401(k) Fee Benchmarking: Disclosures, Peer Review, and Documentation

Benchmarking the fees in your 401(k) plan means collecting every service provider’s written fee disclosures, comparing your plan’s total costs against similarly sized plans, and keeping records that show how you reached your conclusions. That process is how a plan sponsor satisfies the ERISA requirement to pay no more than reasonable expenses, and it is the single best defense against fiduciary-breach claims brought by participants or the Department of Labor.

Why the Duty to Benchmark Exists

Two provisions of ERISA put fee reasonableness on your shoulders. Section 404(a) requires fiduciaries to act with the care and prudence of a knowledgeable person in the same role and to pay only “reasonable expenses of administering the plan.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1104 – Fiduciary Duties Section 408(b)(2) then exempts service contracts from ERISA’s prohibited transaction rules, but only if “no more than reasonable compensation” changes hands.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1108 – Exemptions From Prohibited Transactions You cannot know whether your fees are reasonable without comparing them to what other plans pay for similar services. That comparison is benchmarking.

The duty attaches to whoever actually makes the decisions. ERISA defines a fiduciary functionally: anyone exercising discretion over plan management, controlling plan assets, or administering the plan is a fiduciary, title or no title.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 U.S. Code 1002 – Definitions For most small and mid-sized employers, that is the business owner, the HR director who selected the recordkeeper, and anyone sitting on a retirement plan committee. You can hire an advisor or consultant to run the benchmark; you cannot hand off the underlying obligation.

Step 1: Gather the Fee Disclosures

You cannot compare anything until you have a complete picture of what the plan is paying. Two sets of disclosures are the foundation.

Service Provider Disclosures Under 408(b)(2)

Covered service providers must give you detailed written disclosures of their compensation before entering into or renewing a contract. The disclosures must identify every form of direct compensation the provider receives from the plan and every form of indirect compensation received from outside sources in connection with plan services.4eCFR. 29 CFR 2550.408b-2 – General Statutory Exemption for Services or Office Space Indirect compensation covers revenue sharing from mutual fund companies, 12b-1 fees, sub-transfer agent fees, and commissions. For each indirect payment, the provider identifies who pays it, what services trigger it, and the arrangement behind it.

Compensation may be expressed as a dollar amount, a formula, a percentage of assets, or a per-participant charge, with a reasonable good-faith estimate allowed only when none of those formats fits and the methodology is explained.4eCFR. 29 CFR 2550.408b-2 – General Statutory Exemption for Services or Office Space This is where many plans miss money. Revenue sharing and sub-transfer agent fees reduce participant returns but never appear on an invoice. Pull them from the 408(b)(2) disclosure and add them to the total.

Participant Disclosures Under 404a-5

A separate regulation requires the plan administrator to give participants annual fee information plus quarterly statements showing the actual dollar amounts deducted from their accounts and the services those charges paid for.5eCFR. 29 CFR 2550.404a-5 – Fiduciary Requirements for Disclosure These quarterly statements show what participants actually pay, which can differ from what the 408(b)(2) disclosure suggests. If participants are being charged administrative fees while the investment lineup also generates revenue sharing to the recordkeeper, you may be paying twice for the same service.

Step 2: Build the Cost Inventory

With both sets of disclosures in hand, assemble the data points a meaningful comparison requires:

  • Total plan assets. A $50 million plan has far more negotiating leverage than a $5 million plan, and benchmark data is segmented by asset size.
  • Total participants with balances. Recordkeeping fees are often quoted per head.
  • Recordkeeping and administration fees, isolated from investment costs. These may be a flat per-participant charge, an asset-based percentage, or a mix.
  • Investment expense ratios for every fund in the lineup, including any revenue sharing embedded in them.
  • Advisory fees, broken out separately from recordkeeping.
  • Indirect compensation flowing from fund companies to the recordkeeper.

Average account balance matters too. Plans with higher averages often qualify for lower-cost institutional share classes unavailable to smaller plans, so this figure tells you whether your lineup is using the cheapest share class your plan can access.

Step 3: Compare Against a Real Peer Group

Comparing a 50-employee plan with $3 million in assets against a Fortune 500 plan tells you nothing useful. Effective benchmarking matches your plan against others with similar asset levels and participant counts.

Benchmarking Reports

Several independent firms and industry databases publish reports that rank plan costs by percentile against a peer group. Top quartile means you pay more than 75% of comparable plans; bottom quartile means you are among the cheapest. Reports from recognized industry sources carry more weight in litigation than a comparison you cobbled together yourself. For scale, industry data shows a $5 million plan averages roughly 1.08% of assets in total costs, while a $50 million plan averages around 0.76%.

Requests for Proposal

The most rigorous approach is a Request for Proposal or Request for Information inviting other recordkeepers, advisors, or bundled providers to bid on your plan using your actual data. The bids are live market pricing, not historical averages. Even if you have no intention of leaving your current provider, an RFP generates powerful documentation that you tested the market.

