated at the end of the trading day, so all participants buying in on the same day get the same price.

Target-Date Funds

Target-date funds have become the default investment in most retirement plans. The fund holds a mix of stocks and bonds that automatically shifts toward a more conservative allocation as you approach your selected retirement year. A 2050 fund, for example, starts heavily weighted toward stocks and gradually increases its bond allocation over the next 25 years. If you don’t actively choose investments, your plan will likely place your contributions in a target-date fund aligned with your expected retirement age. Federal regulations recognize target-date funds as a qualified default investment alternative for participant-directed plans.5U.S. Department of Labor. Default Investment Alternatives Under Participant Directed Individual Account Plans

Retirement Income Accounts for Church Employees

Section 403(b)(9) creates a third vehicle, the retirement income account, available only to churches, conventions of churches, and associations of churches. These accounts cover employees of the church itself along with those working in church-operated schools, hospitals, and related organizations.6Legal Information Institute. 26 USC 403(b)(9) – Retirement Income Accounts Provided by Churches Unlike the other two vehicles, retirement income accounts are not limited to annuity contracts or mutual funds. They can invest in a broader range of assets, giving church plan administrators more flexibility in building investment menus.

Church plans also operate under different vesting rules for employer contributions. Where most 403(b) plans require relatively quick vesting of employer money, a non-electing church plan can use a cliff vesting schedule as long as 15 years or a graded schedule spanning up to 20 years. Employee contributions always vest immediately regardless of the schedule, and full vesting is required if the plan terminates. If you work for a church-affiliated organization, your plan’s vesting schedule is worth checking, especially if you might leave before reaching the 15-year mark.

Comparing the Vehicles

When a plan offers more than one vehicle, the practical differences come down to three things: what you can own, what you pay, and how portable the money is.

Annuity contracts give you access to insurance guarantees (fixed interest rates, income riders, death benefits) that mutual funds don’t offer. The cost is layered fees, often around 1.25% in mortality and expense charges on variable contracts plus the fees of the underlying sub-accounts, and the possibility of a surrender charge if you want out early. Custodial mutual fund accounts generally cost less because there’s no insurance company in the middle, but you give up the guarantees and you’re limited to open-end mutual funds. Church retirement income accounts allow the widest investment menu, but only church employers can offer them.

If your plan uses an annuity provider, ask for the contract prospectus and look for two numbers: the mortality and expense risk charge, and the surrender charge schedule. Those two figures tell you most of what you need to know about the real cost of staying and the real cost of leaving.

Roth and Pre-Tax Contributions

The vehicle question is separate from the tax question. Whichever investment vehicle your plan uses, many 403(b) plans now offer a designated Roth contribution option alongside traditional pre-tax contributions, and the choice between them changes when you pay taxes on your savings. Traditional pre-tax deferrals reduce your taxable income today, but every dollar you withdraw in retirement is taxed as ordinary income. Designated Roth contributions are made with after-tax money, but qualified distributions in retirement come out tax-free, including all investment earnings.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 402A – Optional Treatment of Elective Deferrals as Roth Contributions

The same annual deferral limits apply either way, and you can split your contributions between the two. Your plan must maintain separate accounts for Roth contributions and track them independently.8Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Topics – Designated Roth Account Employer matching contributions cannot be deposited into your Roth account; they always go into a separate pre-tax account, even if the match was calculated based on your Roth deferrals. Once you designate a contribution as Roth, you cannot later reclassify it as pre-tax.