If competing bids come in lower than what you pay now and you still want to stay, write down why. Maybe the incumbent’s service quality is measurably better, their technology reduces your administrative burden, or their participant education program outperforms what competitors offer. A fiduciary can justify paying more than the median when the reasoning is sound and recorded.

Step 4: Document the Reasoning, Not Just the Decision

Benchmarking that is not documented is benchmarking that did not happen, at least when a lawyer or investigator starts asking questions. ERISA Section 107 requires fiduciaries to keep records at least six years after the filing date of any report based on the information they contain.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1027 – Retention of Records Because the statute of limitations for fiduciary breach claims runs six years from the last breach-related action,7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1113 – Limitation of Actions treat six years as the floor.

Each benchmarking cycle’s file should contain the complete 408(b)(2) disclosures from every covered provider, the benchmarking reports and any RFP responses, signed committee meeting minutes, investment review documentation, and correspondence from any fee negotiations.

The meeting minutes are where plans either build or destroy their defense. “The committee reviewed the benchmarking report and decided to retain the current provider” is weak. “The committee reviewed the benchmarking report showing recordkeeping costs at the 40th percentile, discussed two lower-cost alternatives, and determined the current provider’s superior loan processing and participant website justified the $8 per-participant premium” gives an auditor or judge what they need to see. Record the reasoning, not just the conclusion.

How Often to Repeat the Process

ERISA sets no schedule. Industry practice has settled on a formal comparison at least every three years, with lighter monitoring in between. The three-year cycle tracks how fast recordkeeping prices move as plans grow and technology drives costs down. Waiting five years or more means paying outdated rates for an extended period, which is the pattern that produces litigation.

Between formal cycles, review each updated 408(b)(2) disclosure as it arrives and check the quarterly participant disclosures for unexpected charges. If the plan goes through a major event, such as a significant jump or drop in assets, a merger, or a large layoff, run a new benchmark regardless of where you are in the cycle. The plan you have now may not resemble the plan you last benchmarked, and your duty runs to the current plan.

If the Numbers Come Back High

Start with negotiation. Armed with benchmarking data and competing bids, go back to the current provider and show them the evidence. Many recordkeepers will cut fees or move your investments into cheaper share classes rather than lose the business. Document every conversation.

If negotiation fails and the overpayment is meaningful, switch. A completed RFP already gives you alternatives. Transitioning assets and participant records takes planning but is routine.

For past overpayments, the DOL’s Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program lets you fix the violation and avoid civil penalties. To correct excessive compensation under the VFCP, the plan must be made whole for the “principal amount,” meaning the difference between what was paid and the reasonable market value of the services, plus lost earnings or restoration of profits, whichever is greater. The application requires a written estimate of the reasonable market value of the services, the estimator’s qualifications, documentation of costs during the period at issue, and a signed statement under penalty of perjury.8Federal Register. Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program Catching the problem through your own benchmarking and correcting it voluntarily is far cheaper than defending a lawsuit or responding to an investigation after someone else raises it.

If a Service Provider Won’t Disclose

Occasionally a covered service provider fails to deliver the required 408(b)(2) disclosures. The regulation sets a specific procedure. Request the missing information in writing. If the provider does not comply within 90 days, notify the Department of Labor, including the plan’s name and number, the provider’s contact information, a description of the missing disclosures, and the date of your written request. Then decide whether to terminate the contract or continue it, consistent with your fiduciary duties.4eCFR. 29 CFR 2550.408b-2 – General Statutory Exemption for Services or Office Space Follow the procedure and you keep the prohibited-transaction exemption. Skip it and you lose the exemption even though the provider was the one who failed.

What Happens If You Skip Benchmarking

A fiduciary who never benchmarks faces liability from three directions at once.

  • Personal liability under ERISA Section 409. You must restore every loss the plan suffered from the overpayment, plus any profits made through the arrangement, and a court can remove you from the fiduciary role.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1109 – Liability for Breach of Fiduciary Duty
  • DOL civil penalties. When the Department recovers money through settlement or court order, it can assess an additional penalty of 20% of the recovery.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1132 – Civil Enforcement
  • Excise taxes on prohibited transactions. If the overpayment costs the arrangement its 408(b)(2) exemption, the disqualified person owes a 15% annual excise tax on the excess compensation, rising to 100% if the transaction is not corrected before assessment.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 4975 – Tax on Prohibited Transactions

Both the DOL and individual participants can bring enforcement actions.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1132 – Civil Enforcement Lawsuits alleging excessive fees are now one of the most active areas of ERISA litigation, and settlements for mid-to-large plans regularly reach seven and eight figures. Plans that can produce documentation of a thoughtful comparison process defend themselves successfully even when their fees were not the lowest available. Plans that cannot produce that documentation are the ones that settle.

One boundary worth noting: fee benchmarking does not cover everything you should evaluate when hiring a service provider. The DOL has published separate guidance on assessing a provider’s cybersecurity program, insurance coverage, and related safeguards,12U.S. Department of Labor. Tips for Hiring a Service Provider With Strong Cybersecurity Practices and those reviews run alongside the fee analysis rather than inside it. A provider with the lowest recordkeeping fee and no documented cybersecurity program is not a bargain.